# What is agenda setting theory?

> Written with AI · [Media effects theories](https://lessoons.com/en/media-effects-theories) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/media-effects-theories/what-is-agenda-setting-theory

Agenda setting theory says that the news media shape which issues the public thinks are most important, by choosing what to cover, how often and how prominently. Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw first tested it in the 1968 Chapel Hill study, published in 1972. In short, the media may not tell people what to think, but they strongly influence what people think about.

## The topic explained

### What the theory says

Agenda setting theory describes how the news media influence the importance people give to issues. Every day editors choose a few stories from thousands, put some on the front page and keep some running for weeks. The media agenda is the list of issues ranked by how much coverage each gets; the public agenda is the list ranked by how many people name each issue as the most important. The theory says the first shapes the second.

The idea goes back to the political scientist Bernard Cohen, who wrote in 1963 that the press often fails to tell people what to think but succeeds remarkably in telling them “what to think about”. The most common mistake is to write that agenda setting means the media change people's opinions. It is about salience, how important an issue seems, not about which side a person takes.

### The Chapel Hill study, 1968

Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw tested the idea during the 1968 American presidential campaign. They asked 100 undecided voters in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, which issues mattered most, and measured the coverage in the nine news sources those voters used: four local newspapers, The New York Times, Time, Newsweek and the evening news on NBC and CBS. The two rankings matched almost perfectly, with a correlation above 0.9. The study was published in 1972.

A correlation does not show which came first: perhaps the media simply covered what voters already cared about. Experiments answered that. In News That Matters (1987), Shanto Iyengar and Donald Kinder showed viewers newscasts edited to add stories on one issue, and afterwards those viewers rated that issue as more important than viewers who had not seen the added stories.

### The second level: from what to how

Later research added a second level, also called attribute agenda setting. The first level is about objects: which issues people think about. The second is about attributes: which features of an issue stand out, and so how people picture it. It is close to framing, the choice of the angle from which a story is told.

A made-up example: two news sites cover electric scooters for a month. One returns again and again to injuries, the other to cheap, quick travel around the city. Readers of both may come to rank scooters as an important issue, which is the first level. Readers of the first site, though, picture scooters mainly as a danger, which is the second level.

### Limits and criticism

The effect is not equally strong for everyone. Harold Zucker (1978) found it clearest for unobtrusive issues, ones people do not meet in their own lives, such as a conflict far away, and weaker for issues they feel directly, such as prices. David Weaver (1977) proposed the need for orientation: people who are interested in a subject and unsure about it follow the media agenda most.

Critics add that the audience is not passive, that broad issue categories can inflate the correlations, and that influence also runs the other way, from the public to the media. With hundreds of channels, sites and feeds, people today may follow very different agendas. A strong exam answer defines the term, cites McCombs and Shaw (1972), gives an example and names one limit.

## Practice: agenda setting theory

For 11th grade students of communications. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Define the media agenda and the public agenda, one sentence each.** — The media agenda is the list of issues ranked by how much coverage each gets. The public agenda is the list of issues ranked by how many people name each one as the most important.
2. **Who first tested agenda setting, during which campaign, and with whom? Give the year the study was published.** — Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw, during the 1968 American presidential campaign, with 100 undecided voters in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. It was published in 1972.
3. **The table shows a made-up week of news. Do the two rankings support agenda setting? Explain, and say what the table cannot prove.** — Yes: the rankings almost match (heat wave and rail line in the same place, the two middle issues swapped). But a match is a correlation; it cannot show whether the coverage raised the issues in the public's mind or followed what the public already cared about.
4. **In an experiment like Iyengar and Kinder's, group A watches newscasts with added stories on one issue and group B watches the same newscasts without them. What result supports agenda setting, and why does an experiment show cause where a survey cannot?** — Group A rates the issue as more important than group B. Since the two groups were matched and only the added stories differed, the stories caused the difference, which a survey correlation cannot show.
5. **First level or second level? (a) After weeks of drought reports, more people name water as the country's top issue. (b) Reviews keep describing a new phone by its battery problems, and buyers come to describe it the same way.** — (a) First level: the coverage raised the importance of an issue. (b) Second level: the coverage made one attribute of the object stand out and shaped how people picture it.
6. **For which issue would you expect a stronger agenda setting effect: the price of bread, or a disease outbreak in a distant country? Use a term from the lesson.** — The outbreak abroad. It is an unobtrusive issue, which people know only through the media, while the price of bread is felt directly at the store (Zucker, 1978).
7. **Bernard Cohen wrote that the press tells people “what to think about”. Explain the difference between that and telling them what to think, give an example, and name one criticism of the theory.** — A good answer says that agenda setting changes how important an issue seems (salience), not the opinion people hold about it; gives an example, such as more coverage of road accidents leading more people to name road safety as a top issue; and names a criticism: correlation is not cause, the audience is active, or today's fragmented media.

## Common questions

### Who created agenda setting theory?

Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw named and tested it in their Chapel Hill study of the 1968 campaign, published in 1972. They built on Walter Lippmann's Public Opinion (1922), about the pictures in our heads, and on Bernard Cohen's 1963 remark that the press tells people what to think about.

### What is the difference between agenda setting and framing?

Agenda setting, the first level, is about which issues seem important. Framing is about the angle from which an issue is presented, which shapes how people understand it. Second-level agenda setting, about the attributes that stand out, sits between the two and overlaps with framing.

### What is the difference between agenda setting and gatekeeping?

Gatekeeping describes selection inside the newsroom: which stories editors let through, as in David Manning White's 1950 study of a wire editor. Agenda setting describes what that selection does to the public: the issues covered most come to seem the most important.

### Does agenda setting still work in the age of social media?

Researchers still find the effect, but the picture is more complex. People follow many sources, so agendas differ more from person to person, and influence runs in several directions: news outlets pick up what trends online, and online discussion often starts from news coverage.

### How do I answer an exam question on agenda setting?

Define the theory in one sentence, cite McCombs and Shaw (1972) and the Chapel Hill study, apply it to the case in the question by naming the issue and the coverage, and add one limit, such as the difference between correlation and cause.
