# How do you allocate joint costs?

> Written with AI · [Accounting: manufacturing costs and product costing](https://lessoons.com/en/manufacturing-cost-accounting) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/manufacturing-cost-accounting/how-do-you-allocate-joint-costs

To allocate joint costs, first deduct any by-product's revenue, then divide what is left among the joint products in proportion to a chosen base: physical units, or sales value at the split-off point. The method changes each product's cost and profit but never the total, and it should not decide whether to sell or process further.

## The topic explained

### One process, several products

Some processes cannot make one product without the others. A dairy that separates milk gets cream and skim milk at once; a refinery gets petrol, diesel and gas from the same crude oil. The costs up to the moment the products part, the split-off point, are joint costs: no product caused them alone, so they must be shared out to allocate joint costs at all.

A made-up dairy separates 10,000 liters of milk at a cost of ₪31,200. It gets 2,000 liters of cream, sold at ₪12 a liter, and 8,000 liters of skim milk, sold at ₪4.50 a liter. Some whey is left over and sold for ₪1,200. The cream and the skim milk are joint products; the whey, worth little beside them, is a by-product.

### Two ways to share the cost

A common treatment deducts the by-product's revenue from the joint cost: 31,200 − 1,200 = ₪30,000 to divide. By physical units, cream gets 2,000/10,000 of the cost, ₪6,000, and skim milk ₪24,000. By sales value at split-off, cream is worth ₪24,000 and skim milk ₪36,000, so cream gets 24/60 of the cost, ₪12,000, and skim milk ₪18,000.

The units method is simple, but it charges a liter of cheap skim milk as much as a liter of valuable cream. The sales value method charges each product in line with its ability to bear the cost, so both products show the same gross margin, 50%. When a product cannot be sold at the split-off point at all, a third method uses its net realizable value: its final selling price less the costs still to be spent on it after the split-off point.

### Different profits, one total

By units, cream earns 24,000 − 6,000 = ₪18,000 and skim milk 36,000 − 24,000 = ₪12,000. By sales value, cream earns ₪12,000 and skim milk ₪18,000. The total is ₪30,000 either way, because the same ₪30,000 of cost is only being divided differently.

This is where students go wrong: they conclude that skim milk is the weaker product under one method and the stronger under the other. Neither profit is a fact about the product; each is a result of the method chosen. The dairy cannot stop making skim milk anyway, since every liter of cream comes with four liters of it.

### Sell now or process further?

The dairy could churn its cream into butter, sold for ₪30,000, at an extra cost of ₪8,000. The decision compares only what changes: extra revenue 30,000 − 24,000 = ₪6,000 against extra cost ₪8,000. Profit would fall by ₪2,000, so the dairy should sell the cream.

The ₪6,000 or ₪12,000 of joint cost charged to the cream plays no part: it is spent whichever way the dairy decides. Joint cost allocation is needed to value inventory and report profit by product, not to choose what to do after the split-off point.

## Practice: joint products and by-products

For 12th grade accounting students. A made-up sawmill cuts logs that cost ₪50,000 into 3,000 planks, sold at ₪20 each, and 1,000 beams, sold at ₪60 each. The sawdust is a by-product sold for ₪2,000. Check the answers at the end.

1. **Name the joint products and the by-product. What is the joint cost to allocate?** — Planks and beams are joint products; sawdust is a by-product. Joint cost to allocate: 50,000 − 2,000 = ₪48,000.
2. **Find the sales value of each joint product.** — Planks 3,000 × ₪20 = ₪60,000; beams 1,000 × ₪60 = ₪60,000.
3. **Allocate the ₪48,000 by units and by sales value.** — By units: planks 3,000/4,000 × 48,000 = ₪36,000; beams ₪12,000. By sales value: each has half of ₪120,000, so ₪24,000 each.
4. **Calculate the gross profit of each product under both methods.** — By units: planks 60,000 − 36,000 = ₪24,000; beams 60,000 − 12,000 = ₪48,000. By sales value: ₪36,000 each. Total ₪72,000 either way.
5. **A manager says, “By units, planks earn half as much as beams, so we should cut fewer planks.” What is wrong?** — The profit of each product depends on the allocation method, and the sawmill cannot cut beams without producing planks. The total profit is the same under any method.
6. **Varnished beams sell for ₪75 each; varnishing costs ₪10,000. Should the sawmill varnish them?** — Extra revenue 1,000 × (75 − 60) = ₪15,000; extra cost ₪10,000; profit rises by ₪5,000, so yes. The joint cost is irrelevant.
7. **Why should a by-product's revenue reduce the joint cost rather than be allocated a share of it?** — The by-product is minor; charging it a share of the cost would show a loss on something sold for whatever it fetches. Deducting its revenue lowers the cost of the main products instead.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between a joint product and a by-product?

Joint products are the main outputs of a shared process, each with a significant sales value. A by-product comes out of the same process but its value is small beside them.

### What is the split-off point?

It is the stage of a process at which the joint products become separate and identifiable. Costs before it are joint; costs after it belong to one product.

### Which joint cost allocation method is best?

The sales value method is often preferred because it charges each product in line with its value, giving equal margins. The units method is simpler but can make a cheap product look unprofitable.

### Should joint costs decide whether to process a product further?

No. The joint cost is spent whatever is decided. Process further only if the extra revenue is greater than the extra cost after the split-off point.

### Why allocate joint costs at all?

To value the inventory of each product and to report a cost and a profit for each one in the statements. The allocation is needed for reporting, not for decisions after the split-off point.
