# What is a relevant cost?

> Written with AI · [Accounting: budgeting and management decisions](https://lessoons.com/en/management-accounting-decisions) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/management-accounting-decisions/what-is-a-relevant-cost

A relevant cost is a future cost that differs between the options a manager is choosing from. Only relevant costs and revenues belong in the decision. Money already spent, a sunk cost, and costs that stay the same whatever is chosen are left out, while the benefit given up by not taking the other option, the opportunity cost, is counted.

## The topic explained

### Costs that change with the choice

Every decision compares a few options. A relevant cost is a cost that will change depending on which option is chosen: it lies in the future and it is different in each option. Every other cost, however large, cannot help choose, because it will be the same whatever the manager does.

Two questions sort any cost. Is it still to come? A cost already paid is a sunk cost: no decision can bring it back. Does it differ between the options? A cost that is the same in all of them, such as the rent of a workshop that stays open either way, cancels out. A cost that passes both questions is relevant.

### A worked decision

A made-up carpentry shop bought wood last year for ₪8,000. No customer wants the original order now. The shop can turn the wood into tables and sell them for ₪15,000, which needs ₪5,000 of extra labor, or sell the wood as it is for ₪3,000. The workshop rent of ₪4,000 a month will be paid in either case.

The ₪8,000 is sunk, and the rent is the same in both options; neither is relevant. The labor is relevant, and so is the ₪3,000: making tables means giving up the sale of the wood. That benefit given up is an opportunity cost. It never appears in the books, because no one pays it, but it is as real for the decision as the labor.

### Comparing only what changes

Making tables adds 15,000 − 5,000 = ₪10,000; selling the wood adds ₪3,000. Making tables is better by ₪7,000. The same answer comes out if the opportunity cost is charged to the tables: 15,000 − 5,000 − 3,000 = ₪7,000 more than doing nothing else with the wood.

The usual trap is to charge the ₪8,000, and perhaps the rent, to the tables: 15,000 − 5,000 − 8,000 − 4,000 shows a "loss" of ₪2,000, and the owner abandons the better option. But the ₪8,000 was lost the day the order fell through, and the rent will be paid anyway. Charging them to one option and not the other changes the answer for no reason.

### Why sunk costs are so hard to ignore

People and businesses find it painful to walk away from money they have already spent, so they keep going to "justify" it. Economists call this the sunk cost fallacy; it is also named after the Concorde airliner, whose British and French backers kept funding it partly because of what they had already spent.

Relevant does not mean large, and irrelevant does not mean unimportant. The ₪8,000 matters for judging last year's purchase and it is in the year's profit. It simply cannot help choose between options that start today. The next lessons apply the same test to special orders, buying instead of making, and dropping a product.

## Practice: relevant costs

For 12th grade accounting students. A made-up printing house has paper it bought earlier for ₪6,000. It can use the paper to print a job for a customer for ₪9,000, which needs ₪2,500 of ink and labor, or sell the paper to another printer for ₪2,000. Depreciation of the machine is ₪1,000 a month either way. Check the answers at the end.

1. **In your own words, what makes a cost relevant to a decision?** — It is still to come, and it is different in the options being compared.
2. **Decide whether each cost is relevant.** — Paper bought earlier: not relevant, sunk. Ink and labor: relevant. Depreciation: not relevant, the same in both options. Paper sale given up: relevant, an opportunity cost of the job.
3. **Complete the comparison. Which option is better, and by how much?** — Option A: extra cost ₪2,500, gain 9,000 − 2,500 = ₪6,500. Option B: gain ₪2,000. Option A is better by ₪4,500.
4. **What is the opportunity cost of printing the job?** — ₪2,000, the sale of the paper that the printing house gives up by using it for the job.
5. **A manager says: "After the ₪6,000 of paper, the job earns only ₪500, while selling the paper brings ₪2,000, so sell the paper." What is wrong?** — He charges the sunk ₪6,000 to the job only. The paper cost ₪6,000 whichever option is chosen; comparing only what changes, the job is better by ₪4,500.
6. **The customer now offers only ₪4,000 for the job. What does the job add, and which option is better?** — 4,000 − 2,500 = ₪1,500, less than the ₪2,000 from selling the paper, so selling the paper is now better by ₪500.
7. **A company has spent ₪50,000 developing a product that now looks unlikely to sell. A manager says it must be launched "so the money is not wasted". How would you answer?** — The ₪50,000 is sunk and will not come back either way. The decision should compare only the future revenue and costs of launching with those of stopping; continuing to recover past spending is the sunk cost fallacy.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between a relevant cost and a sunk cost?

A relevant cost is still to come and differs between the options. A sunk cost has already been paid and cannot be recovered whatever is decided, so it is left out of the decision.

### Is an opportunity cost a relevant cost?

Yes. The benefit given up by not taking another option changes with the choice, so it belongs in the comparison, even though it is never recorded in the books.

### Are fixed costs always irrelevant?

No. A fixed cost that stays the same in every option is irrelevant, but a fixed cost that one option adds or removes, such as renting an extra machine, is relevant.

### Is depreciation a relevant cost?

Usually not. Depreciation spreads the cost of an asset already bought, so it does not change with the decision. A cost to buy a new asset for one option is relevant.

### What is the sunk cost fallacy?

Continuing with a plan because of money or effort already spent, even when the future costs outweigh the future benefits. The past spending cannot be recovered, so it should not decide.
