# What are the theories of emotion?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: motivation and emotion](https://lessoons.com/en/motivation-and-emotion) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/motivation-and-emotion/what-are-the-theories-of-emotion

The three classic theories of emotion disagree about order. James and Lange said the body reacts first and the feeling is our sense of that reaction. Cannon and Bard said the brain produces the bodily reaction and the feeling at the same time. Schachter and Singer said emotion needs both arousal and a label, taken from the situation, that explains it.

## The topic explained

### The body first: James and Lange

The theories of emotion begin with a question about order. Common sense says you see a bear, feel afraid and then run. In 1884 the American psychologist William James turned this round, and the Danish physician Carl Lange reached a similar view on his own in 1885. On the James–Lange theory the event triggers bodily changes first, a racing heart, trembling, running, and the emotion is our awareness of those changes. James put it in one line: “we feel sorry because we cry, angry because we strike, afraid because we tremble.”

The usual misreading is that James denied feelings. He did not; he said a feeling is the experience of the body's reaction, so that without the reaction the emotion would be a cold judgment. The theory explains why emotions are felt so physically, and predicts that each emotion should have its own bodily pattern.

### Body and feeling together: Cannon and Bard

The Harvard physiologist Walter Cannon answered in 1927 with objections from his laboratory, later developed with his student Philip Bard. The same bodily arousal comes with very different emotions, fear and anger alike, and even with fever. The internal organs react too slowly, seconds after we already feel something. Cats whose internal organs had been cut off from the nervous system still showed rage. And an injection of adrenaline produces arousal without any particular emotion.

On the Cannon–Bard theory the event reaches the thalamus, a relay station deep in the brain, which sends signals at the same time to the body and to the cortex, where the feeling arises. Arousal and feeling run in parallel; neither causes the other. Later research showed that the thalamus is not the only center, since structures such as the amygdala and the hypothalamus take part, but the idea of parallel pathways remained.

### Arousal plus a label: Schachter and Singer

Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer (1962) proposed the two-factor theory: emotion needs physiological arousal and a cognitive label that explains it. To test it they told participants they were getting an injection of “Suproxin” to study its effect on eyesight. In fact most got epinephrine (adrenaline), which raises the heart rate, and some a placebo. Some were told the true side effects (informed), some nothing (ignorant), some false effects (misinformed). Each then waited with a confederate who acted either euphoric or angry, while observers behind a one-way mirror rated them.

With the euphoric confederate the misinformed group was rated most euphoric, then the ignorant, the placebo and the informed group; with the angry confederate the ignorant group was angriest. Those with an unexplained arousal took the label from the room; those who knew the cause did not. Dutton and Aron (1974) later found that men who met a woman on a frightening suspension bridge called her afterwards more often than men on a stable bridge, which fits arousal being misread as attraction.

### How strong is the evidence, and was it ethical?

The 1962 effects were modest, and replications failed. Marshall and Zimbardo (1979) found that the euphoric confederate had little effect and that epinephrine did not make people more open to it, and Maslach (1979) found that unexplained arousal felt negative whatever the confederate did. Ethically the study deceived participants about what was injected, so they could not give informed consent, and set out to make some of them angry. A strong answer gives each theory's order, its best evidence and one weakness.

## Practice: theories of emotion

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fill in the missing middle step of each theory.** — James and Lange: the body reacts (heart races, trembling). Cannon and Bard: the thalamus sends signals to body and cortex at once. Schachter and Singer: a cause for the arousal is found in the situation.
2. **Complete James's sentence: we feel sorry because we ..., afraid because we ...** — We feel sorry because we cry, afraid because we tremble. The bodily reaction comes first and the feeling follows from it.
3. **Write what each of Cannon's objections means.** — Same arousal, many emotions: fear and anger feel different but the body reacts almost the same, so arousal cannot tell us which emotion we feel. The organs react slowly: we feel the emotion before the body has changed. Adrenaline alone: arousal from an injection gives no particular emotion.
4. **Write the result of each group with the euphoric confederate, from most to least euphoric.** — Misinformed: most. Ignorant: more. Placebo: less. Informed: least. The groups with unexplained arousal took their emotion from the confederate.
5. **Why was the informed group the least affected by the confederate?** — They had been told the true effects of the injection, so they already had an explanation for their racing heart and did not need to find one in the situation.
6. **A student's heart is pounding before a match. Explain her feeling with each of the three theories.** — James–Lange: she notices the pounding heart and that awareness is her excitement or fear. Cannon–Bard: the thalamus produced the pounding and the feeling together. Schachter–Singer: she is aroused and labels it excitement or fear from the situation, for instance from what her teammates say.
7. **Evaluate Schachter and Singer's study for its evidence and its ethics.** — A good answer says the study supported the idea that unexplained arousal takes a label from the situation, and that the bridge study fits it, but the effects were modest and Marshall and Zimbardo (1979) and Maslach (1979) failed to replicate them. Ethically participants were deceived about the injection and could not give informed consent, and some were made angry. It concludes that the theory is influential but its key study is weak evidence.

## Common questions

### What is the main difference between the James–Lange and Cannon–Bard theories?

The order. James and Lange say the bodily reaction comes first and causes the feeling. Cannon and Bard say the brain produces the bodily reaction and the feeling at the same time, so neither causes the other.

### What is the two-factor theory of emotion?

It is Schachter and Singer's theory that an emotion has two parts: physiological arousal and a cognitive label. The same arousal can become fear, anger or joy, depending on how the person explains it from the situation.

### What was Suproxin?

Suproxin did not exist. It was the cover story in Schachter and Singer's 1962 study: participants were told it was being tested for its effect on vision, while most were actually injected with epinephrine and the rest with a placebo.

### Which theory of emotion is right?

No single one of the three. Bodily feedback does color feelings, as James argued; the brain does run several pathways at once, as Cannon argued; and how we interpret a situation matters, as Schachter argued. Modern appraisal theories build on the last idea.

### What is misattribution of arousal?

It is explaining a bodily arousal by the wrong cause, for example reading a pounding heart from fear as attraction. Dutton and Aron's 1974 suspension bridge study is the best known example.
