# What is a beinoni in the Tanya?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Hasidism, the Mitnagdim and Musar](https://lessoons.com/en/hasidism-mitnagdim-and-musar) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/hasidism-mitnagdim-and-musar/what-is-a-beinoni-in-the-tanya

In the Tanya, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi's book (first printed 1796), a beinoni (the intermediate person) is not someone half good and half bad. He never sins in thought, speech or deed, yet still feels the pull to evil, because his mind rules his heart. The Tanya calls this the level every person can reach at any moment.

## The topic explained

### Three kinds of people

The Talmud names three kinds: “צדיקים יצר טוב שופטן” (the righteous are judged by the good inclination), the wicked by the evil one, and “בינונים — זה וזה שופטן” (the intermediate are judged by both, Berakhot 61b). Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi (1745–1812), founder of Chabad Hasidism, built the Tanya, first printed in 1796, around these three and above all the middle one, the beinoni.

The common mistake is to think a beinoni is someone with half good deeds and half bad, an average person. The Tanya rejects this: the beinoni “שבודאי אינו מחצה זכיות ומחצה עונות” (is certainly not half merits and half sins, ch. 1), and one who sins is called a rasha at the moment he sins. The beinoni of the Tanya stands far higher than that, and yet, the book says, within every person's reach.

### Two souls and a small city

The Tanya teaches that every Jew “יש שתי נשמות” (has two souls, ch. 1): an animal soul that gives life to the body and from which bad traits come, and a divine soul that seeks God. They are at war over the body, which the book calls a small city: “וכמו ששני מלכים נלחמים על עיר אחת, שכל אחד רוצה לכבשה ולמלוך עליה” (as two kings fight over one city, each wanting to conquer it and rule over it, ch. 9).

The image explains a familiar experience: wanting to do two opposite things at once, say to study for tomorrow's test and to keep scrolling. For the Tanya this is not a sign that something is wrong with you; it is what being human feels like.

### The beinoni defined

Chapter 12 gives the definition: “והבינוני, הוא שלעולם אין הרע גובר כל כך לכבוש את העיר קטנה להתלבש בגוף להחטיאו” (the beinoni is one in whom evil never prevails to conquer the small city, to clothe itself in the body and make it sin). The pull of the animal soul is real, but its thought, speech and deed never enter his life: “ולא עבר עבירה מימיו ולא יעבור לעולם” (he has never committed a sin and never will).

How? Not because he feels no desire, but “כי המוח שליט על הלב” (because the mind rules the heart, ch. 12) by nature: a person can choose with his mind not to act on what his heart wants. The beinoni's struggle never ends; only the tzaddik has turned the evil in him into good.

### A level for everyone

Here is the Tanya's comfort and demand: “מדת הבינוני, היא מדת כל אדם ואחריה כל אדם ימשוך, שכל אדם יכול להיות בינוני בכל עת ובכל שעה” (the measure of the beinoni is the measure of every person, and every person should strive for it, for every person can be a beinoni at any time and any hour, ch. 14). One cannot always choose what one feels, but one can choose what one thinks about, says and does.

Critics within the tradition note that the bar is very high, never sinning at all; admirers answer that it moves the goal from feelings, which are not in our control, to actions, which are. A strong answer defines the three types, explains the two souls and the mind over the heart, and weighs this claim.

## Practice: the beinoni in the Tanya

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Who wrote the Tanya, when was it first printed, and which Hasidic movement does it belong to?** — Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi (1745–1812), founder of Chabad Hasidism; it was first printed in 1796.
2. **Fill in the two empty boxes of the table.** — The beinoni's inner pull: still felt, though it never wins. The rasha's deeds: he sins at times.
3. **A student says: a beinoni is an average person, half good deeds and half bad. Why does the Tanya reject this?** — For the Tanya one who sins is, at that moment, a rasha. The beinoni never sins in thought, speech or deed; what makes him a beinoni and not a tzaddik is that he still feels the pull to evil.
4. **Write the soul replaced by a question mark, and explain the image of the small city.** — The animal soul. The body is a small city over which two kings, the divine soul and the animal soul, fight; each wants to rule its thoughts, words and deeds (ch. 9).
5. **“והבינוני, הוא שלעולם אין הרע גובר כל כך לכבוש את העיר קטנה להתלבש בגוף להחטיאו” (the beinoni is one in whom evil never prevails to conquer the small city to make it sin). What does the beinoni still have that the tzaddik does not?** — The pull of the evil inside him: the beinoni feels desire for wrong but never lets it act; in the tzaddik the evil has been turned into good.
6. **Write the missing step in the diagram, and give an example from a student's life.** — The mind rules the heart: the person feels a pull but decides with his mind not to act on it, for example closing a game to study though he wants to keep playing.
7. **“מדת הבינוני, היא מדת כל אדם ואחריה כל אדם ימשוך, שכל אדם יכול להיות בינוני בכל עת ובכל שעה” (the measure of the beinoni is the measure of every person; every person can be a beinoni at any time). Why might this sentence be encouraging?** — It moves the goal from feelings, which a person cannot fully control, to thought, speech and deed, which he can; so the level of beinoni is open to everyone, at every moment.
8. **Write a paragraph: is the Tanya's beinoni a realistic ideal? Use two quotations from this sheet, an objection and your view.** — A good answer explains the beinoni (ch. 12) and the claim that anyone can be one (ch. 14), raises an objection (never sinning at all is very demanding), answers it (the goal is control of action, not of feeling), and argues a view.

## Common questions

### What does beinoni mean?

Beinoni means intermediate, between the tzaddik and the rasha. In the Tanya it is one who never sins in thought, speech or deed but still feels the pull to evil, which he overcomes by the mind ruling the heart.

### What are the two souls in the Tanya?

The animal soul, which gives life to the body and is the source of bad traits and desires, and the divine soul, which seeks God. They struggle over the body, which the Tanya calls a small city.

### Can anyone become a tzaddik according to the Tanya?

The Tanya treats the complete tzaddik as a rare level, in whom evil has been turned into good. The level of beinoni, by contrast, is one every person can reach at any time (ch. 14).

### Why is the Tanya called Likkutei Amarim?

Likkutei Amarim, collected sayings, is the name of its first part; the book is commonly called Tanya after its opening word, from a teaching quoted from the Talmud (Niddah 30b).

### How is the Tanya connected to Hasidism?

Its author, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, was a student of the Maggid of Mezeritch and founded Chabad. The Tanya gives the Hasidic call to serve God a systematic, intellectual form.
