# How does Avraham Ibn Ezra laugh at his bad luck in his poems?

> Written with AI · [Medieval Hebrew poetry: the poets of Spain](https://lessoons.com/en/medieval-hebrew-poetry) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-08 · https://lessoons.com/en/medieval-hebrew-poetry/how-does-avraham-ibn-ezra-laugh-at-his-bad-luck

In Avraham Ibn Ezra's poems (about 1089–1164), written by a scholar who left Spain and wandered through Italy, France and England, poverty and bad luck become a joke. A poem sets up a misfortune, blows it up with exaggeration and ends with a turn: if he sold candles, the sun would never set; if he sold shrouds, no one would die.

## The topic explained

### A wandering scholar

Avraham Ibn Ezra was born in Tudela, in Spain, around 1089. In Spain he was mainly a poet, and probably a poor one. In the 1140s (the exact year is not known) he left Spain, probably fleeing the persecutions of the Almohads, and never settled again: Rome and other cities of Italy; Béziers, Narbonne and Rouen in France; and London, where he was in 1158. He died in 1164; where is not known.

On the road he wrote almost all his books: commentaries on the Bible, Hebrew grammar, astronomy, mathematics and astrology. One poem sums it up: “בְּכָל מָקוֹם גַּרְתִּי / סְפָרִים חִבַּרְתִּי / וְסוֹדוֹת בֵּאַרְתִּי” (in every place I lived / I wrote books / and explained secrets). Remember the astrology: it is the key to his jokes.

### Gilgal u-Mazalot: the stars against him

The four-line poem Gilgal u-Mazalot (“גַּלְגַּל וּמַזָּלוֹת”, the sphere and the stars) opens with a setup in the language of astrology: “גַּלְגַּל וּמַזָּלוֹת בְּמַעְמָדָם / נָטוּ בְּמַהְלָכָם לְמוֹלַדְתִּי” (the sphere and the stars in their stations / swerved in their course at my birth). For an astronomer this is no figure of speech: the heavens took their stand against him on the day he was born.

Then the exaggeration, a picture blown far beyond reality: “לוּ יִהְיוּ נֵרוֹת סְחוֹרָתִי – / לֹא-יֶחֱשַׁךְ שֶׁמֶשׁ עֲדֵי מוֹתִי!” (if candles were my merchandise, / the sun would not go dark until I die!). His luck is bad enough to stop the sun. The second half repeats the pattern and darkens it: “לוּ אֶהֱיֶה סֹחֵר בְּתַכְרִיכִין– / לֹא יִגְוְעוּן אִישִׁים בְּכָל יָמָי!” (if I were a dealer in shrouds, / no one would die in all my days!). The turn is that death, the worst thing of all, becomes the punch line: the bad luck that strikes him would save the world.

A common mistake is to write that the poem is funny and stop. Show how the laugh is built: a serious setup, a growing exaggeration and an ending that reverses the direction.

### The Torn Cloak: an image that reaches the stars

In The Torn Cloak (“הַמְעִיל הַקָּרוּעַ”) the setup is a simile: “מְעִיל יֵשׁ לִי וְהוּא כִדְמוּת כְּבָרָה” (I have a cloak, and it is like a sieve). The exaggeration grows line by line: spread at night like a tent, it lets the stars shine through, and inside it he sees “סַהַר וְכִימָה” (the moon and the Pleiades) and Orion, the stars of Amos 5:8. He tires of counting its holes, like the teeth of a saw.

The turn comes in the last line, where the joke becomes a prayer: “אֱלוֹהַי, הַחֲלִיפֵהוּ בְּמַעְטֵה / תְהִלָּה לִי וְתֵיטִיב הַתְּפִירָה!” (my God, exchange it for a mantle / of praise for me, and sew it better!). The mantle of praise, “מַעֲטֵה תְהִלָּה”, is from Isaiah 61:3, the promise to the mourners of Zion, and the ending asks God himself to be a better tailor. The laughter does not hide the poverty; it lets the poet keep his dignity.

### Ibn Ezra's laughter and Ibn Gabirol's complaint

Both poets write about misfortune, and both speak of the heavens and of God. But Ibn Gabirol's speaker cries “נִחַר בְּקָרְאִי גְּרוֹנִי” (my throat is parched from my crying) and blames a world that does not understand him; he stands above everyone, and alone. Ibn Ezra's speaker blames the stars, laughs at himself and invites the reader to laugh along. The distance of the joke makes the pain something shared.

The common mistake is to take the humor as a sign that he did not suffer. Laughter is a way of complaining: I Rise Early to the Nobleman's House (“אשכים לבית השר”) ends with a sigh, “אוֹיָה לְאִישׁ עָנִי, נוֹלַד בְּלִי כוֹכָב!” (woe to a poor man, born without a star!). A good answer shows what each poet does with the same pain.

## Avraham Ibn Ezra practice: exaggeration, the turn and Ibn Gabirol

For 11th grade students of medieval Hebrew poetry. Every line you need is printed on the sheet; answer in full sentences, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Put the stations of Ibn Ezra's wandering into the table in order of time: London; Tudela in Spain; Béziers, Narbonne and Rouen; Rome, Lucca, Mantua and Verona.** — About 1089: Tudela in Spain, where he was born. From the 1140s: Rome, Lucca, Mantua and Verona in Italy. From about 1148: Béziers, Narbonne and Rouen in France. 1158: London.
2. **This is the whole of Gilgal u-Mazalot: “גַּלְגַּל וּמַזָּלוֹת בְּמַעְמָדָם / נָטוּ בְּמַהְלָכָם לְמוֹלַדְתִּי; / לוּ יִהְיוּ נֵרוֹת סְחוֹרָתִי – / לֹא-יֶחֱשַׁךְ שֶׁמֶשׁ עֲדֵי מוֹתִי! / אִיגַע לְהַצְלִיחַ וְלֹא-אוּכַל, / כִּי עִוְּתוּנִי כּוֹכְבֵי שָׁמָי; / לוּ אֶהֱיֶה סֹחֵר בְּתַכְרִיכִין– / לֹא יִגְוְעוּן אִישִׁים בְּכָל יָמָי!” (The sphere and the stars in their stations / swerved in their course at my birth; / if candles were my merchandise, / the sun would not go dark until I die! / I toil to succeed and cannot, / for the stars of my heavens have wronged me; / if I were a dealer in shrouds, / no one would die in all my days!) Whom does the speaker blame for his bad luck, and why does that blame suit Ibn Ezra in particular?** — He blames the sphere and the stars, which swerved from their course on the day he was born and wronged him. It suits Ibn Ezra because he studied astronomy and astrology and wrote books on them: he uses his own science to laugh at himself.
3. **Complete the diagram of the structure of Gilgal u-Mazalot: what is in the setup, what is the exaggeration and what is the turn?** — Setup: the stars swerved at his birth, so he cannot succeed. Exaggeration: if he sold candles, the sun would not set until he died. Turn: if he sold shrouds, no one would die. In the end his bad luck becomes a blessing for the whole world, and that is the punch line.
4. **From The Torn Cloak: “מְעִיל יֵשׁ לִי וְהוּא כִדְמוּת כְּבָרָה / לְחִטָּה לַהֲנָפָה אוֹ שְׂעוֹרָה, / כְּאֹהֶל אֶפְרְשֶׂנּוּ לֵיל בְּאִישׁוֹן / וְכוֹכְבֵי רוֹם יְשִׂימוּן בּוֹ מְאוֹרָה, / בְּתוֹכוֹ אֶחֱזֶה סַהַר וְכִימָה / וְיוֹפִיעַ כְּסִיל עָלָיו נְהָרָה. / וְאֵלַהּ מִסְּפֹר אֶת כָּל נְקָבָיו / אֲשֶׁר דּוֹמִים לְשִׁנֵּי הַמְּגֵרָה” (I have a cloak, and it is like a sieve / for sifting wheat or barley; / I spread it like a tent in the dead of night / and the stars on high shine their light through it; / inside it I see the moon and the Pleiades, / and Orion shines his light upon it. / I am weary of counting all its holes, / which are like the teeth of a saw.) Find three exaggerations and explain how each grows bigger than the one before.** — 1. The cloak is a sieve for sifting wheat. 2. Spread at night like a tent, it lets the stars through, and in it he sees the moon, the Pleiades and Orion. 3. Its holes cannot be counted, like the teeth of a saw. The exaggeration climbs from the house to the sky: from a kitchen tool to the whole dome of the stars.
5. **The Torn Cloak ends “אֱלוֹהַי, הַחֲלִיפֵהוּ בְּמַעְטֵה / תְהִלָּה לִי וְתֵיטִיב הַתְּפִירָה!” (my God, exchange it for a mantle / of praise for me, and sew it better!). Compare Isaiah 61:3, “מַעֲטֵה תְהִלָּה, תַּחַת רוּחַ כֵּהָה” (a mantle of praise instead of a faint spirit). What is the turn, and what does the echo add?** — The turn: the joke becomes a prayer, and the poet asks God for a new cloak. The echo of Isaiah replaces the torn cloak with the mantle of praise promised to the mourners of Zion, so material honor gives way to spiritual honor. And the request to sew it better makes God a tailor: one last joke.
6. **Read I Rise Early to the Nobleman's House: “אַשְׁכִּים לְבֵית הַשָּׂר – אֹמְרִים: כְּבָר רָכָב! / אָבֹא לְעֵת עֶרֶב – אֹמְרִים: כְּבָר שָׁכָב! / אוֹ יַעֲלֶה מֶרְכָּב, אוֹ יַעֲלֶה מִשְׁכָּב – / אוֹיָה לְאִישׁ עָנִי, נוֹלַד בְּלִי כוֹכָב!” (I come early to the nobleman's house: they say, he has already ridden off! / I come at evening: they say, he has already gone to bed! / Either he mounts his carriage or he mounts his bed: / woe to a poor man, born without a star!) What does the rhyme do in the poem, and who is to blame at the end?** — The whole poem is built on one sound: rakhav, shakhav, merkav, mishkav, kokhav, and every line begins with the letter alef. The same rhyme shows every attempt ending at the same closed door. At the end the blame moves from the nobleman to the star: the poor man was born without one, without luck, which is both a joke and a sigh.
7. **Complete the table comparing Ibn Gabirol's complaint with Ibn Ezra's laughter, and write what both share.** — Against cries out in pain: laughs at himself. Against blames the stars: blames the people around him. Against alone, above others: the reader laughs too. Both share bad luck and real pain, which each poet turns into poetry in his own way.
8. **Write a short poem of your own, two or four lines, about bad luck, with the same structure: setup, exaggeration and turn.** — Many answers are right. A good poem has a setup that presents the bad luck, an exaggeration that blows it up beyond all reason, and a turn at the end that changes direction, for example: if I opened an umbrella shop, it would never rain again.

## Common questions

### Why does Ibn Ezra blame the stars?

Ibn Ezra studied astronomy and astrology and wrote books on them. In his poems he uses the belief that the stars at a person's birth decide his fate to laugh at his own: the sphere swerved when he was born, and he was born without a star. The idea that poverty depends on luck appears in the Talmud too.

### Why do some books quote Gilgal u-Mazalot with different words?

Medieval poems reached us in different manuscripts and collections, so they have different versions. Online, too, it appears in slightly different words. This page quotes the version in Project Ben-Yehuda; Hebrew Wikisource has the same words with slightly different vowels. In an exam, quote the version printed in your class's anthology.

### Did Ibn Ezra write only humorous poems?

No. He also wrote liturgical and serious poems. One of the best known is the lament “אהה ירד על ספרד רע” (alas, evil has come down on Spain), in which he mourns the Jewish communities of Spain and North Africa destroyed under the Almohads and names them one by one.

### What is the turn at the end of a poem?

The turn is a change of direction at the end of a poem that makes readers reread what came before. In Gilgal u-Mazalot death becomes the punch line; in The Torn Cloak the joke becomes a prayer. In an answer, show the direction before the turn and what changes after it.

### What did Ibn Ezra write besides poetry?

On his travels he wrote commentaries on the Bible, above all his commentary on the Torah, and books of Hebrew grammar, astronomy, mathematics and astrology. He wrote in Hebrew, and so brought the learning of Spanish Jewry, written mostly in Arabic, to the communities of Europe.
