# Why do the righteous suffer in Jewish thought?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Questions and Thinkers](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/why-do-the-righteous-suffer

Jewish thought gives several answers to why the righteous suffer, and none settles it alone. The Talmud tells a sufferer to examine his deeds and speaks of “יסורין של אהבה” (sufferings of love); Rabbi Yaakov puts the reward in the world to come; and Rabbi Yannai admits that it is not in our hands to explain the suffering of the righteous (Avot 4:15).

## The topic explained

### Four cases and one question

Why do the righteous suffer? The Talmud puts the question in the mouth of Moses himself: “מפני מה יש צדיק וטוב לו, ויש צדיק ורע לו” (why is there a righteous person who prospers and a righteous person who suffers, Berakhot 7a), and likewise a wicked person who prospers and one who suffers. The Hebrew name of the problem comes from here: tzaddik ve-ra lo, the righteous one who suffers. In philosophy it is called theodicy, the attempt to show that God is just although the world does not always look just.

The Talmud first answers that a suffering righteous person is the son of a wicked father, then rejects this because children are not punished for their parents, and offers: “צדיק ורע לו — צדיק שאינו גמור” (a righteous person who suffers is one who is not completely righteous). Rabbi Meir disagrees: “שתים נתנו לו ואחת לא נתנו לו” (two requests were granted to Moses and one was not), so even Moses was not told why.

### Job: the friends' answer and Job's

The book of Job (“איוב”, Iyov) sets the two answers against each other. Eliphaz, the first friend, argues that suffering proves guilt: “זְכָר־נָא מִי הוּא נָקִי אָבָד” (remember, who that was innocent ever perished? Job 4:7). Job refuses to confess what he did not do: “בְּצִדְקָתִי הֶחֱזַקְתִּי וְלֹא אַרְפֶּהָ” (I hold fast to my righteousness and will not let it go, 27:6).

God answers from the storm with a question, not an explanation: “אֵיפֹה הָיִיתָ בְּיָסְדִי־אָרֶץ” (where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? 38:4). Yet at the end God tells the friends “כִּי לֹא דִבַּרְתֶּם אֵלַי נְכוֹנָה כְּעַבְדִּי אִיּוֹב” (for you have not spoken of Me what is right, as My servant Job has, 42:7). The common misreading is that the book sides with the friends; it rejects their answer and approves of Job's protest.

### The sages' answers: examine, then love

The Talmud gives a person in pain an order of steps: “אם רואה אדם שיסורין באין עליו — יפשפש במעשיו” (if a person sees suffering coming upon him, let him examine his deeds, Berakhot 5a). If he finds no fault, let him look at whether he neglected Torah study; and if he still finds nothing, these are “יסורין של אהבה” (sufferings of love), as in Proverbs 3:12, where a father rebukes the son he loves.

A third answer moves the reward elsewhere. Rabbi Yaakov holds “שכר מצוה בהאי עלמא ליכא” (there is no reward for a commandment in this world, Kiddushin 39b): the account is settled in the world to come. Notice the order in 5a: the inner examination is turned on oneself, never used to judge someone else who suffers.

### The answer that refuses to explain

Rabbi Yannai says plainly: “אין בידינו לא משלות הרשעים ואף לא מיסורי הצדיקים” (it is not in our hands to explain the ease of the wicked or the suffering of the righteous, Avot 4:15). Some thinkers prefer this answer because it does not accuse the sufferer and does not claim to know God's reasons, much as the book of Job approves of Job and not of his friends.

Each answer can be tested against a hard case. After the Holocaust, in which six million Jews were murdered, many religious and secular thinkers refused to call it a punishment, and turned instead to the answers that admit what cannot be known. A strong exam answer presents at least two answers with their sources and weighs each against such a case.

## Practice: why the righteous suffer

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fill in the two empty cells of the table of the four cases Moses asks about in Berakhot 7a.** — Righteous, suffers (tzaddik ve-ra lo); wicked, prospers (rasha ve-tov lo). These are the two cases that make the question hard.
2. **The Talmud answers: “צדיק ורע לו — צדיק שאינו גמור” (a righteous person who suffers is one who is not completely righteous). Rabbi Meir says: “שתים נתנו לו ואחת לא נתנו לו” (two requests were granted and one was not). How do the two views differ?** — The first view explains the suffering: the person has some fault. Rabbi Meir holds that Moses was not given the answer at all, so even the greatest prophet does not know why the righteous suffer.
3. **Eliphaz says: “זְכָר־נָא מִי הוּא נָקִי אָבָד” (who that was innocent ever perished? Job 4:7). Job says: “בְּצִדְקָתִי הֶחֱזַקְתִּי וְלֹא אַרְפֶּהָ” (I hold fast to my righteousness and will not let it go, 27:6). State each one's position in a sentence.** — Eliphaz: suffering proves that the sufferer sinned. Job: he did not sin, and he will not confess to a sin to make his suffering fit a rule.
4. **At the end of the book God says to the friends: “כִּי לֹא דִבַּרְתֶּם אֵלַי נְכוֹנָה כְּעַבְדִּי אִיּוֹב” (you have not spoken of Me what is right, as My servant Job has, 42:7). What does this verse teach about the friends' answer?** — The book rejects the friends' claim that suffering always proves guilt, and approves of Job's honest protest, even though God did not explain his suffering.
5. **Write the missing step in the order of Berakhot 5a.** — Examine your deeds (yefashpesh be-ma'asav): the first step is to look for a fault in oneself.
6. **Fill in the two empty boxes in the table of answers.** — The difficulty of sufferings of love: why should love be shown through pain? The source of we cannot know: Avot 4:15, the words of Rabbi Yannai.
7. **Rabbi Yaakov says: “שכר מצוה בהאי עלמא ליכא” (there is no reward for a commandment in this world, Kiddushin 39b). How does this view answer the question, and what difficulty remains?** — It moves reward and punishment to the world to come, so suffering here does not contradict justice. The difficulty: the world we live in still looks unjust, and the answer cannot be checked.
8. **Write a paragraph: which answer holds up best against a hard case, such as the Holocaust? Present two answers with their sources, weigh each, and explain your choice.** — A good answer presents two answers in their own terms with sources (for example Berakhot 5a and Avot 4:15), notes what each claims and what it costs (blaming the sufferer, leaving the question open), and argues respectfully for one, without mocking the others.

## Common questions

### What does tzaddik ve-ra lo mean?

It means a righteous person who suffers, literally a righteous one for whom it is bad. The phrase comes from Berakhot 7a, where Moses asks God about the four cases of righteous and wicked people who prosper or suffer.

### What are sufferings of love?

In Berakhot 5a, sufferings of love are pains that come to a person who has examined his deeds and found no fault. The Talmud compares them to a father who rebukes a son he loves, after Proverbs 3:12.

### Does the book of Job answer the question?

Not with an explanation. God answers Job from the storm with questions about the creation of the world, and at the end says that the friends, who blamed Job, did not speak rightly, while Job did.

### Is it right to tell a suffering person that he must have sinned?

The sources warn against it. The examination in Berakhot 5a is something a person does about himself, and the book of Job condemns the friends who blamed a suffering man. Comforting a sufferer is not the same as explaining his suffering.

### How do I answer an exam question on the suffering of the righteous?

Define the question, quote at least two sources (Berakhot 7a or 5a, Job, Avot 4:15), present each answer in its own terms, name its difficulty, and test it against a case. Avoid presenting one answer as the only Jewish view.
