# What was the Kol Ha'am ruling?

> Written with AI · [Communications: the media in Israel](https://lessoons.com/en/media-in-israel) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/media-in-israel/what-was-the-kol-haam-ruling

The Kol Ha'am ruling is a 1953 decision of Israel's Supreme Court that cancelled the suspension of two Communist Party newspapers, Kol Ha'am and Al-Ittihad. Written by Justice Shimon Agranat, it held that a paper may be stopped only when its words make serious harm to public safety a near certainty, and it founded freedom of expression in Israeli law although Israel had no constitution.

## The topic explained

### What happened in 1953

The Kol Ha'am ruling began with a news report. On 9 March 1953 the daily Haaretz reported that Israel was ready to provide military aid to the United States in the Korean War. Two newspapers of the Israeli Communist Party, Kol Ha'am in Hebrew and Al-Ittihad in Arabic, published sharp attacks on the government's policy. The Minister of the Interior used his power under the Press Ordinance of the British Mandate, which allowed him to suspend a newspaper that in his opinion was likely to endanger the public peace. He suspended Kol Ha'am for ten days and Al-Ittihad for fifteen.

The papers petitioned the High Court of Justice. On 16 October 1953 three justices, with Shimon Agranat writing, cancelled the suspension orders: the minister had used his power wrongly. The case concerned papers whose views most Israelis then rejected, which is part of why it matters: freedom of the press is tested by unpopular speech.

### The near certainty test

The law said “likely to endanger”. The minister read it as enough that the articles had a tendency to cause harm, an approach known as the bad tendency test. Agranat read it narrowly. Freedom of expression and the public peace must be weighed, and expression gives way only when the publication makes real and serious harm to the public peace a near certainty (in Hebrew “ודאות קרובה”, vadaut krova). A sharp article, even an offensive one, does not meet that bar.

The common mistake is to think the court said the press may publish anything. It did not: the test allows a restriction when serious harm is nearly certain. What it rules out is silencing a newspaper because its words might, perhaps, someday, lead to trouble.

### Free speech without a constitution

Israel had no written constitution and no law that guaranteed free speech. Agranat built the right from two sources. The Declaration of Independence, though it does not mention free speech explicitly, expresses the vision of the state and guides how laws are read. The democratic character of the state requires that citizens can learn, criticize and choose, which is impossible without free expression. Laws, even laws inherited from the Mandate, must therefore be interpreted in a way that protects that freedom.

The ruling is often described as the first time the court declared that Israel is a democratic state with rights that bind the government even without a constitution.

### Why it still matters

The near certainty test spread beyond the press ordinance. In the Schnitzer case of 1989 the Supreme Court applied a similar test to the military censor, who may stop a publication only when it is nearly certain to cause real harm to state security. The Press Ordinance itself was repealed in 2017. Supporters see the ruling as the foundation of free expression in Israel; others argue that a test this strict can leave too little room to act against dangerous speech, and the courts have adapted it over the years.

A strong exam answer gives the facts and the date, explains the near certainty test and how it differs from a bad tendency test, names the sources of the right, and says why the ruling still matters.

## Practice: the Kol Ha'am ruling

For 11th grade communications students. The cases in items 5 and 6 are made up. Answer from what is printed here, then check yourself against the answers.

1. **Which two newspapers were suspended in 1953, and under which law?** — Kol Ha'am (Hebrew) and Al-Ittihad (Arabic), papers of the Israeli Communist Party, under the Press Ordinance of the British Mandate.
2. **Fill in the missing event in the timeline.** — 22 March 1953: the Minister of the Interior ordered Kol Ha'am suspended for ten days (Al-Ittihad for fifteen).
3. **Fill in the missing row: what does each test ask?** — Bad tendency test: is harm possible, could the words lead to it? Near certainty test: is real and serious harm nearly certain?
4. **How did Agranat ground freedom of expression when Israel had no constitution?** — In the Declaration of Independence, which expresses the vision of the state and guides how laws are read, and in the democratic character of the state, which requires free expression; laws are interpreted in light of these values.
5. **Apply the near certainty test: a made-up local paper publishes a harsh editorial calling a government decision a disgrace. May it be suspended?** — No. A harsh or offensive editorial does not make real and serious harm to the public peace nearly certain; under the test, criticism of the government is protected.
6. **Apply the test again: a made-up publication gives the exact time and place where a crowd should attack a building tonight. Could a restriction meet the test? Explain.** — It could: a specific call to violence at a set time and place may make serious harm nearly certain, which is the situation the test allows a restriction for. A good answer explains the difference from mere criticism.
7. **Why does it matter that the papers in the case held views most Israelis then rejected?** — Because freedom of the press is tested by unpopular speech: protecting only popular views would require no rule. The ruling protected the right of a minority view to be published.
8. **Does the near certainty test protect too much or too little? Write a short balanced answer and a conclusion.** — A good answer gives the case that it protects well (it stops the government from silencing critics because of vague fears) and the case that it may protect too much (it can leave too little room to act against dangerous speech before harm is certain), and concludes with a reasoned view.

## Common questions

### What is the near certainty test?

The test set in the Kol Ha'am ruling of 1953: freedom of expression may be restricted only when a publication makes real and serious harm to a protected interest, such as the public peace, nearly certain, not merely possible.

### Who wrote the Kol Ha'am ruling?

Justice Shimon Agranat, sitting with Justices Yoel Sussman and Moshe Landau. Agranat later became President of the Supreme Court.

### Why was the Kol Ha'am ruling important?

It recognized freedom of expression as a right in Israeli law without a constitution, grounded it in the Declaration of Independence and democracy, and set a strict test for silencing the press that later cases applied to other areas, such as military censorship.

### What was the Press Ordinance?

A British Mandate law of 1933 that required a license to publish a newspaper and let the Minister of the Interior suspend a paper. Israel kept it after 1948; the Knesset repealed it in 2017.

### Does the ruling mean the press can publish anything?

No. It allows restrictions when serious harm is nearly certain, and other laws, such as the defamation law and military censorship, still apply. It rules out silencing a paper because of a vague tendency of its words.
