# How are GM foods regulated?

> Written with AI · [Genetically modified organisms: from microbes to crops](https://lessoons.com/en/genetically-modified-organisms) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/genetically-modified-organisms/how-are-gm-foods-regulated

GM foods are regulated by a review before sale and by labeling rules, and countries do both differently. The European Union reviews a food because it was made by genetic engineering and labels it above 0.9% GM content per ingredient. The United States reviews the product itself and has required disclosure since 2022, above 5% per ingredient.

## The topic explained

### Same science, two questions

Every country that regulates GM food asks whether it is safe for people, animals and the environment. They differ on what triggers the question. The European Union takes a process-based approach: a food is reviewed because it was made with genetic engineering. Its rules for GM food and feed and for their labeling date from October 2003. The United States takes a product-based approach: under a framework set in 1986, the Department of Agriculture, the Environmental Protection Agency and the Food and Drug Administration each look at the product's own traits, as they would for any new crop, pesticide or food.

A common misreading is that one side tests GM food and the other does not. Both require safety data. The difference is which foods enter special review, and what the label must say.

### From application to approval, step by step

The path has the same shape almost everywhere. The company submits its data: what the genetic change is, the new protein, the food's composition compared with the ordinary crop, feeding studies and the environmental effects. Much of the review is a comparison with the ordinary crop, an idea the OECD called substantial equivalence in 1993: whatever differs is what gets studied closely. Scientists assess the risk; in the EU this is the European Food Safety Authority, EFSA. Officials then decide; in the EU the Commission and the member states vote. An approved food is labeled and traced through the supply chain, and its effects are monitored after it goes on sale. Moving living GM organisms between countries is covered by an international treaty, the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, in force since 2003.

### Labels and their thresholds

In the EU, a food that contains GM material, or is made from a GM crop, must say so. Traces that got in by accident and could not be avoided are allowed up to 0.9% of each ingredient. In the US, the Bioengineered Food Disclosure Standard, passed by Congress in 2016, became mandatory on January 1, 2022. It allows up to 5% of accidental presence per ingredient, and the label may be text, a symbol or a QR code.

The rules also differ on refined foods. Oil or sugar refined from a GM crop often contains no detectable modified DNA. The US does not count such a food as bioengineered; the EU labels it because it was produced from a GMO. That one difference follows directly from product versus process.

### Israel, and the arguments over labels

In Israel, according to a US Department of Agriculture report of October 2025, imported GE commodities are not restricted, and GE crops are grown only under research permits, under seed regulations of 2005; earlier reports describe draft Health Ministry rules for novel foods that include GE components. Supporters of mandatory labels speak of the consumer's right to know and to choose. Opponents answer that a label suggests a risk the evidence does not show, and adds costs. Both sides cite evidence; the deeper disagreement is about values.

On a bagrut question, name the approach before the details: say whether a rule looks at the process or at the product, and the thresholds, the treatment of refined foods and the debate over labels all follow from that answer.

## Practice: how GM foods are regulated

For 12th grade biotechnology students. Answer each question from the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Explain the difference between process-based and product-based regulation in one sentence each.** — Process-based: a food enters special review because it was made by genetic engineering (the EU). Product-based: the product is reviewed by its own traits, whatever method made it (the US).
2. **Fill in the labeling thresholds in the table.** — EU: 0.9% of GM material per ingredient. US: 5% per ingredient. Below these, accidental and unavoidable presence needs no label.
3. **Fill in steps 2 and 4 of the approval path.** — 2: scientists assess the risk (in the EU, the European Food Safety Authority). 4: the approved food is labeled and traced through the supply chain.
4. **Three ingredients contain accidental GM material: A 0.5%, B 3%, C 7%. Which need a label in the EU, and which in the US?** — EU (above 0.9%): B and C. US (above 5%): only C. A needs no label in either.
5. **Oil refined from GM soybeans contains no detectable modified DNA. Is it labeled in the EU? In the US? Explain why the answers differ.** — In the EU it is labeled, because it was produced from a GMO: the rule looks at the process. In the US it is usually not, because the rule looks at the product, and no modified genetic material can be detected in it.
6. **According to the USDA report of October 2025, what are Israel's rules on imported GE commodities and on growing GE crops?** — Imported GE commodities are not restricted. GE crops are grown only under research permits, under the 2005 seed regulations for genetically engineered plants.
7. **Write one argument for mandatory GM labels and one against.** — For: consumers have a right to know how their food was made and to choose. Against: the label suggests a risk the scientific evidence does not show, and it adds costs for producers and shoppers.

## Common questions

### Are GM foods tested before they are sold?

In the countries that approve them, yes: the company must submit data on the genetic change, the new protein, the food's composition and its effects, and a scientific body assesses the risk before officials decide.

### Why does the EU have stricter GMO rules than the US?

The EU applies a process-based approach and a precautionary principle: a food made by genetic engineering enters special review and is labeled. The US looks at the product's traits, so a GM food goes through the same agencies as any comparable product.

### What is the Cartagena Protocol?

The Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety is an international treaty, adopted in January 2000 and in force since September 2003, on moving living genetically modified organisms between countries, so that an importing country can decide with information in hand.

### Do gene-edited foods count as GM foods?

It depends on the country. Some treat a gene-edited crop with no foreign DNA like a conventional crop, while others review it as a GMO. The rules on this are still changing in many places.

### What does the bioengineered symbol in the US mean?

It is one of the ways a US food can meet the disclosure standard in force since 2022: it says the food contains detectable modified genetic material above the 5% allowance for an ingredient.
