# When can the media publish private information?

> Written with AI · [Communications: media ethics and law in Israel](https://lessoons.com/en/media-ethics-and-law) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/media-ethics-and-law/when-can-the-media-publish-private-information

In Israel the media may publish private information about a person when the person consents, or when a public interest justifies the infringement and the publication is true, under section 18 of the Protection of Privacy Law of 1981. Without consent or such an interest, photographing a person in a private place, or publishing about their intimate life or health, is an infringement of privacy.

## The topic explained

### What the law protects

Whether the media may publish private information is answered first by Israel's Protection of Privacy Law, 1981. It opens with a short rule: no person shall infringe another's privacy without consent. Section 2 then lists what counts as an infringement. For journalists the most important items are photographing a person while they are in the private domain, such as their home; publishing a person's photograph in circumstances that may humiliate them; publishing an identifiable photograph of an injured person taken at the time of the injury, in a way that may embarrass them; and publishing matters of a person's intimate life, including their sexual history, health or conduct in private. Deliberate infringement can be a criminal offense, with up to five years in prison.

The common misreading is that any photograph of a person without permission is forbidden. Taking a picture of someone in a public street is not itself on the list; what matters is where it was taken, what it shows, and how it is published.

### The defenses

Section 18 gives the defenses. The most important for the press is the public interest defense: the infringement is justified if there was a public interest in it in the circumstances, provided that, where it was a publication, it was not false. Other defenses cover publications protected under the defamation law, such as reports of court proceedings, and acts done in good faith in listed circumstances.

Public interest is not the same as what interests the public. Many readers would click on a famous actor's medical file; that curiosity is not a public interest. The test asks whether the information matters for public life: how power is used, how public money is spent, whether the public is in danger.

### The ethics code adds its own rules

The Israel Press Council's ethics code goes further than the law in some respects. It asks journalists to publish material touching a person's privacy only with consent or a public interest, and then only as much as needed. It restricts identifying photographs of people who were killed or seriously injured until their families have been told, unless there is an exceptional public interest, and it gives special protection to minors and to victims of sexual offenses. A journalist can be within the law and still break the code, for example by printing more intimate detail than the story requires.

### Weighing real-looking cases

Take three made-up cases. A photographer shoots a famous singer through the window of her home: an infringement in the private domain with no public interest, so it should not be published. A reporter obtains documents showing that a public official secretly arranged a deal that benefits him: private financial details, but a clear public interest in how public power is used, so publication is justified, limited to what the story needs and with a chance to respond. A news site has a sharp photo of a crash victim's face: the accident is news, the victim's identity usually is not, so the face is blurred.

Public figures have less privacy than private people where their public role is concerned, but not none: a politician's votes are fair game, a child's school report is not. A strong exam answer cites the section of the law, applies the public interest test with reasons, and adds what the ethics code requires.

## Practice: privacy and the press

For 11th grade communications students. Every person and case here is made up. Answer from what is printed on the page; this is a learning exercise, not legal advice.

1. **Which of these is listed in section 2 as an infringement of privacy: (a) photographing a person inside their home without consent; (b) quoting a minister's public speech; (c) publishing a person's medical diagnosis without consent?** — (a) and (c): photographing in the private domain and publishing a matter concerning a person's health. (b) is a public statement and not an infringement.
2. **Fill in the missing item in the table.** — A humiliating photo: section 2(4), publishing a person's photograph in public in circumstances that may humiliate or disgrace them.
3. **Which question is missing from the order of checking, and which section of the law does it come from?** — Is there a public interest that justifies the infringement? It comes from section 18(3), which also requires that the publication be true.
4. **A student writes: “Readers really want to know about the actor's illness, so there is a public interest.” Correct the sentence.** — Curiosity is not a public interest. A public interest concerns matters important to public life, such as the use of power or public money or a danger to the public; an actor's illness usually is not one.
5. **Fill in the missing decision in the table and explain it.** — Blur it: the accident is news, but the victim's identity usually is not, and the law and the ethics code protect injured people from identifiable photos taken at the moment of injury.
6. **Is it forbidden to photograph a person walking in a public street? Explain.** — Not as such: photographing in a public place is not itself listed as an infringement. Publication may still infringe privacy if the photo humiliates the person, shows an intimate matter, or exploits their image for profit.
7. **What does the Press Council code add to the law about photos of people who were killed or badly injured?** — It restricts publishing identifying photos of them until their families have been told, unless there is an exceptional public interest.
8. **A made-up news site learns that a famous footballer's teenage son failed his exams. Should it publish? Write a short balanced answer with a conclusion.** — A good answer weighs the public's curiosity about a famous family against the son's privacy and his being a minor with no public role, notes that there is no public interest in his grades, and concludes that the site should not publish.

## Common questions

### Do public figures have a right to privacy?

Yes, though less where their public role is concerned. Information about how they use public power or money can be published in the public interest; their family life, health or home usually stays private unless it bears directly on their public duties.

### What is the public interest defense?

Section 18(3) of the Protection of Privacy Law: an infringement is justified if a public interest justified it in the circumstances, provided that a publication was not false. Courts weigh the importance of the information against the harm to privacy.

### Can the media publish a photo of a crowd?

Usually yes. Photographing in a public place is not itself an infringement. Problems arise if a person in the photo is shown in a humiliating situation, in an intimate matter, or is identifiable as a victim at the moment of injury.

### What is the penalty for infringing privacy in Israel?

Infringement is a civil wrong for which the injured person can sue, and deliberate infringement in most of the listed ways is also a criminal offense with up to five years in prison, under section 5 of the law.

### How is privacy different from defamation?

Defamation protects a person's good name against statements that may humiliate or harm them; privacy protects their private life even when what is published is true and not insulting. A true report of someone's illness can infringe privacy without being defamatory.
