# What is the levels of processing theory?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: memory systems and forgetting](https://lessoons.com/en/memory-systems-and-forgetting) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/memory-systems-and-forgetting/what-is-the-levels-of-processing-theory

The levels of processing theory, proposed by Fergus Craik and Robert Lockhart in 1972, says that how well something is remembered depends on how deeply it was processed, not on how long it was held. Shallow processing notices what a word looks like, intermediate processing what it sounds like, and deep processing what it means. In Craik and Tulving's 1975 study, words judged for meaning were recognized far more often.

## The topic explained

### Depth, not time

The multi-store model says information reaches long-term memory by rehearsal: the longer it is repeated, the better it is stored. Fergus Craik and Robert Lockhart (1972) proposed a different view, the levels of processing theory: memory is a by-product of how information is processed, and what matters is the depth of processing, not the time spent.

They described a range of levels. Structural (shallow) processing attends to how a word looks: is it in capital letters? Phonemic processing attends to how it sounds: does it rhyme with weight? Semantic (deep) processing attends to its meaning: does it fit the sentence "He met a ___ in the street"? The deeper the processing, the more lasting the memory. Repeating a word without thinking about it, maintenance rehearsal, keeps it in mind for a while but adds little; elaborative rehearsal, linking it to meaning and to what you already know, makes it last.

### The evidence: Craik and Tulving

Fergus Craik and Endel Tulving (1975) showed people words, each after a question that forced one level of processing, and later gave a surprise memory test. In one experiment, of the words that had received a yes answer, people recognized 15 percent of those asked about capital letters, 48 percent of those asked about rhyme and 81 percent of those asked whether they fitted a sentence. The participants did not know there would be a test, so the difference came from the kind of processing, not from trying harder.

Later work found an even deeper level. In the self-reference effect (Rogers, Kuiper and Kirker, 1977), words judged by "does this describe you?" were remembered better than words judged for meaning alone, because they connect to the richest network we have, knowledge about ourselves.

### The circularity criticism

The theory's main weakness is that depth is hard to measure on its own. How do we know a task was deep? Because it led to good memory. Why did it lead to good memory? Because it was deep. Michael Eysenck and Alan Baddeley both made this criticism in 1978: without an independent measure of depth, the theory cannot be tested properly. A second problem: depth is not everything. Morris, Bransford and Franks (1977) found that people who had processed words for rhyme did better than those who processed them for meaning when the test itself was about rhymes, an idea called transfer-appropriate processing: memory is best when the processing at learning matches the test.

### What it means for studying

The practical lesson holds even with the criticism. Reading notes over and over is shallow, maintenance processing. Asking yourself why something is true, putting it in your own words, connecting it to an example from your life or to something you already know, is deep processing. Teachers use the same idea when they ask "why" questions instead of "what" questions, or ask students to teach a classmate: both force processing of meaning. The common mistake in an exam is to describe the three levels and stop; a strong answer adds the evidence with its numbers and one criticism, and may note that the theory changed the question researchers asked, from where a memory is stored to what was done with it at learning.

## Practice: the levels of processing theory

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the level of processing each question about the word chair produces.** — In capital letters?: structural (shallow). Rhymes with bear?: phonemic. Is it furniture?: semantic (deep).
2. **What is the difference between maintenance and elaborative rehearsal? Which leads to better long-term memory?** — Maintenance rehearsal is repeating information without thinking about its meaning; elaborative rehearsal links it to meaning and to what you know. Elaborative rehearsal leads to better long-term memory.
3. **Read the chart. How many times more words were recognized after the sentence question than after the capital-letter question?** — 81 against 15 percent: about 5.4 times as many (81 ÷ 15 = 5.4).
4. **Why was it important that Craik and Tulving's participants did not expect a memory test?** — So that the difference in memory came from the kind of processing the question forced, not from some participants trying harder to memorize.
5. **Fill in the missing box, and explain why this is a criticism of the theory.** — Good recall. Deep processing is said to cause good recall, but good recall is the only evidence that processing was deep, so the argument is circular and the theory cannot be tested independently.
6. **Students who processed words for rhyme did better on a rhyme test than those who processed them for meaning. What does this show?** — Transfer-appropriate processing (Morris, Bransford and Franks 1977): memory is best when the processing at learning matches the kind of test, so depth alone does not decide memory.
7. **Use the theory to design a 15-minute way to study ten new psychology terms, and explain why it should work.** — A good answer uses deep processing: explain each term in your own words, give a personal example (self-reference), connect terms to each other, and test yourself, instead of rereading the list. It should work because meaning and links to existing knowledge produce more lasting memories.

## Common questions

### Who proposed the levels of processing theory?

Fergus Craik and Robert Lockhart, at the University of Toronto, in 1972. Craik and Endel Tulving tested it in a series of experiments published in 1975.

### What is shallow processing?

Shallow processing attends only to the surface of information, such as what a word looks like or how it sounds. It leads to weaker memory than deep, semantic processing, which attends to meaning.

### What is the self-reference effect?

The self-reference effect is the finding that information related to oneself is remembered especially well. Rogers, Kuiper and Kirker (1977) found that words judged by whether they described the participant were recalled better than words judged for meaning alone.

### Is levels of processing better than the multi-store model?

It explains why repetition alone does not guarantee memory, which the multi-store model did not, but it is harder to test because depth has no independent measure. Many textbooks present the two as complementary.

### How can I use deep processing in exam revision?

Explain each idea in your own words, link it to an example from your own life, compare it with a related idea and answer questions about it. These turn shallow rereading into deep processing.
