# Can journalism be objective?

> Written with AI · [News and journalism](https://lessoons.com/en/news-and-journalism) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/news-and-journalism/can-journalism-be-objective

Complete objectivity in journalism is not possible, because every report involves choices: which events to cover, which words to use and whose voices to include. But objectivity as a working method is possible and valuable: checking facts, keeping news apart from opinion, reporting each side's claims fairly and showing the evidence. Critics add that false balance and hidden choices can still mislead.

## The topic explained

### What objectivity means in journalism

Objectivity in journalism does not mean that a reporter has no views. It means a way of working: checking facts before publishing, keeping news apart from opinion, saying who made each claim, and giving the sides of a dispute a fair hearing. The sociologist Michael Schudson, in Discovering the News (1978), described it as trust in facts, distrust of values and a commitment to keeping the two apart.

The idea grew in the early twentieth century, when the writer Walter Lippmann called on journalists to adopt something like a scientific method. In The Elements of Journalism (2001), Bill Kovach and Tom Rosenstiel argued that objectivity was always meant to describe the method, a discipline of verification, not the journalist. The common mistake is to treat objective and neutral-sounding as the same thing: a calm tone can carry an unchecked claim.

### The routines, and Tuchman's critique

In practice objectivity is a set of routines: report each side's claim, bring supporting evidence, put claims in quotation marks so they belong to the speaker, and label opinion as opinion. The sociologist Gaye Tuchman studied a newsroom and in 1972 called these routines a strategic ritual: they protect reporters from criticism and lawsuits, because a reporter can always show that the procedures were followed.

Her point was not that the routines are useless, but that following them does not guarantee the truth. Two quoted sides can both be wrong, and a fact placed in the last paragraph can change the meaning of the whole report.

### Where the choices come in

Between an event and a report there are choices. Selection: in David Manning White's 1950 study, one wire editor rejected about nine in ten of the incoming stories, some for personal reasons. Wording: a made-up headline that says a parking fee soars and one that says it rises 10% report the same fact in different tones. Framing: the angle, the photo and the order of the facts shape how the story is understood.

There is also false balance: giving equal space to positions that do not have equal evidence. If a made-up debate show gives a scientific consensus and a fringe claim five minutes each, viewers may think experts are split down the middle. The press critic Jay Rosen calls the pose of standing above all sides the view from nowhere, and argues that being open about one's methods earns more trust.

### Who holds journalists to the standard in Israel

The debate itself has two main sides. Defenders of objectivity say that without a shared method of checking, news becomes one more opinion and the public loses a common set of facts. Critics answer that hiding the choices behind a neutral tone is less honest than stating them, and that transparency about sources and methods serves readers better. Both sides agree that facts must be checked.

In Israel, the Israel Press Council (“מועצת העיתונות”), founded in 1963, brings together the public (40% of its members), journalists and editors and publishers (30% each). Its ethics code sets rules on accuracy and fairness, and its ethics court hears complaints and can issue a warning, a reprimand or an order to publish an apology. On the exam, a strong answer neither says that objectivity is a myth nor that it is guaranteed: it shows the method, then one limit, with an example.

## Practice: objectivity in journalism

For 10th grade students of communications. All headlines and cases on the sheet are made up for practice. Answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fact or opinion? (a) The parking fee rose from 10 to 11 shekels. (b) The new fee is unfair to residents. (c) The council approved the fee by 7 votes to 4.** — (a) Fact: it can be checked against the price list. (b) Opinion: a judgment, which belongs to a quoted speaker or an opinion column. (c) Fact: it can be checked against the council's record.
2. **Name two routines of objective reporting and say what each one does.** — For example: quoting each side, so the reader hears every claim from its source; and bringing evidence, such as figures and documents, so claims can be checked. Labelling opinion as opinion and keeping it apart from the news is also correct.
3. **Write a neutral version of the third made-up headline, and explain what makes the first two loaded.** — For example: Player scores 25 points in comeback game (any version with a checkable fact and no praise word). Soars and chaos are judgments that add feeling; the neutral versions give the size of the change instead.
4. **What did Gaye Tuchman mean in 1972 by calling objectivity a strategic ritual?** — That journalists follow fixed routines (quoting both sides, evidence, quotation marks) largely to protect themselves from criticism and lawsuits, and that following the routines does not by itself guarantee a true report.
5. **The made-up debate show gives the consensus and the fringe claim equal airtime. What is this called, and what impression does it give viewers?** — False balance. Equal time suggests that experts are evenly split, although 99 in 100 hold one view; a fair report would make the weight of evidence clear.
6. **Which Israeli body hears complaints about journalists' ethics, who sits on it, and what can its ethics court do?** — The Israel Press Council, founded in 1963: 40% public representatives, 30% journalists and 30% editors and publishers. Its ethics court hears complaints and can issue a warning, a reprimand or an order to publish an apology.
7. **Can journalism be objective? Write a paragraph that takes a position, uses two terms from the lesson and gives an example.** — A good answer takes a clear position (for example: objectivity as a method is possible, as a total absence of choices it is not); uses two terms such as selection, framing, strategic ritual or false balance; and gives an example, such as the same fee reported as soaring or as rising 10%.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between objectivity and balance?

Objectivity is the whole method: checking facts, separating news from opinion and showing evidence. Balance is one part of it, giving each side a hearing. Balance without judgment of the evidence can become false balance, when weak claims get the same space as strong ones.

### What is false balance in journalism?

False balance is presenting two positions as equally supported when the evidence is not equal, for example giving a fringe claim the same time as a broad scientific consensus. It looks fair but misleads the audience about the state of knowledge.

### Is it wrong for journalists to have opinions?

No. Every journalist has views; the standard is about the work. News reports keep opinions out and attribute every claim, while opinion columns and editorials are labelled as opinion so the reader knows what kind of text it is.

### How can I tell if a news report is biased?

Look at the choices: which facts lead and which are buried, which words carry feeling, whose voices are quoted and whose are missing, and what the headline and photo suggest. Then compare with another outlet's report of the same event.

### What is the Israel Press Council?

A body founded in 1963 that sets an ethics code for Israeli journalism and runs an ethics court. Public representatives make up 40% of its members, and journalists and editors and publishers 30% each.
