# Jewish Thought: Questions and Thinkers – 11th Grade

> Written with AI · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers

Maimonides' 13 principles of faith are the beliefs he listed in 1168, in his Commentary on the Mishnah, as the foundations every Jew must hold: five about God (He exists, is one, has no body, is first and alone is worshipped), four about prophecy and the Torah, and four about reward and punishment, the Messiah and resurrection. The questions Jewish thinkers have argued over and the answers they gave: what counts as a principle of faith, how reason and revelation fit together, what chosenness claims, why the righteous suffer, and what modern.

## Lessons in this topic (in learning order)

1. [What are Maimonides' 13 principles of faith?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/what-are-maimonides-13-principles-of-faith) (Grade 11) — Maimonides' 13 principles of faith are the beliefs he listed in 1168, in his Commentary on the Mishnah, as the foundations every Jew must hold: five about God (He exists, is one, has no body, is first and alone is worshipped), four about prophecy and the Torah, and four about reward and punishment, the Messiah and resurrection. Later thinkers disputed whether Judaism has such principles at all.
2. [Why did Maimonides reject the eternity of the world?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/why-did-maimonides-reject-the-eternity-of-the-world) (Grade 11) — Maimonides rejected Aristotle's eternity of the world for two reasons, which he gives in the Guide for the Perplexed 2:25. It had never been proven by demonstration, so there was no reason to reinterpret the Torah's plain sense; and an eternal, unchanging world would rule out miracles and revelation, uprooting the Torah. He did not reject it because of the verses: those, he says, could have been interpreted.
3. [What is the divine influence in the Kuzari?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/what-is-the-divine-influence-in-the-kuzari) (Grade 11) — The divine influence (ha-inyan ha-elohi, also translated the divine matter) is, in Yehuda Halevi's Kuzari, a level of being above the intellect: what makes a prophet differ from other people as a person differs from an animal. Halevi holds that it passed from Adam through chosen individuals to all the sons of Jacob, which is his account of the chosenness of Israel.
4. [How can God know the future if we have free will?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/how-can-god-know-the-future-if-we-have-free-will) (Grade 11) — The question of free will and divine foreknowledge asks how a person can choose freely if God already knows the choice. Rabbi Akiva holds both: “הכל צפוי והרשות נתונה” (all is foreseen, and permission is given, Avot 3:15). Saadia Gaon answers that knowing is not causing; Maimonides, that God's knowledge is beyond human grasp; Gersonides and Crescas each give up part of one side.
5. [Why do the righteous suffer in Jewish thought?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/why-do-the-righteous-suffer) (Grade 11) — Jewish thought gives several answers to why the righteous suffer, and none settles it alone. The Talmud tells a sufferer to examine his deeds and speaks of “יסורין של אהבה” (sufferings of love); Rabbi Yaakov puts the reward in the world to come; and Rabbi Yannai admits that it is not in our hands to explain the suffering of the righteous (Avot 4:15).
6. [What are the three oaths in the Talmud?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/what-are-the-three-oaths-in-the-talmud) (Grade 11) — The three oaths are a Talmudic teaching in Ketubot 111a: Israel swore not to go up to the Land “as a wall”, en masse, and not to rebel against the nations, and the nations swore not to oppress Israel too much. Some rabbis read them as forbidding Zionism before the Messiah; religious Zionists answered that they are not law, or no longer bind.
7. [What is the difference between Leibowitz and Soloveitchik?](https://lessoons.com/en/jewish-thought-questions-and-thinkers/what-is-the-difference-between-leibowitz-and-soloveitchik) (Grade 11) — Both Yeshayahu Leibowitz and Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik, born in 1903, put halakha at the center of Jewish life. The difference between Leibowitz and Soloveitchik is in what keeping it means: for Leibowitz, a decision to serve God that asks nothing for oneself, with feeling beside the point; for Soloveitchik, a struggle of the inner self, which the halakha gives shape and form.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### What are Maimonides' 13 principles of faith?

Maimonides' 13 principles of faith are the beliefs he listed in 1168, in his Commentary on the Mishnah, as the foundations every Jew must hold: five about God (He exists, is one, has no body, is first and alone is worshipped), four about prophecy and the Torah, and four about reward and punishment, the Messiah and resurrection. Later thinkers disputed whether Judaism has such principles at all.

### Why did Maimonides reject the eternity of the world?

Maimonides rejected Aristotle's eternity of the world for two reasons, which he gives in the Guide for the Perplexed 2:25. It had never been proven by demonstration, so there was no reason to reinterpret the Torah's plain sense; and an eternal, unchanging world would rule out miracles and revelation, uprooting the Torah. He did not reject it because of the verses: those, he says, could have been interpreted.

### What is the divine influence in the Kuzari?

The divine influence (ha-inyan ha-elohi, also translated the divine matter) is, in Yehuda Halevi's Kuzari, a level of being above the intellect: what makes a prophet differ from other people as a person differs from an animal. Halevi holds that it passed from Adam through chosen individuals to all the sons of Jacob, which is his account of the chosenness of Israel.

### How can God know the future if we have free will?

The question of free will and divine foreknowledge asks how a person can choose freely if God already knows the choice. Rabbi Akiva holds both: “הכל צפוי והרשות נתונה” (all is foreseen, and permission is given, Avot 3:15). Saadia Gaon answers that knowing is not causing; Maimonides, that God's knowledge is beyond human grasp; Gersonides and Crescas each give up part of one side.

### What does Jewish Thought: Questions and Thinkers for 11th Grade cover?

The questions Jewish thinkers have argued over and the answers they gave: what counts as a principle of faith, how reason and revelation fit together, what chosenness claims, why the righteous suffer, and what modern thinkers made of all of it. The unit includes 7 ordered lessons covering The thirteen principles and the idea of a creed, The Rambam on reason and revelation, Yehuda HaLevi, the Kuzari and the claim of chosenness, Free will beside a knowing God.
