# How do you decide whether to make or buy?

> Written with AI · [Accounting: budgeting and management decisions](https://lessoons.com/en/management-accounting-decisions) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/management-accounting-decisions/how-do-you-decide-whether-to-make-or-buy

To decide whether to make or buy a part, compare the supplier's price with the costs the business would actually avoid by stopping production, not with the full cost per unit. Fixed costs that stay either way are left out. If the space or machines freed could earn something else, add that opportunity cost to the cost of making.

## The topic explained

### A supplier's offer

A made-up bicycle maker produces the 4,000 seats it needs each year. Its cost sheet says a seat costs ₪85: materials ₪30, labor ₪20, variable overhead ₪10 and ₪25 of fixed overhead allocated to each seat. A supplier offers to deliver the same seats for ₪72. The cost sheet seems to say: buy, and save 13 × 4,000 = ₪52,000 a year.

To decide whether to make or buy, the right question is not what a seat costs on the cost sheet but which costs would actually disappear if the factory stopped making seats. Materials, labor and variable overhead would. Of the ₪25 of fixed overhead, only ₪8 would: the salary of a supervisor who works only on seats, ₪32,000 a year. The other ₪17 a seat, ₪68,000 of rent, insurance and management, stays whatever is decided.

### Comparing what really changes

The avoidable cost of making is 30 + 20 + 10 + 8 = ₪68 a seat, ₪272,000 a year. Buying costs 72 × 4,000 = ₪288,000. Making is cheaper by ₪16,000, the opposite of what the cost sheet suggested.

This is the misreading to avoid. The ₪68,000 of fixed overhead does not leave with the seats: if the factory buys, those costs are simply spread over the bicycles instead, and the factory pays the supplier on top of them. Comparing the supplier's price with full cost counts them as a saving that never comes. A useful habit is to compare totals for the whole year rather than costs per unit: an annual total cannot hide a fixed cost inside a per-unit figure, and it shows at once how much money each option takes out of the bank.

### When the space could earn money

Now suppose a neighbor would rent the space used for seats for ₪30,000 a year once production stops. Making seats means giving up that rent, an opportunity cost of making. The cost of making for the decision becomes 272,000 + 30,000 = ₪302,000, against ₪288,000 to buy. Buying is now cheaper by ₪14,000.

The same factory, with the same cost sheet, reaches the opposite answer, because one option frees something that has another use. The opportunity cost never appears in the accounts, which is exactly why it is easy to forget.

### Beyond the numbers

A make-or-buy decision is rarely only arithmetic. A supplier may deliver late or cut quality, and a part no longer made in-house is hard to bring back: the workers, the machines and the know-how are gone. On the other side, a specialist supplier may make the part better, and buying frees managers to concentrate on what the business does best.

So the calculation sets a price at which the two options are equal, here ₪68 a seat without the rent and ₪75.50 with it, and the manager weighs the qualitative points around it. A supplier's offer only a little cheaper than that price rarely justifies the risks of depending on it.

## Practice: make or buy

For 12th grade accounting students. A made-up toy factory makes 10,000 boxes a year. A box costs ₪17: materials ₪6, labor ₪4, variable overhead ₪2, ₪1 of fixed overhead that would end if production stopped, and ₪4 of allocated fixed overhead that would remain. A supplier offers boxes at ₪14. Check the answers at the end.

1. **What is an avoidable cost in a make-or-buy decision?** — A cost that would disappear if the business stopped making the part and bought it instead.
2. **Decide which costs are avoided if the boxes are bought.** — Materials, labor, variable overhead and the ₪1 of avoidable fixed overhead: yes. The ₪4 of allocated fixed overhead: no, it remains.
3. **Calculate the avoidable cost of making the year's boxes and compare it with buying.** — Avoidable cost 6 + 4 + 2 + 1 = ₪13 a box, ₪130,000 a year, against 14 × 10,000 = ₪140,000 to buy. Making is cheaper by ₪10,000.
4. **The production manager compares ₪17 with ₪14 and recommends buying. What is wrong?** — The ₪17 includes ₪4 of fixed overhead that stays if the boxes are bought. Comparing full cost with the price treats ₪40,000 a year as a saving that never happens.
5. **If the factory buys, it can rent the freed space for ₪15,000 a year. Complete the comparison.** — Cost of making 130,000 + 15,000 = ₪145,000 against ₪140,000 to buy; buying is cheaper by ₪5,000.
6. **At what supplier's price per box would making and buying cost the same, without the rent and with it?** — Without the rent: ₪13 a box. With it: 13 + 15,000 ÷ 10,000 = ₪14.50 a box.
7. **Give two reasons the factory might keep making the boxes even if buying were slightly cheaper.** — For example: control over quality and delivery dates, keeping the workers and know-how, not depending on a single supplier, or the risk that the supplier raises its price later.

## Common questions

### What is a make-or-buy decision?

The choice between producing a part or service inside the business and buying it from an outside supplier. It compares the costs avoided by not producing with the price of buying.

### Why is full cost misleading in a make-or-buy decision?

Full cost includes allocated fixed costs that remain whether the part is made or bought. Counting them as a saving makes buying look cheaper than it really is.

### What is an avoidable cost?

A cost that disappears if an activity stops, such as the materials and labor of a part, or a supervisor employed only for it. Avoidable costs are the relevant costs of making.

### How does opportunity cost affect make or buy?

If buying frees space or machines that could earn money in another use, that income is given up by making. It is added to the cost of making in the comparison.

### What qualitative factors matter in make or buy?

Quality, reliability of supply, delivery times, the know-how and workers the business would lose, and how dependent it would become on one supplier.
