# What is the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: motivation and emotion](https://lessoons.com/en/motivation-and-emotion) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/motivation-and-emotion/what-is-the-difference-between-intrinsic-and-extrinsic-motivation

Intrinsic motivation is doing something for its own sake, because it is interesting or enjoyable; extrinsic motivation is doing it for what it brings, such as a reward, a grade or avoiding punishment. The difference matters because a reward promised for an activity people already enjoy can lower their later interest in it, while praise and choice tend to strengthen it.

## The topic explained

### Two reasons to do the same thing

Intrinsic motivation is doing an activity for its own sake: a student who plays the guitar because she loves the sound, or solves a puzzle because it is satisfying. Extrinsic motivation is doing it for an outcome outside the activity: practicing for a grade, working for pay, or studying to avoid detention. The same behavior can come from either, and often from both at once, so the difference lies in the reason, not in what the person is seen to do.

The common misreading is that intrinsic is good and extrinsic is bad. Much of life runs on extrinsic motivation, and for a dull task, such as filing forms, there is little intrinsic interest to lose. The real question psychologists ask is narrower: what happens to intrinsic interest when someone starts to be paid or rewarded for an activity they already enjoy?

### The marker study: when a prize backfires

Mark Lepper, David Greene and Richard Nisbett (1973) worked at Bing Nursery School at Stanford University with preschool children who already chose to draw with felt-tip markers in free play. The children were assigned by chance to three conditions. In the expected award condition they agreed to draw in order to win a Good Player Award, a certificate with a gold seal and a ribbon. In the unexpected award condition they drew and then got the certificate as a surprise. In the no award condition they drew and got nothing.

One to two weeks later the markers were put out again in the classroom, with no award on offer, and observers behind a one-way mirror recorded how long each child drew. The expected-award children spent 8.59 percent of their free play with the markers, about half the 16.73 percent of the no-award children, while the unexpected-award group did not differ from the no-award group. The authors called it the overjustification effect: a child who drew in order to get a prize comes to see drawing as something done for a prize. A few years earlier Edward Deci (1971) had found the same pattern with college students paid one dollar for each puzzle they solved.

### Do rewards always kill interest?

No, and the details are argued over. Deci, Koestner and Ryan (1999) combined 128 experiments. Tangible rewards lowered later free-choice interest, most clearly when they were promised in advance, while praise and positive feedback raised it, more clearly in college students than in children. Feedback given in a controlling way lowered interest too. Judy Cameron and David Pierce (1994) had concluded from their own meta-analysis that, overall, rewards do not reduce intrinsic motivation, and in 2001 Cameron and colleagues argued that rewards for low-interest tasks can raise it.

Both sides agree on more than the headlines suggest: the harm appears for tangible rewards, announced beforehand, for tasks people already find interesting, and it is weak or absent for dull tasks and for unexpected rewards.

### Self-determination theory

Deci and Richard Ryan built these findings into self-determination theory. People have three psychological needs: autonomy, the sense of choosing what you do; competence, the sense of getting better at it; and relatedness, feeling connected to others. A reward that feels like control undermines autonomy, while informative praise supports competence. The theory also says that extrinsic motivation can be internalized: a student who studies chemistry because she values becoming a doctor is extrinsically motivated, yet the reason is her own. A good exam answer defines both kinds, describes the marker study with its numbers, and adds the conditions under which rewards help or harm.

## Practice: intrinsic and extrinsic motivation

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write intrinsic or extrinsic for each case.** — Reads novels in the holidays: intrinsic. Works extra shifts for pay: extrinsic. Solves puzzles for fun: intrinsic. Studies to avoid detention: extrinsic.
2. **Fill in the last step of the marker study: what did the observers measure?** — How much of their free play each child spent drawing with the markers, watched through a one-way mirror, with no award on offer.
3. **Name the three conditions of the marker study and say what happened in each.** — Expected award: children drew in order to win a certificate. Unexpected award: they drew and then got the certificate as a surprise. No award: they drew and got nothing.
4. **Read the chart. By about how much did the expected award reduce later drawing, compared with no award?** — By about half: 8.59 percent of free play against 16.73 percent (8.59 ÷ 16.73 ≈ 0.51).
5. **Why did the unexpected award not lower interest, while the expected one did?** — A surprise award came after the drawing and could not be the reason for drawing. Children who drew in order to get the award came to see drawing as done for a prize, the overjustification effect.
6. **A coach wants players to keep loving the game. Use the three needs of self-determination theory to give her one piece of advice for each.** — Autonomy: let players choose some drills or positions. Competence: give specific feedback on how they improved. Relatedness: build team ties and warmth. A good answer links each piece of advice to its need.
7. **A school plans to pay pupils ₪5 for every book they read. Evaluate the plan using the research.** — A good answer says that for pupils who already enjoy reading, a promised tangible reward may lower their later interest (Lepper et al. 1973; Deci, Koestner and Ryan 1999), while for reluctant readers a reward may get reading started (Cameron and colleagues). It suggests safer options, such as praise that gives information, free choice of books and unexpected recognition, and concludes that the effect depends on the pupil and the reward.

## Common questions

### What is the overjustification effect?

It is the drop in intrinsic interest that can follow an expected reward for an activity people already enjoy. Having an outside reason, the reward, people come to see the activity as something done for the reward, so they do less of it once the reward stops.

### Is praise a reward that harms motivation?

Usually not. In the 1999 meta-analysis praise and positive feedback raised later interest on average, more clearly in college students than in children. Praise given to control, such as "good, you did what you should", lowered interest; praise that tells people what they did well raised it.

### Can extrinsic motivation become intrinsic?

Not exactly, but self-determination theory says it can be internalized. A person who starts studying for a grade may come to value what the study leads to, so the reason becomes their own. Self-chosen extrinsic reasons behave much like intrinsic ones.

### Are grades extrinsic motivation?

Yes, a grade is an outcome outside the learning itself. Grades also carry information about progress, which can support a sense of competence. Whether they help or harm depends on whether students experience them as feedback or as pressure.

### What is an example of intrinsic motivation for a student?

Reading about the brain after class because the topic is fascinating, or practicing a language to understand songs, with no test in sight. The activity itself is the reward, so it continues when nobody is checking.
