# What is the law of diminishing marginal returns?

> Written with AI · [The labor market and wages](https://lessoons.com/en/labor-market) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/labor-market/what-is-the-law-of-diminishing-marginal-returns

The law of diminishing marginal returns says that when more of one input, such as workers, is added to a fixed amount of another, such as machines or land, each extra unit eventually adds less output than the one before. It holds in the short run, when at least one input cannot be changed, and it is why a firm's marginal cost eventually rises.

## The topic explained

### More workers, the same oven

A firm in the short run has at least one input it cannot change quickly: a bakery has one oven, a farm has its land. Its other inputs, mostly workers, can be changed. The law of diminishing marginal returns says that as workers are added to the fixed input, the extra output from each new worker, its marginal product, eventually falls.

The reason is the fixed input, not the workers. The first bakers share a large oven and soon have a division of tasks: one kneads, one shapes, one bakes. After a point, new bakers wait for the oven, get in each other's way and add less and less, even though each is as skilled as the first.

### A worked example: the bakery

With one oven (numbers made up for this page), the bakery makes 40 loaves a day with one baker, 100 with two, 150 with three, 180 with four, 200 with five and 210 with six. The total product rises all the way. The marginal product is the change from one row to the next: 100 - 40 = 60 for the second baker, 150 - 100 = 50 for the third, then 30, 20 and 10.

The second baker adds more than the first, because two can divide the work. From the third baker on, each adds less than the one before: diminishing marginal returns have set in. The average product, total output divided by the number of workers, is 150/3 = 50 loaves with three bakers and 210/6 = 35 with six.

### Marginal and average: the rule of averages

Marginal and average product are linked by a rule students already know from test scores. If your average is 80 and the next test is 90, your average rises; if the next is 68, it falls. In the same way, while the marginal product is above the average product, the average rises, and once it is below, the average falls. So the marginal product crosses the average at the average's peak: with three bakers both are 50.

In the bar chart the bars are marginal products and the line is the average. The bars fall from the third baker on, and the line falls once the bars drop below it.

### Why it matters, and three traps

Diminishing returns is the root of a firm's costs. If each extra baker adds fewer loaves but costs the same wage, each extra loaf costs more to make: marginal cost rises. It is also why a firm's demand for workers falls as the wage rises, the subject of the next lesson.

Three traps. Diminishing is not negative: total output still rises while the marginal product is positive; it falls only if a new worker gets so much in the way that the marginal product drops below zero. The law needs a fixed input: if the bakery doubles both its ovens and its bakers, that is a question of returns to scale, a long-run idea. And it says nothing about the new worker being worse: all the bakers here are equally good.

## Practice: diminishing marginal returns

For 11th grade economics students. Use the graph and the tables on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **State the law of diminishing marginal returns, and name the condition it needs.** — As more of one input is added to a fixed amount of another, the marginal product of the added input eventually falls. It needs at least one fixed input, that is, the short run.
2. **Use the graph of the farm. How many extra crates does the second worker add, and how many the fifth?** — Second worker: 24 - 10 = 14 crates. Fifth worker: 44 - 40 = 4 crates.
3. **Fill in the missing cells of the farm table.** — Marginal product of the 3rd worker: 33 - 24 = 9; of the 4th: 40 - 33 = 7. Average with 3 workers: 33/3 = 11; with 5: 44/5 = 8.8 crates.
4. **After which worker do diminishing marginal returns set in on the farm? Explain from the table.** — After the second. The marginal product rises from 10 to 14 and then falls: 9, 7, 4.
5. **With two workers the farm's average product is 12. Does the third worker raise or lower it, and why?** — Lowers it, from 12 to 11, because the third worker's marginal product, 9, is below the average of 12.
6. **Write in the table whether each case shows diminishing marginal returns.** — More cooks in one kitchen: yes, the kitchen is fixed. Double staff and shop: no, nothing is fixed, so it is a question of returns to scale. More tutors in one classroom: yes, the room is fixed.
7. **A seventh baker joins and the bakery's output falls from 210 to 205. What is the marginal product of the seventh baker, and does the law say this must happen?** — 205 - 210 = -5 loaves. The law says the marginal product falls, not that it turns negative; it turns negative only when the extra worker gets so much in the way that total output falls.
8. **Write a short paragraph: why does diminishing marginal returns make the marginal cost of a loaf rise?** — A good answer says that each extra baker costs the same wage but adds fewer loaves, so the cost of each extra loaf, the wage divided by the marginal product, rises as more bakers are hired.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between marginal product and average product?

Marginal product is the extra output from one more worker. Average product is total output divided by the number of workers. The marginal product pulls the average toward it, like the score of the next test.

### Is diminishing returns the same as decreasing returns to scale?

No. Diminishing returns is a short-run idea, with one input fixed. Returns to scale is a long-run idea: what happens to output when every input is increased in the same proportion.

### Does diminishing marginal returns mean total output falls?

No. Total output keeps rising as long as the marginal product is positive. It falls only if the marginal product turns negative, when extra workers get in each other's way.

### Why does marginal product rise at first?

With very few workers the fixed input is underused and the work cannot be divided. A second or third worker allows specialization, so each adds more than the last until the fixed input becomes crowded.

### How is this asked on the bagrut?

Students compute marginal and average product from a production table, find where diminishing returns begin, explain the link between marginal and average, and connect falling marginal product with rising marginal cost.
