# What is the conflict between Antigone and Creon?

> Written with AI · [Literature](https://lessoons.com/en/hebrew-literature-bagrut) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-08 · https://lessoons.com/en/hebrew-literature-bagrut/what-is-the-conflict-between-antigone-and-creon

In Sophocles' tragedy Antigone, Creon, king of Thebes, forbids the burial of Polyneices, who attacked the city, and his sister Antigone buries him anyway. The conflict sets the unwritten law of the gods and of family against the law of the city. Both claims are strong, both are held without compromise, and that is what makes the play a tragedy rather than a story of hero and villain.

## The topic explained

### Two claims at their strongest

Sophocles' Antigone was first staged in the 440s BCE. The sons of Oedipus, Eteocles and Polyneices, have killed each other in a war for Thebes. Creon, the new king, decrees that Eteocles, who defended the city, be buried with honor, and that Polyneices, who led an army against it, lie unburied, “a corpse for birds and dogs to eat” (R. C. Jebb's translation, as are all quotations here). Antigone, their sister, buries him and is caught.

Antigone's claim is not a whim but a higher law: “it was not Zeus that had published me that edict,” and no mortal can override “the unwritten and unfailing statutes of heaven,” whose life “is not of to-day or yesterday, but from all time.” Her duty to her dead brother is also love: “'Tis not my nature to join in hating, but in loving.”

Creon's claim is just as serious. After a civil war, the city is what keeps everyone alive: “our country is the ship that bears us safe.” A traitor cannot be honored like the man who died defending it, and the law must hold “in just things and unjust,” because “disobedience is the worst of evils.” The common mistake: Antigone the heroine, Creon the villain. The philosopher Hegel read the play as a clash of two rights, each one-sided.

### The function of the chorus

The chorus of Theban elders speaks for the city both sides claim, and its odes, sung between the scenes, step back to widen the meaning. At first it defers to Creon: “thou hast power, I ween, to take what order thou wilt.” Its famous Ode to Man begins “Wonders are many, and none is more wonderful than man,” and ends by praising the man who “honours the laws of the land, and that justice which he hath sworn by the gods to uphold”: both laws, not one.

To Antigone on her way to death it says both things at once: “Reverent action claims a certain praise for reverence; but an offence against power cannot be brooked by him who hath power in his keeping. Thy self-willed temper hath wrought thy ruin.” Students often treat the chorus as background or as Sophocles' own voice. It is neither: its movement shows where the argument is going.

### The turning point and its cause

The turning point comes when the blind prophet Teiresias tells Creon that the gods reject the city's sacrifices, because birds and dogs carry the unburied flesh to the altars. He offers a way back: “All men are liable to err; but when an error hath been made, that man is no longer witless or unblest who heals the ill into which he hath fallen, and remains not stubborn.” Creon mocks him, and gives way only when Teiresias foretells that Creon's own son will die: “'Tis dire to yield.”

The chorus tells him: “Go thou, and free the maiden from her rocky chamber, and make a tomb for the unburied dead.” He buries Polyneices first, and reaches the tomb too late: Antigone has hanged herself, his son Haemon kills himself beside her, and his wife Eurydice kills herself. The cause is not only the prophecy but the stubbornness that made Creon yield too late, the error he names himself: “Woe is me, for the wretched blindness of my counsels!”

### Refusing to obey a law, today

The play still frames arguments about civil disobedience: when may a citizen break a law that conscience forbids? Israeli law gives one answer for soldiers: an order that is manifestly illegal must be refused, the black flag test set by the military court in the Kafr Qasim trial in 1958. To apply the play, set out the case, give Antigone's claim (a law above the state) and Creon's (the law that protects everyone), and say what each side's refusal to listen costs.

## Antigone and Creon: the two claims, the chorus and the turning point

For 12th grade students reading Antigone for the literature bagrut. The lines are quoted in R. C. Jebb's translation. Answer in full sentences, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Who is who? Write one sentence about each character.
a. Polyneices
b. Ismene
c. Haemon
d. Teiresias** — a. Polyneices: Antigone's brother, who led an army against Thebes and lies unburied by Creon's edict. b. Ismene: her sister, who refuses to help, then asks to share her death and is turned away. c. Haemon: Creon's son, engaged to Antigone. d. Teiresias: the blind prophet who warns Creon.
2. **Place each quotation in the right column of the diagram, and complete the box of the chorus.
1. “our country is the ship that bears us safe”
2. “'Tis not my nature to join in hating, but in loving.”
3. “disobedience is the worst of evils”
4. “I owe a longer allegiance to the dead than to the living”** — Antigone: 2 (love, not hate) and 4 (duty to the dead). Creon: 1 (the state is a ship) and 3 (obedience and order). The chorus: between them, honoring the laws of the land and the justice of the gods together.
3. **Antigone tells Creon that she did not believe his decrees were “of such force, that a mortal could override the unwritten and unfailing statutes of heaven. For their life is not of to-day or yesterday, but from all time.” What kind of law does she set above the edict, and what do the words “from all time” add?** — She sets the unwritten law of the gods above a king's written decree. “From all time” says that this law was not made by any ruler and cannot be repealed by one: Creon's edict is a day old, the duty to bury the dead is eternal.
4. **The chorus says to Antigone: “Reverent action claims a certain praise for reverence; but an offence against power cannot be brooked by him who hath power in his keeping. Thy self-willed temper hath wrought thy ruin.” On whose side is the chorus here? Explain.** — On neither side alone. It praises her reverence, the claim of the gods, but says that power cannot let its law be broken, which is Creon's claim, and it blames her own self-willed temper. The chorus stands where the play stands: between the claims.
5. **Complete the chain of the turning point: what goes in each empty box?** — Prophecy: the death of his own son, a corpse for corpses. Turning point: Creon yields (“'Tis dire to yield”) and goes to free Antigone. Too late: Antigone has hanged herself in the tomb.
6. **Haemon tells his father: “the trees that yield to it save every twig, while the stiff-necked perish root and branch.” What is the image, and how does the end of the play prove it?** — Trees beside a winter torrent: those that bend survive, those that stand rigid are torn out. Creon refuses to bend until it is too late, and loses his son and his wife: the stiff-necked tree perishes root and branch.
7. **A student wrote: “Antigone is right and Creon is a cruel tyrant, so the play is about good against evil.” What is missing? Rewrite the opening of the answer.** — It gives only one side and turns the tragedy into a melodrama. Better: Both claims are strong: Antigone defends the unwritten law of the gods and her duty to her brother, and Creon defends the law that holds the city together after a civil war. The tragedy is that each holds only half of what is right.
8. **Apply the conflict to a case argued about today: a soldier is given an order he believes is deeply wrong. Israeli military law says a manifestly illegal order must be refused. Write a paragraph: how would Antigone argue, how would Creon argue, and what does the play suggest?** — A good paragraph gives Antigone's argument (a higher law than the order, which conscience cannot break) and Creon's (an army and a state collapse if each person decides which orders to obey). It says the play does not hand a verdict, but warns against refusing to listen, and it quotes at least one line.

## Common questions

### Who is the tragic hero of Antigone, Antigone or Creon?

Both readings are argued. Antigone gives the play its name and dies for her belief. But Creon is the one who passes through Aristotle's stages: a stubborn error, a reversal when he yields too late, and a recognition when he cries out at “the wretched blindness of my counsels.” A good answer chooses one and defends it with the text.

### Why does Antigone bury her brother twice?

The first burial is a thin layer of dust, done in secret. The guards sweep the dust away and bare the body; at noon a whirlwind fills the plain with dust, and when it clears they see Antigone at the corpse, crying out and pouring offerings, and they seize her. The second burial shows that she will not let the law of the city undo the rite.

### Why does Ismene refuse to help Antigone?

Ismene thinks two women cannot fight the king and the law, and that a hopeless quest should not be begun. Later, when Antigone is caught, she claims a share in the deed and asks to die with her. Antigone refuses: “a friend in words is not the friend that I love.” Ismene shows the ordinary choice the heroine rejects.

### What is the Ode to Man in Antigone?

It is the chorus's first ode after the burial is discovered, beginning “Wonders are many, and none is more wonderful than man.” It praises human skill, the ship, the plough and the city, and warns that the same skill leads to evil as well as good. It ends by honoring the man who keeps both the laws of the land and the justice of the gods.

### Is Antigone a play about civil disobedience?

It is often read that way, because Antigone breaks a law openly and accepts the penalty. But the play does not simply side with her: it gives Creon's claim real weight and shows the cost of both sides' stubbornness. That is why it is still used to argue about conscience, the law and the limits of a state's power.
