# What is the difference between a provision and a contingent liability?

> Written with AI · [Accounting: bank loans, interest and liabilities](https://lessoons.com/en/loans-and-liabilities) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/loans-and-liabilities/what-is-the-difference-between-a-provision-and-a-contingent-liability

The difference between a provision and a contingent liability is how likely and how measurable the payment is. A provision is a present obligation from a past event that will probably be paid and can be estimated, so it is recorded as a liability; a contingent liability is only possible or cannot be measured, so it is described in the notes.

## The topic explained

### Liabilities without a fixed bill

Most liabilities come with an invoice: a supplier's bill, a loan schedule. Some do not. A store that sells heaters with a one-year warranty will pay for repairs, but it does not know which heaters will break or what the repairs will cost. The international standard on the subject, IAS 37, sorts such cases with three questions, and the answers decide between a provision and a contingent liability.

First: is there a present obligation that comes from something that has already happened? Second: is a payment probable, which the standard reads as more likely than not? Third: can the amount be estimated reliably? Three yes answers make a provision, a liability recorded in the balance sheet. A no to the second or third question usually makes a contingent liability, described only in the notes to the statements.

### Probable, possible, remote

A made-up store is sued by a customer for ₪200,000. If its lawyers think the store will probably lose and can estimate the loss at ₪120,000, that is a provision of ₪120,000. If they think a loss is possible but not likely, the claim is a contingent liability: no entry, but a note tells readers about the claim. If they think the chance is remote, nothing is shown at all.

The misreading is to treat “contingent” as “not real”. A contingent liability can be large and serious; it stays out of the balance sheet only because the payment is not probable or cannot be measured, and the note is there exactly so readers can weigh it themselves.

### Recording a warranty provision

The store sold 1,000 heaters this year. Experience says repairs cost about ₪30 per heater sold, so it expects to spend ₪30,000. The sale is the past event, and repairs are probable and can be estimated, so on December 31 it records the provision: debit Warranty expense ₪30,000, credit Provision for warranty ₪30,000. The expense falls in the year of the sales that caused it.

Next year the store pays ₪26,000 for repairs: debit Provision for warranty ₪26,000, credit Bank ₪26,000. The repairs use up the provision; they are not a second expense. The ₪4,000 left is reviewed at the year end and kept, increased or reversed to match the best estimate then.

### What is never a provision

Losses the store expects to make next year are not a provision, however likely: nothing has happened yet that obliges it to pay. The same goes for a plan to repaint the shop. A provision always rests on an obligation that already exists.

On the other side of the ledger, a possible gain, such as a claim the store has filed against a supplier, is a contingent asset. It is not recorded as an asset; it is mentioned in the notes when an inflow is probable, and recorded only once it is virtually certain. The rule is deliberately uneven: losses are shown earlier than gains.

## Practice: provisions and contingent liabilities

For 12th grade accounting students. A made-up builder sold homes for ₪900,000 this year with a two-year warranty; experience says repairs cost about 2% of sales. Next year it pays ₪11,000 for repairs. Check the answers at the end.

1. **Name the three questions that decide whether to record a provision.** — Is there a present obligation from a past event? Is a payment probable? Can the amount be estimated reliably?
2. **Calculate the builder's warranty provision.** — 2% × ₪900,000 = ₪18,000.
3. **Complete the entry on December 31.** — Debit Warranty expense ₪18,000, credit Provision for warranty ₪18,000.
4. **Record the repairs next year and find the balance of the provision.** — Debit Provision for warranty ₪11,000, credit Bank ₪11,000. Balance 18,000 − 11,000 = ₪7,000 credit.
5. **A buyer sues the builder for ₪60,000. The lawyers say a loss is possible but unlikely. How is it shown?** — As a contingent liability: no entry; a note describes the claim and, where possible, its amount.
6. **Decide the treatment of each case.** — Warranty on homes sold: provision. Lawsuit, loss possible: note. Losses expected next year: nothing. Lawsuit, loss probable and estimated: provision.
7. **A student records next year's ₪11,000 of repairs as debit Warranty expense, credit Bank. What goes wrong over the two years?** — The repairs are counted as an expense twice, once in the provision and again when paid, so next year's profit is ₪11,000 too low and the provision stays at ₪18,000 though most of it was used.

## Common questions

### Is a provision a liability?

Yes. A provision is a liability whose timing or amount is uncertain. It is recorded in the balance sheet, current or non-current according to when payment is expected.

### Is a contingent liability recorded in the books?

No. A contingent liability is not recorded as a liability. It is described in the notes to the financial statements, unless the chance of paying is remote.

### What does probable mean for a provision?

Under IAS 37, probable means more likely than not. A payment with a lower chance is only possible, which points to a contingent liability.

### Is a provision the same as a reserve?

No. A provision is a liability for an expected payment. A reserve is part of equity and is not an obligation to pay anyone.

### Can a provision be reversed?

Yes. Each year end the provision is reviewed. If less is now expected to be paid, the excess is reversed, which reduces that year's expense.
