# What is the difference between a fixed and a floating exchange rate?

> Written with AI · [Monetary policy, exchange rates and the economy](https://lessoons.com/en/monetary-policy) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/monetary-policy/what-is-the-difference-between-a-fixed-and-a-floating-exchange-rate

Under a floating exchange rate the price of foreign currency is set each day by supply and demand in the market. Under a fixed exchange rate the central bank promises a rate and buys or sells foreign currency from its reserves to hold it. A float lets the rate absorb shocks and leaves the central bank free to set interest rates; a peg gives certainty but ties its hands.

## The topic explained

### Who sets the price of a dollar

An exchange rate is the price of a foreign currency. The difference between a fixed and floating exchange rate is who sets it. Under a floating rate, the price is whatever clears the market: importers and investors abroad demand dollars, exporters and foreign investors supply them. Under a fixed rate, or peg, the central bank announces a rate and stands ready to trade at it. Between the two lie bands, in which the rate floats within limits.

Take the market for dollars (numbers made up for this page): demand Q = 30 - 5E and supply Q = 5E - 10, in billions of dollars a year, with E the shekels per dollar. Floating, the rate settles where 30 - 5E = 5E - 10: E = 4 shekels and 10 billion dollars.

### How a central bank holds a peg

Suppose the bank fixes the rate at ₪3.8. At that price buyers want 30 - 19 = 11 billion dollars but only 19 - 10 = 9 billion are offered. To hold the rate, the bank must sell the missing 2 billion dollars from its foreign exchange reserves each year. If it fixed the rate at ₪4.2 instead, 11 billion would be offered and 9 wanted, and the bank would have to buy 2 billion, paying with shekels it creates.

A peg below the market rate drains reserves, and if markets doubt the bank can keep paying, they sell the currency faster, until the peg breaks. A peg above the market rate builds reserves but pours new shekels into the economy, which can feed inflation.

### The trade-off, and Israel's path

Economists sum up the choice as the impossible trinity: a country cannot have a fixed rate, free movement of capital and its own interest rate policy all at once. A peg gives exporters and importers certainty and can import the low inflation of the anchor currency, but the central bank must set interest rates to defend the rate. A float lets the rate absorb shocks, falling when exports slump, and frees the interest rate to target inflation, at the cost of a rate that can swing.

Israel moved in stages from a peg to a float. From 1989 the shekel moved inside a band around a basket of currencies; from 1992 the band crawled, rising along a slope; in 1997 it was widened so far that the Bank of Israel stopped intervening; and on June 9, 2005 the band was abolished. The shekel floats, and since March 2008 the Bank has at times bought dollars, the subject of the next lesson.

### Common mistakes

Thinking a fixed rate cannot change: a government can devalue it, and markets often force it to. Thinking a floating rate means the central bank never acts: it can still buy or sell currency, as the Bank of Israel has. And reading the graph the wrong way: a higher number of shekels per dollar means a weaker shekel.

## Practice: fixed and floating exchange rates

For 12th grade economics students. Use the graph and the tables on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Define a floating and a fixed exchange rate in one sentence each.** — Floating: the rate is set by supply and demand in the foreign exchange market. Fixed: the central bank announces a rate and buys or sells foreign currency to hold it.
2. **Use the graph. What is the floating rate and the quantity of dollars traded?** — 30 - 5E = 5E - 10, so E = 4 shekels per dollar and Q = 10 billion dollars.
3. **Fill in the table for pegs of ₪3.6 and ₪4.5.** — ₪3.6: wanted 30 - 18 = 12, offered 18 - 10 = 8; the bank must sell 4 billion dollars. ₪4.5: wanted 30 - 22.5 = 7.5, offered 22.5 - 10 = 12.5; the bank must buy 5 billion dollars.
4. **Write in the table whether each feature belongs to a fixed or a floating rate.** — Exporters know the rate in advance: fixed. The rate falls in an export boom: floating (more dollars are supplied, so the shekel strengthens). Reserves can run out: fixed.
5. **What is the impossible trinity? Which part did Israel give up by floating the shekel?** — A country cannot have a fixed rate, free capital movement and an independent interest rate policy at once. By floating, Israel gave up the fixed rate and kept free capital movement and its own interest rate.
6. **Put Israel's regimes in order: a crawling band, the abolition of the band, a band around a basket, the end of intervention.** — A band around a basket (1989), a crawling band (1992), the end of intervention when the band was widened (1997), the abolition of the band (2005).
7. **Write a short paragraph: why can a peg set below the market rate end in a crisis?** — A good answer says that the bank must keep selling dollars from its reserves to meet the excess demand; as reserves fall, markets doubt the peg, sell the currency faster and demand even more dollars, until the bank gives up and the currency falls sharply.

## Common questions

### Does the shekel float?

Yes. The band against a basket of currencies was abolished on June 9, 2005, and the rate is set in the market. The Bank of Israel has at times bought foreign currency since March 2008, without committing to a rate.

### What is a currency peg?

A fixed exchange rate against one currency, such as the dollar, or a basket of currencies, held by the central bank's readiness to buy or sell at that rate.

### What is a devaluation?

A decision by a government or central bank to lower the official value of a fixed currency, so that each dollar costs more units of it. Under a float the same fall is called a depreciation.

### What is the impossible trinity?

The rule that a country can have at most two of three: a fixed exchange rate, free movement of capital, and an independent monetary policy. Every regime chooses which one to give up.

### How is this asked on the bagrut?

Students show on a graph of the foreign exchange market how a central bank holds a fixed rate, compute how much it must buy or sell, compare the two regimes, and describe Israel's path to a float.
