# What is information disorder?

> Written with AI · [Communications: misinformation and how to check it](https://lessoons.com/en/misinformation-and-verification) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/misinformation-and-verification/what-is-information-disorder

Information disorder is the name Claire Wardle and Hossein Derakhshan gave in a 2017 Council of Europe report to the polluted information world, in place of “fake news.” It has three kinds: misinformation (false, shared without meaning harm), disinformation (false, created to harm) and malinformation (true, used to harm). The framework also asks who made a message, what form it takes and how audiences read it.

## The topic explained

### Two questions, three kinds

In October 2017 the researchers Claire Wardle and Hossein Derakhshan published a report for the Council of Europe called “Information Disorder.” They argued that the phrase fake news was too vague and too often used as an insult, and offered a framework instead. It begins with two questions about any piece of content: is it false, and was it created or shared in order to harm? The answers give three kinds.

Misinformation is false, but not created to cause harm: a person who sincerely forwards a wrong health tip. Disinformation is false and deliberately created to harm a person, a group, an organization or a country: an invented story about a rival. Malinformation is based on reality but used to inflict harm: a genuine private message, address or medical detail leaked to shame someone. The third kind surprises students, because nothing in it is false; it shows that the problem is not only truth but also intent and harm. In Hebrew it is sometimes called “מידע זדוני” (malicious information).

### Agent, message, interpreter

The framework then looks at three elements. The agent is whoever creates, produces or spreads the content. Questions to ask: is it an official body or an individual, organized or alone, and what is the motive: money from clicks, political influence, belonging to a group, or the pleasure of causing trouble? The message is the content itself: is it text, an image, a video or a meme; is it meant to last or to vanish; does it impersonate a real source? The interpreter is the person who receives it: how does she read it, given her views and her group, and what does she do next: ignore it, believe it, share it or challenge it?

Separating the three prevents a common mistake: judging a message only by its content. The same meme means one thing when a fake account plants it and another when a worried parent forwards it.

### One message, three phases

Wardle and Derakhshan also describe three phases: creation, when the message is conceived; production, when it is turned into a media product; and distribution, when it is made public and shared. The agent in each phase may be different. Imagine a made-up network that invents a claim that a city's tap water has been poisoned: that is disinformation. A designer turns it into an alarming image with a headline. Then thousands of ordinary people share it to warn their friends, sincerely believing it. For them it is misinformation.

So a message can change kind as it travels. That is why counting how many people shared a falsehood says little about how many meant harm, and why blaming everyone who shared it is both unfair and useless.

### Why the kind decides the response

Each kind calls for a different response. Misinformation is best met with a quick, friendly correction and with media literacy, because the people spreading it want the truth. Disinformation calls for exposing the agent, its methods and its funding, and for action by platforms against fake accounts. Malinformation cannot be fact-checked, since it is true; the answer is privacy protection and refusing to amplify it. A strong answer defines the three kinds by the two questions, uses the elements and phases, and shows how one case can move between kinds.

## Practice: information disorder

For 12th grade communications students. Every account, company, person and post here is made up. Answer from what is printed on the page, then check yourself against the answers.

1. **What are the two questions that divide information disorder into three kinds?** — Is the content false? Was it created or shared in order to harm? False without intent is misinformation; false with intent is disinformation; true with intent to harm is malinformation.
2. **Fill in the missing cell of the table, and explain why it surprises many readers.** — No, it is real: malinformation is genuine information. It surprises because people expect harmful information to be false, but true private details can be used to hurt someone.
3. **Classify each made-up case: (a) A grandfather forwards a photo of a flooded street, believing it is from today, though it is ten years old. (b) A company invents bad reviews about a rival's restaurant. (c) Someone posts a nurse's real home address to encourage people to harass her.** — (a) Misinformation: false context, but no intent to harm. (b) Disinformation: false and created to harm. (c) Malinformation: the address is real, but it is shared to cause harm.
4. **Fill in the missing element, and write two questions you would ask about it.** — Message. For example: is it text, an image or a video? Does it imitate a real news outlet or official logo?
5. **Name three possible motives of an agent who spreads disinformation.** — For example: money (clicks and advertising), political influence, social belonging or status in a group, or the psychological pleasure of causing trouble.
6. **Fill in the missing phase, and explain how the made-up message changed kind along the way.** — Production: the invented claim is turned into a meme with a headline. It began as disinformation, created to harm, and became misinformation when honest people shared it believing it was true.
7. **Why is fact-checking not a solution to malinformation? What would help instead?** — Because malinformation is true, so a fact-check would confirm it. What helps is protecting privacy, removing doxxing or harassment, and choosing not to spread the material.
8. **A news site counts 40,000 shares of a false post and writes: “40,000 people spread disinformation.” Use the framework to criticize the sentence.** — The phases and elements show that the agent who created the post may have meant harm, but most sharers probably believed it; for them it was misinformation. Counting shares does not measure intent, so the sentence blames ordinary people for the creator's act.

## Common questions

### Who coined the term information disorder?

Claire Wardle and Hossein Derakhshan used it as the title of their October 2017 report for the Council of Europe, as a more precise alternative to the phrase fake news.

### What is the difference between disinformation and malinformation?

Both are shared to cause harm. Disinformation is false, while malinformation is true: genuine information, such as a leaked private message or a home address, used to hurt someone.

### Can misinformation become disinformation?

Yes, in both directions. A lie created on purpose (disinformation) becomes misinformation when honest people share it believing it; and an honest error becomes disinformation if someone keeps spreading it after learning it is false, in order to harm.

### What are the three elements of information disorder?

The agent (who creates, produces or spreads the content, and why), the message (its content and form) and the interpreter (the person who receives it, how she reads it and what she does with it).

### Why not just say fake news?

Because the phrase lumps together very different things, from satire to state propaganda, and is often used to attack accurate reporting. Separate terms make it possible to choose the right response for each case.
