# Why does the Talmud forbid calculating the end?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: The Messiah and Redemption](https://lessoons.com/en/messiah-and-redemption-in-jewish-thought) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/messiah-and-redemption-in-jewish-thought/why-is-calculating-the-end-forbidden

The Talmud forbids calculating the end of days because a date that passes breaks hope: people say, the end came and he did not come, so he will never come. Instead, it says, wait for him. Maimonides added that no one can know the end, and the false messiah Shabbetai Zvi, in 1665 and 1666, showed what such hopes can cost.

## The topic explained

### A curse on those who calculate

The Talmud is unusually harsh: “תיפח עצמן של מחשבי קיצין, שהיו אומרים כיון שהגיע את הקץ ולא בא שוב אינו בא” (may the bones of those who calculate the ends rot, for they say: since the end came and he did not come, he will not come, Sanhedrin 97b). Its answer is “אלא חכה לו” (rather, wait for him), from Habakkuk: “אִם־יִתְמַהְמָהּ חַכֵּה־לוֹ כִּי־בֹא יָבֹא לֹא יְאַחֵר” (if it tarries, wait for it, for it will surely come, it will not delay, Habakkuk 2:3).

The danger in calculating the end is not the arithmetic but what follows it. A date gives hope a deadline, and when the deadline passes the hope breaks. The common misreading is that the sages opposed longing for redemption; they opposed tying it to a date.

### Maimonides: no one can know

Maimonides rules: “וכן לא יחשב הקצין” (and one should not calculate the ends), “אלא יחכה ויאמין בכלל הדבר” (rather, wait and believe in the principle, Hilkhot Melakhim 12:2). In his Letter to Yemen he explains: “שהקץ על דרך האמת לא יתכן לשום אדם לדעת אותו לעולם” (the true end cannot be known by any person, ever), as Daniel was told “כִּי־סְתֻמִים וַחֲתֻמִים הַדְּבָרִים עַד־עֵת קֵץ” (for the words are closed and sealed until the time of the end, Daniel 12:9).

He gives a warning from history: a group of Ephraimites, the sages taught, left Egypt thirty years early on a wrong reckoning, and were killed. And he gives pastoral advice: “אל יעציבו אתכם אם לא יעלה חשבונם אבל כל מה שיוסיף להתאחר הוסיפו בו תקוה” (let it not grieve you if their reckoning fails; rather, the longer it is delayed, add hope).

What about great sages who did calculate, such as Saadia Gaon? Maimonides is generous: “ואנו דנין את רב סעדיה לכף זכות” (we judge Rav Saadia favorably). Saadia lived when many were losing their faith, and he set out a reckoning to strengthen the people and raise their hope, for the sake of heaven. His error in the date is forgiven; the rule against calculating still stands. Maimonides also tells the scholar of Yemen to clear his mind of astrology, which he calls nonsense.

### The Letter to Yemen and a false messiah

The Letter to Yemen answered a crisis. A man in Yemen was announcing that he was the Messiah, and a respected scholar wrote to Maimonides about him. Maimonides is blunt: “לפי שהוא משגע בלי ספק” (for he is surely mad). He is less surprised by the man than by learned people who believe him.

His code gives the test that such claims fail: a Messiah is presumed only by a life of Torah and by fighting the Lord's wars, and proved only by success: rebuilding the Temple and gathering the exiles. Words prove nothing.

### Shabbetai Zvi: what was at stake

Five centuries later the warning came true on a vast scale. At Rosh Hashanah 1665 in Smyrna, Shabbetai Zvi declared himself the Messiah, and his prophet Nathan of Gaza announced that redemption would begin in 1666. Communities from Italy to the Netherlands believed; some communities prepared to emigrate, and followers canceled fasts. In 1666 he was arrested by the Ottoman authorities, and on 16 September he converted to Islam before the sultan. Many despaired, and some kept believing even then. A strong answer explains the Talmud's warning, Maimonides' test, and how a tradition can hope without setting a date.

## Practice: calculating the end

For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the third step in the diagram. Why do the sages fear it?** — Despair: people say that since the date passed and he did not come, he will never come. A failed date can destroy hope itself.
2. **Habakkuk says: “אִם־יִתְמַהְמָהּ חַכֵּה־לוֹ כִּי־בֹא יָבֹא לֹא יְאַחֵר” (if it tarries, wait for it, for it will surely come). How does the Talmud use this verse?** — As the answer to the calculators: instead of setting a date, wait; the delay is no proof that redemption will not come.
3. **Maimonides writes: “שהקץ על דרך האמת לא יתכן לשום אדם לדעת אותו לעולם” (the true end cannot be known by any person, ever). Which verse supports him?** — Daniel 12:9: the words are closed and sealed until the time of the end.
4. **Maimonides advises: “אל יעציבו אתכם אם לא יעלה חשבונם אבל כל מה שיוסיף להתאחר הוסיפו בו תקוה” (let it not grieve you if their reckoning fails; the longer it is delayed, add hope). Why is this advice needed?** — Because people who believed a calculation lose heart when the date passes; Maimonides turns delay into a reason for more hope, not less.
5. **Write the event of 1666 on the timeline.** — Shabbetai Zvi was arrested, and on 16 September 1666 he converted to Islam before the Ottoman sultan.
6. **Fill in the last box: how did Shabbetai Zvi fail the test of building the Temple?** — He converted to Islam in 1666; he built nothing and gathered no exiles, so by Maimonides' test he was not the Messiah.
7. **Write a paragraph: how can a tradition hope for redemption without being misled? Use the Talmud, Maimonides and Shabbetai Zvi.** — A good answer explains the ban on calculating the end, Maimonides' test by deeds and his advice to add hope, shows how Shabbetai Zvi's movement fell, and draws a reasoned conclusion.

## Common questions

### What does mechashvei kitzin mean?

Those who calculate the ends: people who try to work out the date of the redemption. The Talmud (Sanhedrin 97b) curses them because a failed date leads people to despair.

### Why is it forbidden to calculate when the Messiah will come?

Because when the calculated date passes, people conclude that he will never come. The Talmud says instead to wait, and Maimonides rules that one should not calculate the ends but believe in the principle.

### What is Maimonides' Letter to Yemen?

A letter Maimonides wrote to the Jews of Yemen in a time of crisis, answering among other things a man there who claimed to be the Messiah. He calls the man surely mad and warns against calculating the end.

### Who was Shabbetai Zvi?

A Jew from Smyrna who declared himself the Messiah in 1665. His movement spread across the Jewish world until, in 1666, he converted to Islam before the Ottoman sultan.

### What happened to Shabbetai Zvi's followers?

Many despaired and returned to normal life; some kept believing that his conversion was part of a plan. About 300 families converted with him, and their descendants were known as the Dönme.
