# Are facial expressions of emotion universal?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: motivation and emotion](https://lessoons.com/en/motivation-and-emotion) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/motivation-and-emotion/are-facial-expressions-of-emotion-universal

Partly. Ekman and Friesen (1971) found that the Fore of New Guinea, cut off from Western media, matched faces to stories of emotion on 64 to 90 percent of trials, which supports a few universal facial expressions. Later studies showed that the method inflated agreement and that culture shapes both when emotions are shown and how faces are read.

## The topic explained

### Darwin's question

Do people everywhere show joy, fear and anger with the same face? Charles Darwin argued in The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals (1872) that facial expressions evolved, so they should be universal, shared by all humans. The opposite view, strong among anthropologists in the mid twentieth century, held that expressions are learned like words, so each culture has its own. The American psychologist Paul Ekman set out to test the question in the 1960s.

The common misreading is that universal means everyone feels the same things or shows them equally. The claim is narrower: a small set of basic emotions, in Ekman's list happiness, sadness, anger, fear, surprise and disgust, come with facial movements that people in any culture can recognize. How often and when people show them is a separate question.

### The study in New Guinea

Ekman and Wallace Friesen first showed photographs of posed faces to people in Japan, Brazil, Argentina, Chile and the United States, who matched them to emotion words at rates of 70 to 90 percent. But all of them watched films and magazines, so they could have learned the faces. The Fore of Papua New Guinea, a pre-industrial people with almost no contact with Western media, could not.

In the study published in 1971, a Fore listener heard a short story about an emotional event and chose which of three photographs showed the face of the person in the story; children chose between two. The Fore chose the expected face on 64 to 90 percent of trials, depending on the emotion, far above chance, and children did about as well as adults. They often confused fear with surprise. Ekman read this as strong evidence that the basic expressions do not depend on learning from the media.

### Same faces, different rules

Ekman did not claim that culture plays no part. He and Friesen described display rules, unwritten codes learned early in life about who may show which emotion, where and how strongly: smiling over a disappointing gift, hiding grief at work, exaggerating delight at a friend's news. Display rules explain why two cultures can share the same expressions and still look very different in daily life. Ekman and Friesen later built the Facial Action Coding System (1978), which describes any expression as a set of numbered muscle movements, and in the 1990s Ekman proposed adding further basic emotions, such as contempt, embarrassment and pride.

### The case against

James Russell (1994) argued that the method itself produced much of the agreement. In a forced choice test the labels or stories offered decide the possible answers, so people pick the best fit even when they would not name that emotion on their own; and the faces were posed, chosen by the researchers' own judgment, not caught in real life. Rachael Jack and colleagues (2012) had 15 Western and 15 East Asian participants label computer-generated faces. The Western participants' mental pictures formed six clear groups; the East Asian ones overlapped, especially for surprise, fear, disgust and anger, and relied more on the eyes. Lisa Feldman Barrett's theory of constructed emotion goes further: emotions are built by each brain from concepts learned in a culture.

A strong answer gives Ekman's evidence with its numbers, explains display rules, and weighs the method criticism, concluding that recognition across cultures is real but weaker and more culture-shaped than the strong universal claim.

## Practice: are facial expressions universal?

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Name the emotion each drawn face shows.** — From left to right: happiness, sadness, surprise, anger.
2. **List Ekman's six basic emotions.** — Happiness, sadness, anger, fear, surprise and disgust.
3. **Fill in the missing step of the Fore study.** — The listener picks the photograph that shows the face of the person in the story (children chose between two photographs).
4. **Why did Ekman go to the Fore, when people in five countries had already matched the faces?** — People in Japan, Brazil, Argentina, Chile and the United States watched films and magazines, so they could have learned the faces. The Fore had almost no contact with Western media, so matching by them could not be explained by that learning.
5. **The Fore chose the expected face on 64 to 90 percent of trials and often confused fear with surprise. Write one conclusion and one caution.** — Conclusion: recognition was far above chance in a people cut off from Western media, which supports some universal expressions. Caution: the rate was not perfect, varied by emotion, and the forced choice between a few photographs may have raised it.
6. **Write what each criticism says.** — Forced choice: the answers offered decide what people can say, so agreement is inflated. Posed faces: the photographs were posed and chosen by the researchers, not expressions caught in real life. Jack and others, 2012: East Asian participants' mental pictures of the six expressions overlapped, while Western ones formed six clear groups.
7. **Explain how display rules let expressions be universal and still differ between cultures.** — The facial movement for an emotion may be shared, but each culture teaches rules about when, where and how strongly to show it. So the same expression can be common in one culture's public life and hidden in another's, for example grief at a funeral or anger at work.
8. **Evaluate the claim: "Ekman proved that facial expressions are the same everywhere."** — A good answer says that Ekman's Fore study (64 to 90 percent matching) supports some shared expressions, but proved is too strong: forced choice and posed faces inflated agreement (Russell 1994), East Asian and Western participants picture the expressions differently (Jack and others 2012), and display rules change how emotions are shown. It concludes that recognition is partly universal and partly shaped by culture.

## Common questions

### What are the six basic emotions?

In Ekman's account they are happiness, sadness, anger, fear, surprise and disgust, the emotions tested with the Fore of New Guinea. In the 1990s Ekman suggested a longer list that also includes contempt, embarrassment, pride and others.

### What are display rules?

Display rules are unwritten norms, learned early in life, about which emotions may be shown, by whom, where and how strongly. They explain why people in different cultures may share expressions yet show them very differently in daily life.

### Who were the Fore?

The Fore are a people of Papua New Guinea. When Ekman and Friesen studied them they had almost no contact with Western films and magazines, so they could not have learned Western facial expressions from the media.

### What is the Facial Action Coding System?

It is a method, completed by Ekman and Friesen by 1978, that describes any facial expression as a combination of numbered muscle movements called action units. Researchers use it to code faces without guessing the emotion behind them.

### Can you tell what someone feels from their face?

Only roughly. A face gives clues, but the same movement can come with different feelings, people hide emotions by display rules, and culture shapes how faces are read. Context, words and knowing the person matter as much as the expression.
