# How do trade unions affect wages?

> Written with AI · [The labor market and wages](https://lessoons.com/en/labor-market) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/labor-market/how-do-trade-unions-affect-wages

Trade unions raise wages by bargaining for all their members together, so an employer cannot replace one worker who asks for more. Union members usually earn more than similar workers without a union. In the simple supply and demand model, a wage set above the market wage also means fewer jobs in that sector; where one employer dominates, a union can raise pay without that loss.

## The topic explained

### What trade unions bargain for

A trade union is an organization of workers that negotiates with employers on their behalf. Alone, a worker who asks for a raise can be told to leave; together, the workers can threaten to stop work altogether. That is collective bargaining, and its result is a collective agreement: a contract that sets wages, hours, pension contributions, promotion rules and how disputes are settled.

In Israel the largest workers' organization is the Histadrut, founded in Haifa in December 1920. The Collective Agreements Law of 1957 gives the agreements legal force and distinguishes two kinds. A special agreement covers one employer or one plant, such as a hospital and its nurses. A general agreement covers a whole branch or the whole country and is signed with an employers' organization. The minister may issue an extension order that applies a general agreement to workers and employers who did not sign it, so its terms can reach far beyond the union's members.

### A worked example: a wage above the market

Take a labor market with demand L_(d) = 200 - 4W and supply L_(s) = 4W - 40, in thousands of workers and shekels an hour (numbers made up for this page). Without a union the market settles where 200 - 4W = 4W - 40: a wage of ₪30 and 80 thousand jobs.

Now a union agrees on ₪35 with all the employers in the branch. Firms hire where the wage meets demand, and the number who want the jobs is read from supply: L_(d) = 200 - 4 · 35 = 60 L_(s) = 4 · 35 - 40 = 100 So 60 thousand are hired, 100 thousand want work, and 40 thousand are left outside. Those who keep their jobs earn 35/30 - 1 ≈ 16.7% more; 20 thousand jobs are gone from the branch, and the wage bill falls from ₪2,400 to ₪2,100 thousand an hour. The gain of the insiders is paid partly by the outsiders, who look for work elsewhere and push wages there down.

### Two views of what unions do

The worked example is the monopoly view: a union sells labor the way a single seller sells a good, raising its price by limiting how much is bought. Its critics add that a union may protect insiders with jobs against outsiders without them, and slow down change in a firm.

The voice view stresses what the model leaves out. A worker who is unhappy can quit, or can complain through the union; when complaints are heard, fewer workers quit, firms spend less on hiring and training, and conditions can improve. Richard Freeman and James Medoff, in What Do Unions Do? (1984), presented evidence against the purely negative view and concluded that unions on balance probably raise efficiency. Others read the evidence differently, and the bagrut asks for both views.

A third case matters too. Where one large employer dominates a town or a profession, it can hold wages below the market level and hire fewer workers. A union facing such an employer can raise both the wage and the number employed, as a minimum wage can.

### Common mistakes

Saying that a union raises wages for everyone: in the simple model it raises them for those it covers, while outsiders may earn less. Saying that a union must always cost jobs: against a dominant employer it need not. Confusing a collective agreement with a law: it is a contract, and in Israel it reaches non-members only through an extension order or the employer's own agreement.

## Practice: trade unions and wages

For 11th grade economics students. Use the graph and the tables on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **What is a collective agreement, and what is the difference between a special and a general agreement?** — A contract between workers' organizations and employers that sets wages and conditions. A special agreement covers one employer or plant; a general agreement covers a whole branch or the country.
2. **Use the graph. Find the market wage and the number employed without a union.** — 200 - 4W = 4W - 40, so W = 30 shekels an hour and L = 80 thousand workers.
3. **The union agrees on a wage of ₪40. Fill in the table.** — Firms hire 200 - 160 = 40 thousand; 160 - 40 = 120 thousand want work; 80 thousand are left without a job in the branch.
4. **By what percent does the union wage of ₪40 exceed the market wage, and how many jobs does the branch lose?** — 40/30 - 1 ≈ 33.3%. Jobs fall from 80 to 40 thousand, a loss of 40 thousand.
5. **Write in the table whether each agreement is special or general.** — One hospital and its nurses: special. All building firms: general. One bank and its tellers: special.
6. **Which kind of agreement can the minister extend by an order, and what does the order do?** — Only a general agreement. The extension order applies its terms to workers and employers in the branch who did not sign it.
7. **Write a short paragraph comparing the monopoly view and the voice view of unions.** — A good answer says that in the monopoly view a union raises wages above the market and cuts jobs, with outsiders paying; in the voice view a union lets workers complain instead of quitting, cuts turnover and can raise productivity; and it adds that facing a dominant employer a union can raise both pay and jobs.

## Common questions

### What is collective bargaining?

Negotiation between an employer and a union that speaks for all the workers together, about wages, hours, pensions and conditions. Its result is a collective agreement that binds both sides.

### Do union members earn more?

On average union members earn more than similar workers without a union, but economists disagree about how much of the gap the union causes and how much comes from where unions are found.

### What is an extension order in Israel?

An order by the minister, under the Collective Agreements Law of 1957, that applies a general collective agreement to workers and employers in a branch who did not sign it.

### Can a union raise wages without losing jobs?

Yes, when a single large employer holds wages below the market level. Then a higher agreed wage can draw more workers into jobs, as a well-set minimum wage can.

### What is the Histadrut?

Israel's largest workers' organization, founded in Haifa in December 1920. It signs collective agreements with employers and the state, and calls strikes in disputes.
