# How do you decide whether to accept a special order?

> Written with AI · [Accounting: budgeting and management decisions](https://lessoons.com/en/management-accounting-decisions) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/management-accounting-decisions/how-do-you-decide-whether-to-accept-a-special-order

To decide whether to accept a special order, compare the extra revenue it brings with the extra costs it causes. If the factory has idle capacity, accept when the price covers the variable cost of each unit plus any cost the order adds; fixed costs paid anyway do not count. Without idle capacity, the contribution of regular sales given up is a cost too.

## The topic explained

### An offer below the usual price

A made-up backpack factory can make 10,000 backpacks a year and sells 8,000 at ₪120 each. Each backpack costs ₪70 in variable costs, materials, labor and power, and the factory's fixed costs are ₪200,000 a year. A chain of school shops abroad offers to buy 1,500 backpacks at ₪85, a one-time order that will not touch the regular customers.

To decide whether to accept a special order, ask what changes if the factory says yes. The 1,500 backpacks bring 1,500 × 85 = ₪127,500 and cost 1,500 × 70 = ₪105,000 in variable costs, plus ₪3,000 of extra shipping. The fixed costs of ₪200,000 are paid whether the order comes or not.

### Full cost is the wrong yardstick

Spread over the 8,000 regular backpacks, the fixed costs are ₪25 a unit, so the full cost of a backpack is 70 + 25 = ₪95. A manager who compares the offer with that figure sees ₪85 against ₪95 and rejects it as a loss of ₪10 a unit.

That is the classic misreading. The ₪25 is not a cost the order causes; the factory pays it anyway. Each special unit brings ₪15 more than the cost it adds, its contribution: 1,500 × 15 = ₪22,500, less the ₪3,000 of shipping, ₪19,500 more profit. The relevant comparison is the price against the variable cost and any cost the order adds. Full cost still has its place: over the long run, regular prices must cover every cost, fixed ones included. It misleads only for a one-off decision made with spare capacity.

### Checking it on the whole factory

The safest check is to work out the factory's profit both ways. Without the order: sales of ₪960,000 less variable costs of ₪560,000 and fixed costs of ₪200,000 leave ₪200,000. With it: sales of ₪1,087,500 less variable costs of ₪665,000 and fixed costs of ₪203,000 leave ₪219,500, exactly ₪19,500 more.

Two conditions sit behind this answer: the regular customers must not hear of the price and ask for the same, and the order must fit in the idle capacity. A business that sells too much below its usual price can teach its own customers to wait for a discount.

### When the factory is already full

Suppose the chain wants 2,500 backpacks. With 8,000 regular sales and room for 10,000, the factory can fit only 2,000 extra; 500 regular backpacks would be lost, each with a contribution of 120 − 70 = ₪50. That ₪25,000 is an opportunity cost of the order. The order adds 2,500 × 15 = ₪37,500, so profit still rises by ₪12,500.

The lowest price that leaves profit unchanged is the variable cost plus the lost contribution spread over the order: 70 + 25,000 ÷ 2,500 = ₪80 a backpack. At ₪78, the order would cost ₪5,000 of profit, and the factory should refuse.

## Practice: special orders

For 12th grade accounting students. A made-up ceramics workshop can make 5,000 mugs a year and sells 4,000 at ₪40. The variable cost of a mug is ₪22 and fixed costs are ₪30,000 a year. A company asks for 800 mugs at ₪26 each with its logo, which adds ₪1 a mug. Check the answers at the end.

1. **Why are the workshop's fixed costs left out of the decision?** — They are ₪30,000 whether the order is accepted or not, so they do not change with the decision.
2. **Complete the calculation of the order.** — Contribution a unit 26 − 23 = ₪3; change in profit 3 × 800 = ₪2,400.
3. **The manager says the full cost of a mug is ₪29.50, so ₪26 means a loss. Is he right?** — No. The full cost, 22 + 30,000 ÷ 4,000 = ₪29.50, includes ₪7.50 of fixed costs the order does not cause. The order adds ₪23 a mug and brings ₪26, so it adds ₪3 a mug.
4. **Complete the profit table with the order.** — Sales 160,000 + 800 × 26 = ₪180,800; variable costs 88,000 + 800 × 23 = ₪106,400; fixed costs ₪30,000; profit ₪44,400, ₪2,400 more than ₪42,000.
5. **The company now asks for 1,500 mugs at the same price. The workshop can make only 5,000. Should it accept?** — Only 1,000 fit; 500 regular mugs are lost, with a contribution of 40 − 22 = ₪18 each, ₪9,000. The order adds 1,500 × 3 = ₪4,500. Profit falls by ₪4,500, so it should refuse at ₪26.
6. **What is the lowest price per mug for the order of 1,500 that leaves profit unchanged?** — 22 + 1 + 9,000 ÷ 1,500 = ₪29 a mug.
7. **Name two considerations, beyond this year's profit, before accepting a special order.** — For example: regular customers may ask for the same low price; the order may block capacity for a better order later; the buyer may become a regular customer; quality and delivery dates must be met.

## Common questions

### What is a special order in accounting?

A one-time offer to buy goods at a price different from the usual one, often lower. The decision rests on how the order changes total profit, not on the average cost per unit.

### Why are fixed costs ignored in a special order decision?

Fixed costs that stay the same whether or not the order is accepted do not change profit by accepting it. Only fixed costs the order adds, such as special tools, are counted.

### What is the minimum price for a special order?

With idle capacity, the variable cost of each unit plus any cost the order adds. Without idle capacity, add the contribution of the regular sales given up, spread over the order.

### What if accepting the order means losing regular sales?

The contribution of the lost regular sales becomes a cost of the order. The order is worth accepting only if its own contribution is larger than the contribution given up.

### Can a special order hurt a business even if it adds profit?

Yes. Regular customers may demand the same price, or the order may take capacity needed for better business later. These effects are weighed beside the calculation.
