# What is a budget deficit?

> Written with AI · [Economics: growth, inflation and the policy toolbox](https://lessoons.com/en/macroeconomics) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/macroeconomics/what-is-a-budget-deficit

A budget deficit is the amount by which a government's spending in a year exceeds its revenue, mostly taxes. The gap is borrowed, so each deficit adds to the public debt. A country that spends ₪500 billion and collects ₪450 billion runs a ₪50 billion deficit; with a GDP of ₪2,000 billion, that is 2.5% of GDP.

## The topic explained

### Revenue, spending and the gap

A state budget is a list of choices about who pays and who receives. On one side stand revenues: income tax, VAT and other taxes. On the other stand expenditures: education, health and welfare, defense, and the interest on past borrowing. In Israel the budget is passed by the Knesset each year as a law.

When spending is larger than revenue, the difference is a budget deficit; when revenue is larger, a surplus. In the model country in the table, spending of 500 against revenue of 450 (₪ billion) gives a deficit of 50. To compare countries of different sizes, the deficit is divided by GDP: 50/2000 = 2.5% of GDP.

### Deficit and debt are not the same

The deficit is a flow, measured over a year; the public debt is a stock, everything still owed at a moment. The deficit is financed by selling government bonds, so each year's deficit is added to the debt: 1,200 becomes 1,250, then 1,300.

What matters for the burden is the debt-to-GDP ratio, the debt divided by the economy's yearly output. If nominal GDP grows 4% a year, from 2,000 to 2,080 and then to about 2,163, the ratio goes from 1200/2000 = 60% to about 60.1% and stays there, although the debt itself keeps rising. A large deficit in a slow-growing economy, or rising interest rates on the debt, push the ratio up.

### Automatic stabilizers

Part of the deficit moves with the business cycle without anyone deciding anything. In a recession incomes and profits fall, so income tax and VAT bring in less; more people are out of work, so unemployment benefits cost more. The deficit widens by itself, and the money it leaves with households keeps their spending from falling as far. In a boom the same mechanisms work the other way and the deficit shrinks.

These are the automatic stabilizers. They explain why a deficit that grows in a recession is not, on its own, a sign of a careless government; economists separate it from the structural deficit, the part that would remain in a normal year.

### Who pays: a progressive or a flat tax

Take three yearly incomes: ₪60,000, ₪150,000 and ₪400,000. A flat tax of 20% takes 12,000, 30,000 and 80,000. A progressive tax, with the invented brackets of 10% up to ₪100,000, 30% to ₪300,000 and 45% above, takes 6,000, 25,000 and 115,000: an average rate of 10%, about 16.7% and 28.75%. Each bracket's marginal rate applies only to the part of income inside it, so a raise never lowers take-home pay.

Supporters of progressive taxes stress fairness: a shekel matters more to a poor household. Supporters of flatter taxes stress incentives and simplicity. The bagrut asks for both arguments, not for a verdict.

## Practice: the budget deficit

For 12th grade economics students. Use the tables and figures on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Define a budget deficit and the public debt. Which is a flow and which is a stock?** — Deficit: spending minus revenue in one year. Public debt: the total the government owes at a moment. The deficit is a flow; the debt is a stock, and each deficit adds to it.
2. **Fill in the two missing cells of the table.** — Deficit: 410 - 380 = 30 billion shekels. As a share of GDP: 30/1500 = 2%.
3. **The same country starts the year with a debt of ₪900 billion, and its GDP grows by 4%. Find the debt and the debt-to-GDP ratio at the end of the year, and compare with the start.** — Debt: 900 + 30 = 930. GDP: 1500 · 1.04 = 1560. Ratio: 930/1560 ≈ 59.6%, down from 900/1500 = 60%: the debt grew, but GDP grew faster.
4. **Fill in the two blank boxes of the flow for a boom, and explain why the deficit shrinks without a decision.** — Tax receipts rise and fewer people draw unemployment benefits. Revenue rises and spending falls automatically, so the deficit shrinks; this restrains spending and cools the boom a little.
5. **Use the bracket table. Compute the tax on a yearly income of ₪250,000 and the average tax rate.** — 10% · 100,000 + 30% · 150,000 = 10,000 + 45,000 = 55,000 shekels. Average rate: 55,000250,000 = 22%.
6. **With the same brackets, Maya earns ₪100,000 and gets a raise of ₪1,000. A friend warns her that she will now pay 30% on all her income. Is that right? How much more tax does she pay, and how much more does she keep?** — No. Only the extra ₪1,000 falls in the 30% bracket: tax rises by 0.3 · 1000 = 300 shekels, and she keeps 1000 - 300 = 700 more.
7. **A recession has widened the deficit. Write a short paragraph: should the government cut spending now to close it? Give both views.** — A good answer sets out the view that cutting in a recession deepens it, since the stabilizers are doing their job and the deficit will shrink in recovery; and the view that a high debt raises interest costs and the risk of losing the trust of lenders, so a credible plan to cut must be made. It names the trade off without declaring one side right.

## Common questions

### Is a budget deficit always bad?

No. A deficit in a recession, or one that pays for investment such as roads and schools, can be sensible. A large deficit year after year in good times raises the debt ratio and the interest bill, which limits what the budget can do later.

### How is a budget deficit financed?

Mostly by borrowing: the government sells bonds to households, pension funds, banks and foreign investors, who are repaid with interest. In a few countries the central bank has financed deficits by creating money, which has often led to high inflation.

### What is the debt-to-GDP ratio?

The public debt divided by one year's GDP, written as a percentage. It compares what a country owes with what it produces, so it shows the burden better than the debt in shekels.

### What is the difference between a structural and a cyclical deficit?

The cyclical deficit is the part caused by the business cycle, through the automatic stabilizers, and disappears in recovery. The structural deficit is what would remain in a normal year, and only a policy change closes it.

### What is the difference between the marginal and the average tax rate?

The marginal rate is the tax on the next shekel earned. The average rate is the total tax divided by total income. Under a progressive tax the average rate is always below the top marginal rate a person reaches.
