# Who was Shmuel HaNagid?

> Written with AI · [Medieval Hebrew poetry: the poets of Spain](https://lessoons.com/en/medieval-hebrew-poetry) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-08 · https://lessoons.com/en/medieval-hebrew-poetry/who-was-shmuel-hanagid

Shmuel HaNagid (993–1056) was the first great Hebrew poet of Muslim Spain and, from 1038, the vizier of Granada and the commander of its army. He wrote war poems in which the speaker thanks God for each victory, and beside them reflective poems on how short a life is, gathered in three books named after the books of David and Solomon.

## The topic explained

### Shmuel HaNagid: poet and vizier

Shmuel HaNagid (993–1056) was born in Mérida and grew up in Córdoba, in Muslim Spain. After Córdoba was sacked in 1013 he moved to Málaga, then rose at the court of Granada. In 1027 he became the first nagid, leader of the Jews of Spain. In 1038 King Badis made him chief vizier and army commander, and he led the army to war almost every year until 1056.

He was also a rabbi and the first great Hebrew poet of the Golden Age. He gathered his poems in three books named after books of David and Solomon: Ben Tehillim (Psalms), Ben Mishlei (Proverbs) and Ben Kohelet (Ecclesiastes). The speaker is the voice that talks in a poem. The common mistake: even when the speaker is called Shmuel and fights a real battle, the poem is not a diary; ask what it does with the facts.

### The war poem: a speaker who thanks God

In 1038 the army of Granada under his command defeated Zuhayr, ruler of Almería, at Alfuente. HaNagid's poem of 149 lines on the battle, Eloah Oz (“אֱלוֹהַּ עֹז”, God of strength), opens “אֱלוֹהַּ עֹז וְאֵל קַנּוֹא וְנוֹרָא, / מְרוֹמָם אַתְּ עֲלֵי כָל שִׁיר וְשִׁירָה” (God of strength, jealous and awesome God, / you are exalted above every song and poem). The commander does not boast of tactics; the speaker thanks God, and the victory becomes a miracle.

Asked if he is afraid, he answers “בְּתִמָּהוֹן: אֲדֹנָי לִי — וְאִירָא?” (in wonder: the Lord is with me, and shall I fear?), turning Psalm 118:6, “יְהוָה לִי, לֹא אִירָא” (the Lord is with me, I will not fear), into a rhetorical question. A weak answer calls the poem religious; a strong one shows that thanks to God is how it tells the battle.

### The biblical model: David, Samuel and Purim

Behind the speaker stands King David, the warrior who wrote psalms. Psalm 18 is the song David sang “בְּיוֹם הִצִּיל־יְהוָה אוֹתוֹ מִכַּף כָּל־אֹיְבָיו” (on the day the Lord delivered him from the hand of all his enemies). HaNagid, who named a book Ben Tehillim, writes his victories in that role.

Inside the poem the battle is told with the cast of the Bible. Zuhayr is Agag, king of Amalek; his vizier Ibn Abbas, who sent letters against HaNagid and his people, is a new Haman; and the poet's name does the rest: “לְפָנִים מֵת אֲגָג עַל-יַד שְׁמוּאֵל” (long ago Agag died at the hand of Samuel), as in 1 Samuel 15. At the end he asks the communities to “וּפוּר מִשְׁנֶה עֲשׂוּ לָאֵל” (make a second Purim for God). A war between two Muslim kingdoms becomes Jewish sacred history.

### The private voice: a night in a ruined fortress

In Ben Kohelet the same commander speaks in another voice. The poem opens in the field, “הֲלִינוֹתִי גְדוּד כָּבֵד בְּבִירָה / הֲרָסוּהָ, יְמֵי קֶדֶם, קְצִינִים” (I lodged a large troop in a fortress / that commanders destroyed in days of old), then turns: “וְדִבַּרְתִּי לְלִבִּי” (and I spoke to my heart), an echo of Ecclesiastes 1:16.

He asks where those who lived there have gone, in opposite pairs: builders and destroyers, princes and paupers, slaves and masters, mourners and bridegrooms. All “וְהָיוּ עַל פְּנֵי אֶרֶץ שְׁכֵנִים – / וְהֵם הַיּוֹם בְּלֵב אֶרֶץ שְׁכוּנִים!” (were neighbors on the face of the earth, / and today they dwell in the heart of the earth): one root, sh-k-n, for life and for the grave. The last line adds himself and his army: “אֱמֶת, נַפְשִׁי, אֱמֶת, כָּהֵם לְמָחָר / אֱהִי אָנִי וְאֵלֶּה הַהֲמוֹנִים” (truly, my soul, truly: tomorrow, like them, / I shall be, and all these crowds).

In the public voice the speaker stands at the head of his people, beside God; in the private voice he is one of tomorrow's dead. Do not call one sincere and the other a pose: the same man wrote both.

## Shmuel HaNagid practice: the war poem and the ruined fortress

For 11th grade students of medieval Hebrew poetry. Every line you need is printed on the sheet; answer in full sentences, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Complete the table: which book of the Bible is each of HaNagid's three books of poetry named after?** — Ben Tehillim: Psalms (Tehillim), traditionally David's. Ben Mishlei: Proverbs (Mishlei), traditionally Solomon's. Ben Kohelet: Ecclesiastes (Kohelet), also traditionally Solomon's. Each name means son of that book: a new book in its line.
2. **Read the opening of Eloah Oz (1038): “אֱלוֹהַּ עֹז וְאֵל קַנּוֹא וְנוֹרָא, / מְרוֹמָם אַתְּ עֲלֵי כָל שִׁיר וְשִׁירָה” (God of strength, jealous and awesome God, / you are exalted above every song and poem). The poem is about a battle the poet won. Whom does the first line address, and what does that tell you about the speaker?** — It addresses God, not the soldiers or the reader. Before a word about the battle, the speaker sets God above every poem, his own included. The victory poem is a poem of thanks, and the commander presents himself as the one God saved.
3. **Asked if he is afraid, the speaker answers “בְּתִמָּהוֹן: אֲדֹנָי לִי — וְאִירָא?” (in wonder: the Lord is with me, and shall I fear?). Compare Psalm 118:6, “יְהוָה לִי, לֹא אִירָא” (the Lord is with me, I will not fear). What did the poet change, and why?** — He turned the psalm's statement into a rhetorical question, asked in wonder. The question makes fear sound absurd: whoever has God with him cannot even imagine being afraid. The echo also gives the commander the voice of the psalmist.
4. **In Eloah Oz, Zuhayr, ruler of Almería, is called Agag; his vizier, Ibn Abbas, sent letters against HaNagid and his people; the poet recalls that Agag died at the hand of Samuel and asks for a second Purim. Complete the table: who in the Bible is whom in the poem?** — Agag, king of Amalek: Zuhayr, ruler of Almería. Haman: Ibn Abbas, the vizier who sent letters against the Jews, as Haman did. Samuel, who killed Agag: Shmuel HaNagid himself, whose name makes the link. Purim: the day of the victory, which the poet asks to keep as a second Purim.
5. **This short poem is from Ben Mishlei: “קְרָב דּוֹמֶה בְּרֹאשׁוֹ אֶל יְפֵיפָה / אֲשֶׁר כָּל אִישׁ לְשַׂחֵק בָּהּ יְאַוֶּה, / וְסוֹפוֹ כַזְּקֵנָה הַמְּאוּסָה / אֲשֶׁר כָּל שׁוֹחֲרָהּ יִבְכֶּה וְיִדְוֶה.” (War at its start is like a beautiful girl / whom every man longs to play with, / and at its end like a despised old woman / whose every suitor weeps and grieves.) Name the device, and say how this view of war differs from Eloah Oz.** — Two similes: war at its start is a beautiful girl, at its end a despised old woman. The ground: war attracts before it begins and leaves only grief behind it. Eloah Oz tells one war as a miracle and thanks God; this proverb, in the voice of a wise man, speaks of every war and its cost.
6. **Read the opening of the poem from Ben Kohelet: “הֲלִינוֹתִי גְדוּד כָּבֵד בְּבִירָה / הֲרָסוּהָ, יְמֵי קֶדֶם, קְצִינִים, / וְיָשַׁנּוּ עֲלֵי גַבָּהּ וְצִדָּהּ, / וְתַחְתֵּינוּ בְּעָלֶיהָ יְשֵׁנִים.” (I lodged a large troop in a fortress / that commanders destroyed in days of old, / and we slept on its back and its sides, / and under us its owners were sleeping.) Who sleeps above, who sleeps below, and what does the verb sleep do here?** — The soldiers sleep on top of the ruin; the owners of the fortress, who lived there generations ago, sleep beneath them, in their graves. The same verb, yashanu and yeshenim, is used for both, so the living and the dead already lie side by side: sleep is a picture of death.
7. **Three more lines of the poem. Line 3: “וְדִבַּרְתִּי לְלִבִּי” “אֵי קְהָלִים / וְעַמִּים, שָׁכְנוּ בָזֹאת לְפָנִים?” (and I spoke to my heart: where are the congregations / and peoples who lived here before?). Line 7: “וְהָיוּ עַל פְּנֵי אֶרֶץ שְׁכֵנִים – / וְהֵם הַיּוֹם בְּלֵב אֶרֶץ שְׁכוּנִים!” (they were neighbors on the face of the earth, / and today they dwell in the heart of the earth!). Line 10: “אֱמֶת, נַפְשִׁי, אֱמֶת, כָּהֵם לְמָחָר / אֱהִי אָנִי וְאֵלֶּה הַהֲמוֹנִים” (truly, my soul, truly: tomorrow, like them, / I shall be, and all these crowds). Complete the table: what happens in each part of the poem?** — Lines 1–2: the public scene, a commander and his troop sleeping in a ruined fortress. Line 3: the turn inward, he speaks to his heart. Lines 3–9: the questions: where are all who lived here? They lie in the earth. Line 10: the conclusion: tomorrow he and his soldiers will be like them.
8. **Compare the speaker of Eloah Oz with the speaker of the fortress poem. Write a paragraph with a quotation from each poem.** — A good answer says that in Eloah Oz the speaker uses a public voice: a leader who stands with God against his enemies and speaks for his people (“בְּתִמָּהוֹן: אֲדֹנָי לִי — וְאִירָא?”). In the fortress poem he uses a private voice: he speaks to his own soul and counts himself among tomorrow's dead (“כָּהֵם לְמָחָר / אֱהִי אָנִי”). The best answers add that both voices come from a man who faced death in battle.

## Common questions

### What does the title nagid mean?

Nagid is a biblical word for a leader or prince. In 1027 Shmuel ibn Naghrela became the nagid of the Jews of Spain, the first to hold the title, and he has been called Shmuel HaNagid ever since. It was his office in the Jewish community, apart from his post as vizier at the king's court.

### Did a Jew really command a Muslim army?

Yes. From 1038 Shmuel HaNagid was chief vizier to King Badis of Granada and the commander of his army, and he went to war almost every year until 1056. It was an exceptional achievement, and his enemies' envy of it is one of the subjects of his war poems.

### Is the speaker of HaNagid's poems the poet himself?

Not quite. The war poems name real battles and even the poet's name, but the speaker is a figure the poem shapes: a David who thanks God, a Samuel who defeats Agag. In an answer, write the speaker rather than HaNagid, and show how the poem shapes the facts.

### What is Ben Kohelet?

Ben Kohelet, son of Ecclesiastes, is HaNagid's book of reflective poems, written in the spirit of Ecclesiastes: the shortness of life, the emptiness of power and the fear of death. The poem about the troop in the ruined fortress belongs to it, where the commander sees that he and his soldiers will soon be like the dead beneath them.

### How do HaNagid's war poems differ from his reflective poems?

The war poems speak in a public voice: a leader thanks God for a victory and tells it as a chapter in his people's history. The reflective poems speak in a private voice: a man talks to his own soul about death. The same experience of the battlefield stands behind both.
