# How was Makhtesh Ramon formed?

> Written with AI · [Geography: the landforms of Israel](https://lessoons.com/en/landforms-of-israel) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/landforms-of-israel/how-was-makhtesh-ramon-formed

Makhtesh Ramon was formed by erosion, not by a meteorite or a volcano. Layers of hard limestone lay over soft sandstone and were folded into a long arch. Once streams broke through the hard top, they washed the soft sandstone out much faster, and the hard rock was left standing as steep walls around a valley 40 km long and about 500 m deep.

## The topic explained

### What a makhtesh is

A makhtesh is a deep closed valley surrounded by steep walls of hard rock and drained by a single stream that leaves through one gap. The Hebrew word means a mortar, the bowl in which grain is pounded, and the landform looks like one. The Negev has five: Makhtesh Ramon, the largest at about 40 km long, 2 to 10 km wide and some 500 m deep; HaMakhtesh HaGadol, about 10 by 5 km; HaMakhtesh HaKatan, about 7 by 5 km; and two small twin makhteshim on Har Arif. Two more are in Sinai.

The landform is rare because it needs a particular recipe of rock and structure. The most common mistake is to call Makhtesh Ramon a crater. In English it is often sold as the Ramon Crater, but no meteorite fell there and no volcano blew it open. Geographers sometimes call it an erosion cirque: a hollow carved out by water from the inside.

### Hard rock on top, soft rock underneath

The recipe begins with the layers. At the bottom lies sandstone, laid down on land in the Lower Cretaceous, soft and easy to wash away. Above it lie hard limestone and dolomite, laid down later in the sea. Then the layers were squeezed and folded into an anticline, a long arch of rock whose crest stood highest.

Erosion attacked the crest first, because it was highest and most cracked. As long as the hard cap held, the streams cut slowly. Once they broke through it, they reached the soft sandstone and cut into it many times faster. The valley widened under the cap, the hard rock above lost its support and broke off, and the walls retreated outward while staying steep. Mitzpe Ramon stands on the northern rim, on the hard cap, and looks down over the walls to the floor.

### Why the erosion was so fast

A stream cuts down only as far as the place it drains to, its base level. For a long time the streams of the Negev ran north and west. Then the rift valley of the Arava and the Dead Sea formed, beginning about 5 million years ago, and its floor dropped far below the Negev highlands. The streams turned east toward it and, with a much steeper fall, cut down hard. Each makhtesh is drained by its own outlet, and every grain of sand washed from the floor left through that gap.

The result is a window into the past. The deeper the valley, the older the rock exposed, and the rocks at the bottom of Makhtesh Ramon are up to about 200 million years old. Hills in its northeast were once covered with fossil ammonites, shelled animals of the ancient sea.

### How to tell a makhtesh from a crater

Inside Makhtesh Ramon there are dark hills of basalt, such as Giv'at Ga'ash, and students often take them as proof of a volcano. They are old lava that came up through cracks and was later uncovered by erosion; they did not make the valley. Three questions settle it on the bagrut. What made the hollow? For a makhtesh, erosion. Does it have an outlet? A makhtesh has exactly one. What are the walls? Hard cap rock over soft rock. A full answer names the layers, the fold, the breach and the washing out, in that order.

## Practice: how a makhtesh forms

For 11th grade geography students. Use the cross-section, chart and tables printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your answers.

1. **Write the name of each part of the cross-section marked A to E.** — A: the former arch of hard rock, removed by erosion. B: hard limestone on the rim. C: soft sandstone. D: a steep wall. E: the floor of the makhtesh.
2. **Name the missing stage 3 and explain why the stage after it went so much faster.** — Streams breach the hard top. Once the streams were through the hard cap they reached soft sandstone, which washes away many times faster, so the valley grew quickly under the cap.
3. **HaMakhtesh HaKatan is about 7 km long. Write its length in place of the question mark and work out how many times longer Makhtesh Ramon is.** — 7 km. 40 ÷ 7 ≈ 5.7, so Makhtesh Ramon is almost six times as long.
4. **Why is a makhtesh drained by a single outlet rather than by a stream that flows in one end and out the other?** — It is a closed hollow carved from the inside: the walls of hard rock surround it on every side but one, so all the rain inside it gathers into one stream that leaves through the one gap. A canyon, by contrast, has an inlet and an outlet.
5. **Fill in the makhtesh column of the table.** — Made by: erosion. Outlet: one stream. Walls: hard cap rock over soft rock.
6. **A friend sees the black basalt hill of Giv'at Ga'ash and says: this proves Makhtesh Ramon is a volcano. How do you answer?** — The basalt is lava that rose through cracks long ago and was later uncovered when erosion removed the rock around it. The hollow itself was carved by streams; it has one outlet and hard walls over soft sandstone, the signs of a makhtesh, not of a volcanic crater.
7. **Imagine the same fold had been made only of soft sandstone, with no hard layer on top. Would a makhtesh have formed? Explain.** — No. Without a hard cap the whole arch would have worn down at about the same speed, leaving low, rounded hills and wide valleys. The steep walls exist because hard rock above resists erosion while soft rock below is washed out.

## Common questions

### Is Makhtesh Ramon a crater?

No. It is often called the Ramon Crater in English, but it was not made by a meteorite or a volcano. It is an erosion valley, carved by streams that washed soft sandstone out from under a hard cap of limestone.

### How big is Makhtesh Ramon?

About 40 km long, between 2 and 10 km wide and about 500 m deep, which makes it the largest makhtesh in the world. HaMakhtesh HaGadol is about 10 km long and HaMakhtesh HaKatan about 7 km.

### How many makhteshim are there?

The Negev has five: Makhtesh Ramon, HaMakhtesh HaGadol, HaMakhtesh HaKatan and two small twin makhteshim on Har Arif. Two more are in Sinai. Similar erosion valleys have been described elsewhere, but these are the classic examples.

### How old is Makhtesh Ramon?

Its rocks are very old, up to about 200 million years at the bottom, but the valley is much younger. Its final deep carving followed the forming of the Arava rift, which began about 5 million years ago and turned the Negev streams east.

### What does the word makhtesh mean?

Makhtesh is the Hebrew word for a mortar, the bowl in which grain or spices are pounded. The landform takes its name from that likeness, and English geology writing uses the Hebrew word for it.
