# What is cultivation theory?

> Written with AI · [Media effects theories](https://lessoons.com/en/media-effects-theories) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/media-effects-theories/what-is-cultivation-theory

Cultivation theory says that years of heavy television viewing slowly bring a viewer's beliefs about the real world closer to the world shown on the screen. George Gerbner and Larry Gross set it out in 1976. Heavy viewers, for example, tend to see the world as more dangerous than light viewers do, an effect Gerbner called the mean world syndrome.

## The topic explained

### What the theory says

Cultivation theory asks what a lifetime of television does to the way people see reality. George Gerbner, dean of the Annenberg School for Communication at the University of Pennsylvania, began the Cultural Indicators project in 1968 to study it, and with Larry Gross set out the theory in Living with Television: The Violence Profile (1976). The idea is that television tells the same kinds of stories again and again, and that years of heavy viewing slowly cultivate, like a farmer growing a crop, a picture of the world that is closer to those stories.

The research had two parts. Message system analysis counted what television shows, such as how much violence appears in prime-time drama. Cultivation analysis then asked viewers about the real world. The most common mistake is to say the theory claims that violent television makes people violent. That is a different question. Cultivation is about beliefs: how dangerous the world seems, how much people can be trusted.

### Heavy viewers, light viewers and the mean world

Gerbner's team compared heavy viewers, who watched more than four hours a day, with light viewers, who watched less than two. They asked questions with two possible answers, one closer to the facts and one closer to the television world, and looked at who chose the television answer. The difference between heavy and light viewers of similar age, sex and education is called the cultivation differential.

Heavy viewers more often overestimated the danger of violence and agreed that most people cannot be trusted. Gerbner called this the mean world syndrome. The effect is meant to be slow and cumulative: not one frightening program, but thousands of hours of the same kind of story.

### Mainstreaming and resonance

In 1980 Gerbner and his colleagues added two ideas. Mainstreaming: among light viewers, different groups hold quite different views, but among heavy viewers those differences shrink, as if television pulls everyone toward one shared outlook. Resonance: when what people see on the screen matches what they live, the effect grows, a double dose. A made-up example: a viewer who has been robbed and also watches a lot of crime drama may come to fear crime even more than other heavy viewers.

### Criticism, and cultivation today

Paul Hirsch (1980) reanalyzed the data and found that once other factors were controlled together, the effect became very small. The effect is also a correlation, and the cause may run the other way: people who are afraid may stay home and watch more television. Michael Morgan and James Shanahan's 1997 meta-analysis of twenty years of studies found an average effect of only .09: small, but steady across studies. Defenders reply that a small effect spread across a whole population over years still matters.

The theory was built for a few channels that everyone watched. With streaming and social media, viewers choose very different diets, so researchers now test cultivation by genre, such as crime shows, rather than by hours of television in general. A strong exam answer defines the theory, names Gerbner, explains heavy and light viewers, and adds one criticism.

## Practice: cultivation theory

For 11th grade students of communications. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Who developed cultivation theory, and what does the word cultivation suggest about how the effect works?** — George Gerbner, with Larry Gross (1976). Like growing a crop, the effect is slow and builds up over years of heavy viewing; it is not the effect of a single program.
2. **Complete the last box of the diagram.** — Beliefs about the real world that come closer to the television world, such as seeing the world as more dangerous than it is.
3. **A student writes: “Cultivation theory says violent TV makes viewers violent.” What is wrong with the sentence, and how would you correct it?** — Cultivation is about beliefs, not behavior. A better sentence: cultivation theory says heavy viewing makes viewers' beliefs about the world, such as how dangerous it is, closer to the television world.
4. **Why did Gerbner's team compare heavy and light viewers of similar age, sex and education, rather than all heavy and all light viewers?** — To rule out other explanations: if the two groups differ only in how much they watch, a difference in their answers (the cultivation differential) points to television rather than to age, sex or education.
5. **Mainstreaming or resonance? Write the term for each case in the table: (a) among heavy viewers, two groups whose views were far apart now hold similar views; (b) a viewer who lives in a neighborhood with a lot of crime and watches crime dramas every night fears crime most of all.** — (a) Mainstreaming: heavy viewing pulls different groups toward one shared outlook. (b) Resonance: the screen matches the viewer's own life, so the effect is doubled.
6. **A made-up survey finds that people who watch more television are more afraid to walk alone at night. Give two reasons why this does not prove that television caused the fear.** — It is a correlation. The cause may run the other way: fearful people stay home and watch more. And a third factor, such as age or living in a dangerous area, may cause both, as Hirsch (1980) argued when he controlled other factors.
7. **Does cultivation theory still apply when each person streams different shows? Argue for and against, and conclude.** — A good answer argues that repeated stories still shape beliefs within a genre, such as crime shows, so cultivation can be tested by genre (for); that there is no longer one shared television world for everyone, and the effects were small to begin with, about .09 on average (against); and draws a reasoned conclusion.

## Common questions

### What is the mean world syndrome?

Gerbner's name for a finding of cultivation research: heavy television viewers are more likely than light viewers to see the world as dangerous and to believe that most people cannot be trusted, because television drama shows so much more violence than everyday life.

### What is the difference between cultivation and agenda setting?

Agenda setting is about which issues seem important, and it works through the news over weeks. Cultivation is about the whole picture of reality, how dangerous or fair the world seems, and it works through years of all kinds of television, drama included.

### Is cultivation theory still relevant?

Researchers still use it, and meta-analyses find a small but steady effect. Today it is usually tested by genre or platform, such as crime drama, reality shows or social media, because viewers no longer share the same few channels.

### What are the main criticisms of cultivation theory?

The effects are small (an average of .09 in a 1997 meta-analysis); they shrink when other factors are controlled (Hirsch, 1980); the data are correlations, so the cause may run the other way; and the theory treats television as one uniform message.

### Why is it called cultivation?

Because the effect is pictured as growth, like a crop in a field: not a sudden change caused by one program, but a slow, cumulative shaping of beliefs through years of the same kinds of stories.
