# What is A. D. Gordon's religion of labor?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Modern Thinkers](https://lessoons.com/en/modern-jewish-thinkers) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/modern-jewish-thinkers/a-d-gordon-religion-of-labor

The religion of labor is the name A. D. Gordon's contemporaries gave to his teaching. Gordon (1856–1922) held that physical work in nature, above all working the land of Israel, would heal a Jewish people cut off from nature for two thousand years and renew each person too: not labor for a living, but labor for the sake of life.

## The topic explained

### Labor for the sake of life

Aaron David Gordon was born in 1856 in Podolia and worked for more than twenty years as a clerk on the Ginzburg family's estate. In 1904, in his late forties, he came to the Land of Israel and became a hired farm hand, in Ein Ganim, Rishon LeZion, the Galilee and Degania, where he died in 1922. He wrote at night and became the spiritual guide of the Hapoel Hatzair movement. His contemporaries called his teaching the religion of labor; the name was theirs, not his.

In 1909, in The Dream and Its Meaning, he described what he found in the field: “לא עבודה לשם מחייה ולא עבודה לשם מצווה. כי אם עבודה לשם חיים” (not labor for a living and not labor as a commandment, but labor for the sake of life). A common mistake is to read Gordon as an economic plan or as socialism. For him labor is not a means of making a living; it is the way a person returns to living fully.

### A people torn from nature

In his essay Labor (“העבודה”, 1911) Gordon diagnosed the people's illness: “עם, אשר נקרע כולו מעל הטבע, אשר במשך אלפיים שנה היה כלוא בתוך החומות” (a people wholly torn from nature, which for two thousand years was shut up within walls). Such a people, he wrote, is used to every kind of life except a life of labor, and will not become a living people again without a great effort of will.

The cure is “עבודה, שהאדם קשור אליה קשר אורגני, טבעי” (labor to which a person is bound by an organic, natural tie), labor by which the people is bound to its land and to “a culture that grows from its soil and its labor”, in his words. Labor is not only a way to acquire land; a national culture grows from it. That is why Gordon opposed a model in which others would farm the land while Jews managed and wrote.

### Why religion: the person, nature and the cosmos

Gordon saw labor as a meeting between the person and all of existence. In his Letters to the Diaspora he wrote “העבודה חייבת לאפשר לאדם להכיר את הטבע הכרה קוסמית” (labor must let a person know nature with a cosmic awareness), and that its task is also to break down “the thick, narrow walls of city culture”. Cosmic awareness is a felt unity with nature and the world, something science alone does not give. Hence the word religion: not commandments and prayers, but reverence and belonging.

Gordon also rejected Marxist class struggle. In the essay Building a Nation he wrote “בניין אומה אינו בניין חברה” (building a nation is not building a society). Change, in his view, begins with each person's self-education, not with a war between classes.

### The person before the nation, and the critics

For all his stress on the nation, Gordon did not give up the individual: “את האדם אסור להקריב אפילו על מזבח האומה” (a person may not be sacrificed even on the altar of the nation). His ideas shaped cooperative settlement: he wrote founding rules for a workers' moshav, and the Gordonia youth movement, founded in Poland in 1925, set out to live by them.

His teaching has critics. Socialists in the labor movement saw history as class struggle; others argue that a modern economy cannot rest on everyone doing manual work, and that few Israelis do it today. A strong answer gives Gordon's idea in his own words, then the objection.

## Practice: A. D. Gordon's religion of labor

For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the quotations printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **When did Gordon come to the Land of Israel, and what work did he do there? Who gave his teaching the name religion of labor?** — He came in 1904 and worked as a hired farm hand. His contemporaries gave his teaching the name religion of labor; he did not coin it himself.
2. **In The Dream and Its Meaning (1909) Gordon writes “לא עבודה לשם מחייה ולא עבודה לשם מצווה. כי אם עבודה לשם חיים” (not labor for a living and not labor as a commandment, but labor for the sake of life). Which three kinds of labor are named, and which does Gordon choose?** — Labor for a living, labor as a religious duty and labor for the sake of life. Gordon chooses labor for the sake of life: work that is part of life itself.
3. **In his essay Labor (1911) Gordon writes “עם, אשר נקרע כולו מעל הטבע, אשר במשך אלפיים שנה היה כלוא בתוך החומות” (a people wholly torn from nature, which for two thousand years was shut up within walls). What illness does Gordon diagnose, and what cure does he offer?** — The people grew distant from nature and from manual work during two thousand years of exile. The cure is labor in nature, above all working the land of Israel, by the Jews themselves.
4. **Fill in the missing boxes in the path Gordon draws.** — Second box: farm labor, working the land. Fourth box: a new culture, a living culture growing from the soil and from labor.
5. **Fill in Gordon's column of the table.** — Who acts: the whole people. Labor is: a way of life. Change by: self-education.
6. **“העבודה חייבת לאפשר לאדם להכיר את הטבע הכרה קוסמית” (labor must let a person know nature with a cosmic awareness; Letters to the Diaspora). Explain why Gordon's teaching was called a religion, though it is not about commandments.** — Gordon gives labor an experience of unity with nature and all of existence, an attitude of reverence and belonging. That is a religious side even without commandments and prayer, which is why his contemporaries called it a religion of labor.
7. **“את האדם אסור להקריב אפילו על מזבח האומה” (a person may not be sacrificed even on the altar of the nation). What does this sentence show about the individual and the nation in Gordon's thought?** — The nation matters, but the person may not be given up for it. National revival has to heal the individual, not sacrifice him.
8. **Write a paragraph: is the religion of labor still relevant in Israel today? Give Gordon's claim, one quotation from this sheet, one objection and a reply.** — A good answer states the claim (labor in nature renews the person and the people), quotes for example labor for the sake of life, raises an objection (a modern economy does not rest on everyone's manual work) and replies, for example that the idea is about how we relate to work and nature, not only about farming.

## Common questions

### Was A. D. Gordon religious?

Gordon grew up in a traditional Jewish home, but his teaching is not a religion of commandments and prayer. He spoke of labor and nature in a language of holiness and unity with existence, which is why his contemporaries called it the religion of labor.

### How was Gordon different from the socialists?

Marxist socialism saw history as a struggle between classes. Gordon rejected that: for him building a nation is not building a society, and change begins with each person's self-education and labor, not with class war.

### What does labor for the sake of life mean?

Gordon distinguishes labor for a living, labor as a commandment and labor for the sake of life. In the first two, work is a means; in the third it is part of life itself, the way a person truly lives and connects with nature.

### How did Gordon influence settlement in Israel?

Gordon was the spiritual guide of the Hapoel Hatzair movement, wrote founding rules for a workers' moshav, and the Gordonia youth movement, founded in Poland in 1925, set out to live by his ideas and built kibbutzim.

### How is Gordon different from Ahad Ha'am?

Ahad Ha'am saw the Land of Israel as a spiritual center whose culture would renew the Jews abroad. Gordon started from below: from each person's manual work in the land, from which, in his view, culture grows.
