# What is military censorship in Israel?

> Written with AI · [Communications: the media in Israel](https://lessoons.com/en/media-in-israel) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/media-in-israel/what-is-military-censorship-in-israel

Military censorship in Israel is the review of security news before it is published. Under the Defence (Emergency) Regulations of 1945, the media must submit items on defined security subjects to the military censor, who may approve, cut or ban them. Since the Schnitzer ruling of 1989, the censor may stop a publication only when it is nearly certain to cause real and serious harm to state security.

## The topic explained

### Review before publication

Military censorship in Israel is a form of prior restraint: a check that comes before publication, not after it. Its legal basis is the Defence (Emergency) Regulations of 1945, from the British Mandate, which allow the censor to ban a publication that would harm the defense of the state, public safety or public order, and to require material to be submitted in advance. In practice newspapers, broadcasters and news sites send items on defined security subjects to the censor, who approves them, cuts part or bans them.

The censor is appointed by the Minister of Defense and is traditionally a senior army officer, but in deciding about a publication the censor is not meant to take orders from the minister or the chief of staff. The common mistake is to think the censor checks all news. It deals only with security information, not with criticism of the government or the army as such.

### The agreement and the court

Since 1949 the censorship has worked largely through an agreement between the army and the editors of the main media, and disputes can go to a committee of three: a representative of the army, one of the media and a representative of the public, who chairs it. A new agreement in May 1996 limited censorship to material whose publication would, with near certainty, cause real harm to state security, and confirmed the media's right to petition the High Court.

The decisive ruling came earlier. In the Schnitzer case, decided on 10 January 1989, the censor had banned parts of a column in the Tel Aviv weekly Ha'Ir that criticized the outgoing head of the Mossad. Justice Aharon Barak wrote that regulations from the Mandate must be read in light of democratic values, and that the censor may restrict publication only where there is a near certainty of substantial and grave harm to security, a standard that is especially demanding for prior restraint. The censor had not shown such a danger, and the column was allowed.

### Censorship in practice

Censorship is not rare. According to figures published by the media-watch site The Seventh Eye in 2021, between 2016 and June 2021 the censor banned on average about 300 articles a year in full and cut about 2,300 in part. Since 2012 it has also watched blogs and social networks.

The internet has made the task harder. Information published abroad cannot be stopped there, so Israeli media often report it with the phrase “according to foreign sources”, which tells readers that the information comes from outside and has passed the censor in that form. A ban at home may also draw attention to a story already circulating elsewhere.

### Security and the right to know

Supporters of censorship say that in a country facing real military threats, publishing the details of operations, weapons or intelligence sources can cost lives, and that a professional censor bound by the near certainty test is safer than leaving every editor to judge alone. Critics answer that prior review gives the state power over the news, that its decisions are mostly secret and hard to challenge, and that the public needs information to judge how security is managed. Both sides accept that some information must be protected; they differ on how much and who decides.

A strong exam answer explains prior restraint, names the 1945 regulations, the editors' agreement and the committee of three, explains the Schnitzer test and gives both sides.

## Practice: military censorship in Israel

For 11th grade communications students. The items in the cases are made up. Answer from what is printed here, then check yourself against the answers.

1. **What is prior restraint, and why is military censorship an example of it?** — A restriction applied before publication rather than after it. Military censorship reviews security items before they are published and may cut or ban them.
2. **Fill in the missing step in the diagram.** — The censor approves the item, cuts part of it or bans it.
3. **Fill in the missing row of the table: who sits on the committee of three?** — A representative of the army, a representative of the media and a representative of the public, who chairs it.
4. **What did the Supreme Court decide in the Schnitzer case (1989)?** — That the censor may restrict publication only where there is a near certainty of substantial and grave harm to state security, a standard especially demanding for prior restraint; the column criticizing the head of the Mossad was allowed.
5. **Apply the test: (a) a made-up item gives the planned route of a secret operation tomorrow; (b) a made-up column argues that the army's budget is badly managed. Which could the censor stop?** — (a) Could be stopped: publishing the route of an operation could, with near certainty, cause real harm. (b) Could not: criticism of how security is managed is not security information and does not meet the test.
6. **Read the chart. Roughly how many times more articles were cut in part than banned in full? Show the calculation.** — 2,300 ÷ 300 ≈ 7.7, so roughly eight times as many were cut in part as were banned in full.
7. **Why do Israeli media sometimes write “according to foreign sources”?** — To report information already published abroad, which the censor cannot stop there; the phrase tells readers that the information comes from outside, as it was allowed to appear.
8. **Is military censorship justified in a democracy? Write a short balanced answer and a conclusion.** — A good answer gives the case for (details of operations or sources can cost lives, and a professional censor bound by the near certainty test is safer than each editor alone) and the case against (prior review gives the state power over news, decisions are secret and hard to challenge, and the public needs information to judge security policy), and concludes with a reasoned view.

## Common questions

### On what law is Israeli military censorship based?

On the Defence (Emergency) Regulations of 1945, from the British Mandate, which Israel kept. They let the censor ban publications that would harm state defense, public safety or public order, and require material to be submitted in advance.

### What was the Schnitzer case?

A 1989 Supreme Court ruling, written by Justice Aharon Barak, on a censored column that criticized the head of the Mossad. It held that the censor may restrict publication only where there is a near certainty of substantial and grave harm to security.

### What is the committee of three?

A body for disputes between the media and the censor, with a representative of the army, one of the media and a representative of the public who chairs it. A medium that disagrees can also petition the High Court.

### Does the censor check social media?

Since 2012 the censor has monitored blogs and social networks and has asked some online writers to submit security items. It cannot control sites under foreign jurisdiction, which makes enforcement online difficult.

### Is criticism of the army censored?

No. The censor deals with security information, such as details of operations or intelligence, not with opinions. Criticism of the army or of security policy does not meet the near certainty test and may be published.
