# What is the difference between sacred and secular Hebrew poetry?

> Written with AI · [Medieval Hebrew poetry: the poets of Spain](https://lessoons.com/en/medieval-hebrew-poetry) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-08 · https://lessoons.com/en/medieval-hebrew-poetry/what-is-the-difference-between-sacred-and-secular-hebrew-poetry

In medieval Spain, sacred Hebrew poetry (shirat ha-kodesh) was written to be said in the synagogue as part of the prayers, and secular poetry (shirat ha-chol) was written for the court and the banquet, for its own sake. The same poets wrote both: piyyutim such as the reshut, the selicha and the kina, and poems of wine, desire, praise, friendship and reflection.

## The topic explained

### What separates a sacred poem from a secular one

In Muslim Spain the difference between sacred and secular Hebrew poetry is first of all a difference of place. Sacred poetry was written to be woven into the prayers, so it was kept in prayer books, by its place in the service. Secular poetry was written for the court and the banquet, for the beauty of the poem, and was gathered in each poet's diwan, his book of poems. The same men wrote both: rabbis, Bible commentators and philosophers also wrote wine poems and love poems.

So the subject alone does not decide. Many secular poems mention God: the reflective poems (shirei hagut) say that everything passes and call on the reader to serve God, yet they are secular, because they were not said in prayer. The common mistake is to call a poem sacred because the word God appears in it. Ask first where it was said.

### The kinds of poem, from reshut to wine song

Each side has its own kinds of poem, and their names tell their place. A reshut is a short poem said before a prayer, like Ibn Gabirol's At dawn I seek you before Nishmat. A selicha asks forgiveness for sins and is said before and during the High Holy Days; a pticha opens the selichot. A kina mourns, mostly on Tisha b'Av, and the yotzer, ahava and geula belong to the blessings of the Shema.

The most common secular kind is the praise poem, for a patron or a friend. Beside it stand wine poems of the court banquet, poems of desire, where the beloved is called a gazelle (tzvi or tzviya), and poems of complaint, nature, weddings and reflection. Many of these kinds came from Arabic poetry.

### The speaker: the people before God, the lover before the gazelle

Compare two poems by Yehuda Halevi. Lord, hear your poor (“יה שמע אביוניך”) opens the Yom Kippur selichot: “יָהּ שְׁמַע אֶבְיוֹנֶֽיךָ / הַמְחַלִּים פָּנֶֽיךָ / אָבִֽינוּ, לְבָנֶֽיךָ / אַל תַּעְלֵם אׇזְנֶֽךָ” (Lord, hear your poor / who plead before you / our Father, to your children / do not hide your ear). The speaker is not one person but a congregation, calling God “אָבִינוּ” (our Father), so every worshipper can say the words as his own.

What ails you, gazelle (“מה לך צביה”) is a poem of desire: “מַה לָּךְ צְבִיָּה תִּמְנְעִי צִירָיִךְ / מִדּוֹד צְלָעָיו מָלְאוּ צִירָיִךְ” (what ails you, gazelle, that you hold back your envoys / from a lover whose ribs are full of your pangs). Here one I speaks, and one word, tzirayikh, means both envoys and pangs: a tzimud (pun). Do not read it as the poet's diary: the lover is a stock figure of the genre. Yet both speakers ask a distant you to listen.

### The girdle poem: the rhyme changes, the girdle returns

Beside the classical line, the poets wrote the girdle poem (shir ezor, the Arabic muwashshah), a form born in Spain. It is built of stanzas. Each opens with a branch (anaf), lines in a rhyme that changes from stanza to stanza, and closes with a girdle (ezor), whose rhyme returns through the poem like a refrain. It may open with a madrich in the returning rhyme and end with a kharja, which in secular poems was sometimes in Arabic.

Lord, hear your poor is built this way: five stanzas of three lines in a new rhyme and a fourth that returns to -nekha. In the second, the branch speaks of the people's sins in -nam (their), and the girdle turns to God in -nekha (your): “אִם לֹא תַּעֲשֶׂה לְמַעֲנָם / עֲשֵׂה צוּרִי לְמַעֲנֶֽךָ” (if you will not act for their sake / act, my Rock, for your own). The change of rhyme is the turn of the plea. Do not stop at saying the rhymes change: find the rhyme that returns.

## Practice: sacred and secular Hebrew poetry

For 11th grade students reading medieval Hebrew poetry. Every line is printed on the sheet; work in order and check yourself against the answers.

1. **In the table, write beside each kind of poem whether it is sacred or secular.** — Sacred: selicha, reshut, kina for Tisha b'Av. Secular: wine poem, praise poem, poem of desire.
2. **Where were sacred poems kept, and where were secular poems kept? Why does that matter when you sort a poem?** — Sacred poems were kept in prayer books (siddurim and machzorim), by their place in the service; secular poems were gathered in each poet's diwan. It matters because it shows that the test is the poem's use, in prayer or at court, not only its subject.
3. **Read the opening of Yehuda Halevi's Lord, hear your poor:
“יָהּ שְׁמַע אֶבְיוֹנֶֽיךָ / הַמְחַלִּים פָּנֶֽיךָ / אָבִֽינוּ, לְבָנֶֽיךָ / אַל תַּעְלֵם אׇזְנֶֽךָ” (Lord, hear your poor / who plead before you / our Father, to your children / do not hide your ear)
Who speaks, to whom, and which words show it?** — The speaker is the congregation, all the worshippers, not one person: they are “אֶבְיוֹנֶיךָ” (your poor) and “בָנֶיךָ” (your children). The one addressed is God, whom the speaker calls “אָבִינוּ” (our Father) and asks not to hide his ear.
4. **Read the first line of Yehuda Halevi's What ails you, gazelle:
“מַה לָּךְ צְבִיָּה תִּמְנְעִי צִירָיִךְ / מִדּוֹד צְלָעָיו מָלְאוּ צִירָיִךְ” (what ails you, gazelle, that you hold back your envoys / from a lover whose ribs are full of your pangs)
a. Who speaks, and to whom? b. What does “צִירָיִךְ” (tzirayikh) mean in the dalet, and what in the sogar? What is the device called?** — a. The speaker is the lover, and he speaks to the gazelle, a name for the beloved. b. In the dalet the word means her envoys; in the sogar, pangs, like labor pains: she sends him no messenger, and he is full of pain because of her. One word used in two senses is a tzimud (pun).
5. **This is the second stanza of Lord, hear your poor:
“הַוּוֹתָם וַעֲוֺנָם / מְחֵה, וְרֻבֵּי זְדוֹנָם / אִם לֹא תַּעֲשֶׂה לְמַעֲנָם / עֲשֵׂה צוּרִי לְמַעֲנֶֽךָ” (their wrongs and their sins / wipe away, and their many crimes / if you will not act for their sake / act, my Rock, for your own)
Mark each line branch or girdle in the table, with its rhyme. What changes between the rhyme of the branch and the rhyme of the girdle?** — The first three lines are the branch, in -nam; the fourth is the girdle, in -nekha, which returns through the whole poem. The branch speaks of the people and their sins (their), and the girdle turns to God (your): if not for their sake, then for yours.
6. **Complete the comparison table of the two poems. Use this line of What ails you, gazelle too: “אִם הַפְּרִידָה עַל שְׁנֵינוּ נִגְזְרָה / עִמְדִי מְעַט עַד אֶחֱזֶה פָנָיִךְ” (if parting is decreed for the two of us / stay a little, till I see your face).** — Lord, hear your poor: the speaker is the congregation, the one addressed is God, and the request is that he hear their prayer and forgive. What ails you, gazelle: the speaker is the lover, the one addressed is the gazelle, and the request is “עִמְדִי מְעַט” (stay a little): a moment more before they part.
7. **A student wrote: In What ails you, gazelle, Yehuda Halevi tells about the woman he loved, who left him. What is wrong with the answer? Rewrite it.** — The student confuses the speaker with the poet. In the love poetry of Spain the lover and the gazelle are stock figures of the genre, and nobody knows whether a real story lies behind them. A better answer: the speaker, a lover whose beloved is leaving, begs her to stay a little.
8. **Write a paragraph comparing the two poems by Yehuda Halevi: how are they alike, and how do they differ?** — A good paragraph says that both poems speak to a distant you and ask it to listen, with a quotation from each. Then it names three differences, the speaker (a congregation or one lover), the one addressed (God or the beloved) and the form (stanzas with a returning rhyme or one single rhyme), and says what each difference changes.

## Common questions

### What is a piyyut?

A piyyut is a poem written to be said in the prayers, to replace part of the fixed prayer text or to add to it. The word comes from the Greek word for poet. The poets of Spain wrote many piyyutim, such as reshuyot, selichot and kinot, and many are still said in synagogues today.

### Are secular poems only about worldly things?

No. The reflective poems of Spain are about time, death and the emptiness of worldly pleasure, and many call on the reader to serve God. They are still secular, because they were written to be read, not prayed. So to sort a poem, ask where it was said, not only what it is about.

### What is a kharja?

A kharja (Arabic for exit) is the ending of a girdle poem. In secular girdle poems it was sometimes in Arabic or in the Romance language spoken in Spain, though the rest of the poem is Hebrew, and the returning rhyme of the girdles comes from it. In sacred girdle poems it was in Hebrew.

### Why did rabbis and philosophers write wine and love poems?

In Spain poetry was seen as a craft: a poet had fixed kinds of poem and models, and he showed his skill by writing them well. Wine and love poems were part of court culture, and writing them was not felt to clash with a religious life. That is why a love poem tells us nothing certain about the poet's private life.

### What is the difference between a selicha and a kina?

A selicha is a piyyut that asks God to forgive sins, said before and during the High Holy Days and on fast days. A kina is a piyyut of deep mourning, said mostly on Tisha b'Av for the destroyed Temple and the sufferings of the people. Both are sacred: one asks, the other mourns.
