# How does free trade affect consumer and producer surplus?

> Written with AI · [International trade and the balance of payments](https://lessoons.com/en/international-trade) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/international-trade/how-does-free-trade-affect-consumer-and-producer-surplus

When a small country opens a market to imports at a world price below its own, the local price falls to the world price. Consumer surplus rises, because buyers pay less and buy more; producer surplus falls, because local firms sell less at a lower price. The consumers' gain is larger than the producers' loss, so the country as a whole gains.

## The topic explained

### The world price and a small country

Opening a market to free trade changes the price, and so the consumer surplus and the producer surplus in it. Take a small country's cheese market (numbers made up for this page): demand Q_(d) = 90 - 2P and supply Q_(s) = 3P - 60, in thousands of tons at a price in shekels per kilo. Closed to trade, the market clears at 90 - 2P = 3P - 60, so P = 30 and 30 thousand tons.

Abroad, cheese sells at a world price of ₪24. A small country buys too little to move that price, so once trade is free, nobody at home pays more than ₪24 and nobody at home sells for less: the local price falls to the world price.

### A worked example: how much is imported

At ₪24, buyers want 90 - 48 = 42 thousand tons and local firms make 72 - 60 = 12 thousand. The gap, 42 - 12 = 30 thousand tons, is imported. Local output falls from 30 to 12, and the firms whose costs are above ₪24 a kilo stop producing.

On the graph, imports are the horizontal distance between the supply curve and the demand curve along the world-price line. The lower the world price, the wider the gap: at ₪20 local firms would make nothing, 3 · 20 - 60 = 0, and all 50 thousand tons bought would be imported.

The rule is general: when the world price is below the price without trade, the country imports; when it is above, the country exports.

### Who gains, who loses, and the net gain

Consumers pay ₪6 less on every kilo they used to buy and gain on the 12 thousand new tons they now buy: Δ CS = 6 · (30 + 42)/2 = 216 million shekels. Producers sell less at a lower price: Δ PS = -6 · (30 + 12)/2 = -126 million shekels.

Part of the consumers' gain, 126, is the producers' loss passed to buyers. The rest, 216 - 126 = 90 million shekels, is a net gain to the country, the two triangles in the graph: cheese now bought abroad more cheaply than it could be made at home, and cheese bought that buyers value above the world price. That is what economists mean by the gains from trade.

### What the numbers hide, and common mistakes

The net gain is a total. It does not say that everyone gains: the losses fall on a few firms and their workers, who may need time and help to move to other work, while the gains are spread over many buyers. This is why opening a market is argued over even when the sum is positive.

Three mistakes are common. Computing the producers' loss on the new output, 12 thousand tons, instead of on the average of the old and new outputs. Forgetting that the country could just as well export: at a world price of ₪35 the local price rises, producers gain and consumers lose, and again the gain exceeds the loss. And thinking that imports “take” the gain abroad: the gain is measured inside the country, in what its buyers and firms pay and receive.

## Practice: free trade and surplus

For 12th grade economics students. Use the equations, the graph, the table and the chain of boxes on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Explain in two sentences why a small country trades at the world price.** — It buys or sells too small a share of the world market to move the price. Once trade is free, buyers will not pay more than the world price and sellers will not take less.
2. **Demand is Q_(d) = 90 - 2P and supply Q_(s) = 3P - 60. Find the price and quantity without trade.** — 90 - 2P = 3P - 60, so 5P = 150, P = 30 shekels a kilo and Q = 30 thousand tons.
3. **Use the graph. The world price is ₪26. How much is bought at home, made at home and imported?** — Bought: 90 - 52 = 38 thousand tons. Made: 78 - 60 = 18 thousand. Imported: 38 - 18 = 20 thousand tons.
4. **At the world price of ₪26, compute the change in consumer surplus and in producer surplus, and fill in the table.** — Δ CS = 4 · (30 + 38)/2 = 136. Δ PS = -4 · (30 + 18)/2 = -96. Net gain: 136 - 96 = 40 million shekels, which equals 1/2 · 4 · 20.
5. **Fill in the blank box of the chain for a world price of ₪35, and say who gains and who loses.** — Buyers take 20 thousand tons and firms make 45 thousand. Producers gain and consumers lose; the net gain is 1/2 · 5 · 25 = 62.5 million shekels.
6. **Why is the world price of ₪24 a larger gain to the country than ₪26, compared with no trade?** — The further the world price is from the price without trade, the larger the triangles of net gain: 90 million at ₪24 against 40 million at ₪26.
7. **Write a short paragraph: the net gain is positive, so why do local cheese makers oppose opening the market?** — A good answer says that the net gain is a sum over the whole country, while the loss of 126 million falls on a small group of firms and workers, who lose a great deal each. The consumers' gain is spread thinly, so the losers have the stronger reason to organize.

## Common questions

### What are the gains from trade?

The rise in total surplus when a country trades at the world price: what buyers gain from cheaper imports, or producers from higher export prices, minus what the other side loses. In the simple model it is always positive.

### Does free trade make everyone better off?

No. In an importing market buyers gain and local producers lose. The total gain is larger than the loss, so the winners could compensate the losers, but nothing in the market makes them do so.

### What is a small open economy?

A country whose purchases and sales are too small to change world prices. It takes the world price as given, as Israel does for most goods it imports.

### What happens if the world price is above the local price?

The country exports. The local price rises to the world price, producers make more and gain, buyers pay more and lose, and the producers' gain is larger than the buyers' loss.

### How is this asked on the bagrut?

Students find imports or exports at a world price from domestic demand and supply, compute the changes in consumer and producer surplus, and explain why the country gains while one group loses.
