# What did the case of H.M. teach us about memory?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: memory systems and forgetting](https://lessoons.com/en/memory-systems-and-forgetting) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/memory-systems-and-forgetting/what-did-the-case-of-hm-teach-about-memory

The case of H.M., Henry Molaison, taught that the hippocampus is needed to form new long-term memories of facts and events, but not to hold information for a few seconds or to learn new skills. After an operation in 1953 removed parts of both his temporal lobes, he could no longer remember new experiences, yet his short-term memory, old memories and ability to learn motor skills remained.

## The topic explained

### An operation in 1953

Henry Molaison, born in 1926 in Connecticut, suffered from severe epileptic seizures that grew worse after his 16th birthday and that medication could not control. On 1 September 1953 the neurosurgeon William Beecher Scoville removed tissue from both sides of his brain in the medial temporal lobes, including much of the hippocampus on each side, and most of the amygdala. The seizures became less severe. But Henry was left with a memory loss so specific that it changed how scientists understood memory. To protect his privacy he was known in research only as H.M. until his death in 2008.

William Scoville and the psychologist Brenda Milner first reported the case in 1957. Over the following decades H.M. took part in studies by Milner and later by Suzanne Corkin, who studied him until he died.

### What he lost, and what he kept

H.M. had severe anterograde amnesia: he could not form new conscious memories of events or facts. He could meet the same researcher many times and greet her each time as a stranger, and read the same magazine again with fresh interest. He also had some retrograde amnesia: most memories from the one to two years before the operation were lost, and some from further back. But memories from his childhood remained.

Just as important was what remained. His short-term memory was intact: he could repeat a short string of digits as well as other people, and hold a conversation as long as he was not distracted. His intelligence and language were unaffected. The common mistake is to say H.M. had no memory at all; he had lost one particular ability, moving new information into lasting conscious memory.

### The mirror star: learning without remembering

In the early 1960s Brenda Milner gave H.M. a mirror-tracing task: drawing a line between the two outlines of a star while seeing his hand and the paper only in a mirror, which reverses every movement. His errors fell from trial to trial and from day to day, like anyone else's, yet each day he said he had never done the task before. He was learning a procedural skill without any conscious memory of learning it.

Together these findings showed that memory is not one thing. Short-term memory, long-term memory for facts and events, and memory for skills depend on different systems, and the hippocampus is needed for turning new experiences into lasting explicit memories, a process called consolidation, but not for the others.

### What one case can and cannot prove

A case study examines one person in depth. H.M.'s case was studied for more than fifty years with many tasks, and its findings have been supported by later patients and by brain imaging, which gives them weight. But one case has limits: the damage was not limited to the hippocampus, his epilepsy and medication may have affected him, and no one can know exactly what his memory was like before. After his death his brain was cut into 2,401 thin sections in 2009 so that the exact damage could be mapped. A good answer uses the case as evidence for separate memory systems and adds one of these limits.

## Practice: the case of H.M.

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fill in the two missing events on the timeline.** — 1953: the operation that removed parts of both medial temporal lobes. 1957: the first report of the case, by Scoville and Milner.
2. **What is the difference between anterograde and retrograde amnesia? Which did H.M. mainly have?** — Anterograde amnesia is losing the ability to form new memories after an injury; retrograde amnesia is losing memories from before it. H.M. mainly had severe anterograde amnesia, with some retrograde loss of the one to two years before the operation.
3. **Fill in the two missing answers.** — Remember new events and facts: could not. Learn a new motor skill: could (the mirror-tracing task).
4. **Describe the mirror-tracing task and what H.M.'s results showed.** — He traced between the two outlines of a star while seeing his hand only in a mirror. His errors fell over days, but he did not remember having done the task. It showed that procedural memory can be learned without the hippocampus and without conscious memory.
5. **How does the case of H.M. support the multi-store model, and how does it go beyond it?** — It supports separate short-term and long-term stores: his short-term memory worked but nothing reached lasting long-term memory. It goes beyond the model by showing that long-term memory itself has separate systems, since he could still learn skills.
6. **Why was H.M. known only by his initials until 2008?** — To protect his privacy, a basic duty of confidentiality in research. His full name was released only after his death.
7. **Evaluate the case of H.M. as evidence about memory: one strength and two limits.** — A good answer gives a strength (studied in depth with many tasks for over fifty years; findings supported by later patients and imaging) and two limits (damage was not only to the hippocampus; one person may not represent others; epilepsy and medication may have played a part; no detailed record of his memory before the operation), and concludes.

## Common questions

### Who was H.M.?

H.M. was Henry Molaison (1926–2008), an American man who had an operation for epilepsy in 1953 that removed parts of both medial temporal lobes. He became the most studied patient in the history of memory research.

### Could H.M. remember anything new?

He could hold new information for a short time while he was attending to it, and he learned new motor skills such as mirror tracing. What he could not do was keep new events and facts in lasting conscious memory.

### What does the hippocampus do?

The hippocampus, in the medial temporal lobe, is needed to turn new experiences and facts into lasting explicit memories. It is not where all memories are stored, and it is not needed for short-term memory or for learning skills.

### Why was his brain cut into slices?

So that scientists could map exactly which tissue had been removed and which remained. In 2009 a team led by Jacopo Annese cut it into 2,401 thin sections, and a digital atlas was published in 2014.

### What is a case study in psychology?

A case study is a detailed investigation of one person or a small group, often using interviews, observation and tests. It can reveal rare conditions in depth but is hard to generalize from.
