# What is the difference between an editorial and an op-ed?

> Written with AI · [Communications: news writing and journalistic genres](https://lessoons.com/en/journalistic-writing-and-genres) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/journalistic-writing-and-genres/what-is-the-difference-between-an-editorial-and-an-op-ed

An editorial is an opinion article that speaks for the newspaper itself, written by its editorial board and usually unsigned. An op-ed is a signed opinion article by an individual, often from outside the paper, and gives that writer's view, not the paper's. The name means “opposite the editorial page,” where The New York Times began printing such pieces in 1970.

## The topic explained

### Three voices on the opinion pages

The difference between an editorial and an op-ed is a question of whose voice is speaking. An editorial is the newspaper speaking for itself: it is written by members of its editorial board, usually appears without a byline, and states the paper's position on an issue. An op-ed is signed by its writer, who may be an expert, a public figure, an activist or an ordinary reader, and it states only that person's view. A column is also signed, but its writer is a regular contributor with a fixed place in the paper, week after week.

A newspaper that prints an op-ed does not necessarily agree with it. Many papers deliberately publish op-eds that argue against their own editorials, to give readers more than one view.

### Where the name comes from

The modern op-ed page was launched by The New York Times on 21 September 1970, developed under its editorial page editor John B. Oakes. The page stood opposite the editorial page, and that is all “op-ed” means. The common misreading is that the word stands for “opinion-editorial”; it does not. In 2021 the Times itself stopped using the term and began calling such pieces guest essays.

On the printed page the layout made the difference visible: on one side, the paper's own editorials and letters from readers; on the facing side, signed pieces by others. Online, the separation depends on clear labels, such as Opinion, Editorial or Guest essay, at the top of each piece.

### Why news and opinion are kept apart

A news report is meant to tell readers what happened; an opinion piece tells them what someone thinks should be done. Mixing the two, so that a reader cannot tell which is which, misleads. The Israel Press Council's ethics code requires news and opinion to be distinguished, and adds that facts reported inside an opinion piece must meet the same standards of accuracy as news. An opinion writer may choose which facts to stress, but may not invent or distort them.

This is why careful readers check the label before judging a piece, and why a sentence like “the newspaper said” is wrong when quoting a signed op-ed: the paper published it, but the writer said it.

Between the two sits news analysis, a signed piece by a reporter who explains what an event means and what may follow, without arguing for a side. On television and online the lines are harder to see, because the same commentators may report, analyze and argue in one evening. The question to ask is always the same: is this telling me what happened, explaining it, or trying to persuade me?

### How an opinion piece is built

Most opinion pieces build an argument in five parts: a clear claim, evidence that supports it, a fair statement of the counterargument, an answer to it, and a conclusion, often a call to act. Take a made-up op-ed by a school principal arguing that phones should be collected at the start of the school day. The claim comes first; then evidence, such as what teachers at the school observed; then the strongest objection, that parents need to reach their children; then an answer, a phone at the office for emergencies; then the call. Pieces that ignore the other side persuade fewer readers who disagree. A strong exam answer tells the three genres apart and analyzes the parts of an argument in an example.

## Practice: editorials, op-eds and columns

For 10th grade communications students. Every newspaper, writer and argument here is made up. Answer from what is printed on the page, then check yourself against the answers.

1. **Editorial, op-ed or column? (a) an unsigned article saying “We believe the city must build more bike lanes”; (b) a doctor's signed article on vaccination, published once; (c) a writer's weekly signed piece on Fridays.** — (a) editorial; (b) op-ed; (c) column.
2. **Fill in the missing cell in the table.** — The writer's: an op-ed gives the view of the person who signed it, not of the newspaper.
3. **What is the page marked with a question mark called, and where does its name come from?** — The op-ed page: the name means the page opposite the editorial page, where signed pieces by others are printed.
4. **A student writes: “Op-ed stands for opinion and editorial.” Correct the sentence.** — Op-ed means opposite the editorial page. The term comes from the page The New York Times launched in 1970, which faced its editorial page.
5. **A made-up news site quotes a signed guest piece with the words “the site said yesterday.” What is wrong?** — The view belongs to the writer, not to the site. It should say that the writer argued, in a piece published by the site.
6. **Which part of the argument is missing? Write it for the made-up op-ed about collecting phones at school.** — The counterargument: the strongest objection, for example that parents need to be able to reach their children during the day.
7. **An opinion writer states as a fact that a made-up school's grades “fell by half” when they fell by 5 percent. Is this allowed because it is an opinion piece?** — No. Opinions are free, but facts inside an opinion piece must be accurate; the Press Council code applies the rules for news to facts in opinion pieces.
8. **Should a newspaper publish op-eds that disagree with its own editorials? Write a short balanced answer with a conclusion.** — A good answer gives the case for (readers meet more views, the paper shows confidence and fairness, debate improves) and against (the paper may seem confused, and some views may be harmful or misleading), and concludes with a reasoned view, for example publishing opposing views that meet standards of accuracy and respect.

## Common questions

### Who writes a newspaper's editorials?

Members of its editorial board, a group of senior journalists who meet to decide the paper's positions. Editorials are usually unsigned because they speak for the institution, not for one writer.

### Can anyone write an op-ed?

Anyone can submit one, and newspapers publish op-eds by experts, public figures, activists and readers. Editors choose among submissions for relevance, quality and variety, and check the facts before publishing.

### What is the difference between an op-ed and a column?

Both are signed opinion pieces. A columnist writes regularly, often weekly, in a fixed place in the paper; an op-ed writer usually writes once or occasionally, often from outside journalism.

### Why do newspapers separate news and opinion?

So that readers can tell reports of what happened from arguments about what should happen. Ethics codes, including the Israel Press Council's, require the two to be distinguished, and labels and layout make the separation visible.

### Is a letter to the editor an op-ed?

No, though both are signed opinions from outside the paper. A letter is short and usually responds to something the paper published; an op-ed is a longer article that develops an argument.
