# What are the schedules of reinforcement?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: how behaviour is learned](https://lessoons.com/en/learning-in-psychology) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/learning-in-psychology/what-are-the-schedules-of-reinforcement

Schedules of reinforcement are the rules that decide when a behavior is rewarded. In continuous reinforcement every response is rewarded; in partial reinforcement only some are, by number of responses (fixed or variable ratio) or by time (fixed or variable interval). Partial schedules, especially variable ratio, like a slot machine, produce behavior that lasts much longer after the rewards stop.

## The topic explained

### Every time, or only sometimes

In operant conditioning a behavior followed by a reward, a reinforcer, becomes more likely. But in real life rewards rarely come every time. A schedule of reinforcement is the rule that decides which responses are reinforced. Charles Ferster and B. F. Skinner studied them for years with pigeons and rats and published the results in the book Schedules of Reinforcement (1957).

In continuous reinforcement every correct response is reinforced. It is the fastest way to teach a new behavior: a puppy that gets a treat every time it sits learns to sit quickly. In partial reinforcement only some responses are reinforced. Learning is slower, but the behavior lasts longer, and this is the first thing to understand about schedules. Most everyday behavior is on partial schedules: not every phone call is answered, not every question in class is praised, not every fishing trip catches a fish, and yet people keep calling, asking and fishing.

### Four partial schedules: number or time, fixed or variable

Partial schedules differ on two questions. Does the reward depend on the number of responses (a ratio schedule) or on the time that has passed (an interval schedule)? And is that number or time fixed or variable, changing around an average? Together they make four schedules.

Fixed ratio (FR): a reward after a set number of responses, such as a salesperson paid a bonus for every 10th sale. Variable ratio (VR): a reward after an unpredictable number, averaging some value, like a slot machine. Fixed interval (FI): a reward for the first response after a set time, like a quiz every Sunday. Variable interval (VI): a reward for the first response after unpredictable times, like a message that may be waiting whenever you check your phone.

### Each schedule leaves its own pattern

Skinner's cumulative recorder drew a line that climbed with every response, so its slope showed the rate. Ratio schedules give higher rates than interval schedules, because responding faster brings the reward sooner. On FR there is a pause after each reward, then a fast burst. VR gives a high, steady rate with almost no pauses: the next response might be the winning one. On FI responding drops after each reward and speeds up as the time approaches, a scallop, like a student who studies little after a weekly quiz and a lot the night before the next. VI gives a moderate, steady rate.

### Why habits last: resistance to extinction

Extinction is the fading of a behavior when reinforcement stops. After continuous reinforcement the change is obvious, and the behavior stops quickly: a vending machine that does not deliver is abandoned after two tries. After partial reinforcement, especially on variable schedules, a run without reward looks normal, so the behavior goes on. This is the partial reinforcement extinction effect, and it is why a gambler keeps playing and why a child whose tantrums are sometimes rewarded keeps having them. The common mistake is to think that rewarding every time builds the strongest habit; it builds the fastest one, not the most lasting. The practical rule that follows: teach with continuous reinforcement, then thin it out to a partial schedule so that the behavior survives the days when no reward comes.

## Practice: schedules of reinforcement

For 10th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write one example for each of the four schedules.** — Fixed ratio: a bonus for every 10th sale. Variable ratio: a slot machine. Fixed interval: a quiz every Sunday. Variable interval: checking your phone for messages. Any correct example of your own counts.
2. **What is the difference between a ratio and an interval schedule?** — In a ratio schedule the reward depends on the number of responses; in an interval schedule it depends on the time that has passed since the last reward.
3. **Match each curve, 1 to 4, to its schedule, and explain one of your choices.** — 1: variable ratio (steepest, steady). 2: fixed ratio (steps: pause after each reward, then a burst). 3: variable interval (moderate, steady). 4: fixed interval (scallops: slow after a reward, fast near the next).
4. **Fill in the extinction column for continuous reinforcement and variable ratio.** — Continuous: extinction is fastest. Variable ratio: extinction is slowest, the most resistant schedule.
5. **A student studies very little after each weekly quiz and a lot the night before the next one. Which schedule is this, and what pattern does it produce?** — Fixed interval: the reward (a good grade) is available at a set time. It produces a scallop: low responding after the reward, rising as the time approaches.
6. **Explain why gamblers keep playing a slot machine after many losses.** — A slot machine pays on a variable ratio schedule: the next play could always be the winner, so responding is high and steady. Because long runs without reward are normal on this schedule, losses do not signal that rewards have stopped, so the behavior resists extinction.
7. **Parents sometimes give in to a child's tantrum and sometimes do not. Use the schedules of reinforcement to explain why the tantrums are hard to stop, and suggest what the parents should do.** — Giving in sometimes is partial, variable reinforcement, which makes the behavior very resistant to extinction. The parents should stop reinforcing the tantrum every time and reinforce calm behavior instead; the tantrums may get worse for a while before they fade. A good answer notes that consistency matters most.

## Common questions

### Which schedule of reinforcement is most resistant to extinction?

Variable ratio. Because rewards come after an unpredictable number of responses, a long run without a reward looks normal, so the behavior continues long after rewards stop. Slot machines use this schedule.

### Is a monthly salary a fixed interval schedule?

It is close to one, since pay comes at a set time, but in a real job the salary depends on keeping up the work over the whole month, not on one response at the end. Textbooks use it as an approximate example.

### Why use continuous reinforcement at all?

It is the fastest way to teach a new behavior. A common plan is to start with continuous reinforcement until the behavior is learned, then move to a partial schedule so that it lasts.

### What is a cumulative record?

A cumulative record is a line that rises by one step with every response over time, invented by Skinner. Its steepness shows the rate of responding, and pauses appear as flat parts, which is how each schedule's pattern was first seen.

### How do schedules of reinforcement relate to phones and apps?

Notifications, likes and feeds deliver rewards at unpredictable times or after unpredictable numbers of checks, similar to variable schedules. That is one reason checking a phone becomes a habit that is hard to break.
