# Why did Maimonides reject the eternity of the world?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Questions and Thinkers](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/why-did-maimonides-reject-the-eternity-of-the-world

Maimonides rejected Aristotle's eternity of the world for two reasons, which he gives in the Guide for the Perplexed 2:25. It had never been proven by demonstration, so there was no reason to reinterpret the Torah's plain sense; and an eternal, unchanging world would rule out miracles and revelation, uprooting the Torah. He did not reject it because of the verses: those, he says, could have been interpreted.

## The topic explained

### Three views of the world's beginning

In the Guide for the Perplexed (completed about 1190) Maimonides sets out the choice: “דעות האנשים בקדמות העולם או חידושו לכל מי שיאמין שיש שם אלוה נמצא – הם שלש דעות” (the opinions of people about the eternity or creation of the world, among all who believe that God exists, are three, 2:13). The first, the view of the Torah of Moses, is that God brought the world into being “האלוה המציאו אחר ההעדר הגמור המוחלט” (after complete and absolute non-existence): creation from nothing. Time itself, he adds, “ושהזמן עצמו גם כן מכלל הנבראים” (is also among the created things), so there was no time before the world.

The second is Plato's: the heavens come to be and pass away, but “שיש חומר אחד נמצא קדמון כקדמות האלוה” (there is one matter, existing eternally as God is eternal). The third is Aristotle's: the world, its order and its time are eternal, never begun and never ending. A common mistake is to treat Plato's view as the Torah's because both speak of a beginning; Maimonides insists they differ: for Plato something was always there besides God.

### Not because of the verses

The surprise comes in 2:25: “אין בריחתנו מן המאמר בקדמות העולם מפני הכתובים” (our flight from the claim that the world is eternal is not because of the verses in the Torah). There are no more verses about creation than verses that describe God with a body, and Maimonides interprets those: “ולא שערי הפרוש סתומים בפנינו” (nor are the gates of interpretation closed before us).

So why not interpret the creation verses too? Because the case is different. That God has no body has been proven; but “וקדמות העולם לא התבאר במופת” (the eternity of the world has not been shown by demonstration). This is his rule for reason and revelation: a verse is read against its plain sense only when a proof forces it. Where reason has no proof either way, the plain sense of the Torah stands.

### What eternity would cost

The second reason concerns the result. Aristotle's world exists by necessity, its nature never changes and nothing departs from its course, and such a belief “הנה היא סותרת הדת מעיקרה ומכזבת לכל אות בהכרח” (contradicts the religion at its root and necessarily denies every sign). If nothing can change, there are no miracles, no revelation and no commandments given at a chosen time.

Plato's view is milder: “הדעת ההוא לא יסתור יסודי התורה” (that opinion does not contradict the foundations of the Torah), and the verses could be fitted to it. Still, unproven, it is not needed. With creation, on the other hand, “עם האמנת חידוש העולם יהיו האותות כולם אפשריות ותהיה התורה אפשרית” (with belief in the creation of the world all the miracles become possible and the Torah becomes possible).

### What a reader gains and gives up

Read this way, the Torah is held to the standard of proof: the reader gives up the simple certainty that every verse means what it seems, since a proven truth can overrule its plain sense. In return the reader gains a faith that never has to deny what reason has shown.

Critics answered from both sides. Some philosophers suspected that Maimonides was more Aristotelian than he admitted; traditional readers objected that a Torah open to reinterpretation whenever proof appears is too dependent on the science of the day. A strong answer gives the three views, the two reasons, and one such objection.

## Practice: Maimonides and the eternity of the world

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Maimonides writes: “דעות האנשים בקדמות העולם או חידושו לכל מי שיאמין שיש שם אלוה נמצא – הם שלש דעות” (the opinions about the eternity or creation of the world are three, 2:13). Name the three views and whose each one is.** — Creation from nothing, the view of the Torah of Moses; creation from an eternal matter, the view of Plato; an eternal, unchanging world, the view of Aristotle.
2. **Fill in the two empty boxes of the table.** — Plato: the world is made from eternal matter. Aristotle's view uproots the Torah, since it denies miracles.
3. **Maimonides writes: “אין בריחתנו מן המאמר בקדמות העולם מפני הכתובים” (our flight from the claim that the world is eternal is not because of the verses). Why is this sentence surprising, and how does he explain it?** — One would expect a believer to reject eternity because the Torah says the world was created. Maimonides says the verses could have been interpreted, as he interpreted the verses about God's body; the gates of interpretation are not closed.
4. **Write the example missing under interpret the verse in the diagram.** — God has no body: since this has been proven, verses that describe God in bodily terms are interpreted.
5. **“וקדמות העולם לא התבאר במופת” (the eternity of the world has not been shown by demonstration). What is the difference between a demonstration and a reasonable argument, and why does it matter here?** — A demonstration (mofet) proves a claim with certainty; a reasonable argument only makes it likely. Only a demonstration allows reading a verse against its plain sense, and eternity has none.
6. **Write the missing step in the chain that shows the cost of Aristotle's view.** — No sign, no miracle: if nature can never change, there can be no miracles and no revelation.
7. **About Plato's view Maimonides writes: “הדעת ההוא לא יסתור יסודי התורה” (that opinion does not contradict the foundations of the Torah). Why, then, does he not adopt it?** — Because it has not been demonstrated either. Without a proof there is no need to move away from the plain sense of the Torah, which teaches creation from nothing.
8. **Write a paragraph: what does a reader gain and what does he give up by reading the Torah as Maimonides does? Include one quotation and one objection.** — A good answer explains that the reader gains a faith that never denies proven truth, and gives up the certainty that every verse means what it seems; it quotes 2:25 and raises an objection (the Torah becomes dependent on the science of the day) with a reply.

## Common questions

### What does eternity of the world mean?

It is the view, held by Aristotle, that the world never began and will never end: it has always existed in the same order. Its opposite is creation, the view that the world came into being at a beginning.

### Did Maimonides prove that the world was created?

No. In the Guide he argues that neither creation nor eternity can be demonstrated, and that creation is the more reasonable view. Without a proof, he keeps the plain sense of the Torah.

### What is the difference between Plato's view and the Torah's?

Both speak of a world that came to be, but for Plato it was made from a matter that always existed beside God. The Torah's view, as Maimonides reads it, is creation from nothing, with time itself created.

### Why does it matter whether the world is eternal?

Because a necessary, unchanging world leaves no room for will: no miracles, no revelation and no commandments given at a chosen moment. A created world, Maimonides says, makes the Torah possible.

### How is this question connected to reason and revelation?

It shows Maimonides' method. Where reason has a proof, a verse is interpreted to fit it; where reason has none, the plain sense of the Torah is kept. Revelation and reason are meant never to contradict each other.
