# Jewish Thought: Free Will and Providence in Depth – 12th Grade

> Written with AI · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought

Pharaoh was punished because he first chose evil freely: for the first five plagues the Torah says he hardened his own heart. Hard cases for the belief that people choose and God guides: the hardening of Pharaoh's heart, the one thing that is not in the hands of heaven, the stars and fate, and the balance between trust in God and human effort.

## Lessons in this topic (in learning order)

1. [Why was Pharaoh punished if God hardened his heart?](https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought/why-was-pharaoh-punished-if-god-hardened-his-heart) (Grade 12) — Pharaoh was punished because he first chose evil freely: for the first five plagues the Torah says he hardened his own heart. Maimonides explains that God's hardening was itself the punishment, the withholding of repentance from a man who had sinned greatly. Sforno reads it the other way: it kept Pharaoh free from fear, so his choice stayed his own.
2. [What does everything is in the hands of heaven except the fear of heaven mean?](https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought/what-does-everything-is-in-the-hands-of-heaven-except-the-fear-of-heaven-mean) (Grade 12) — The saying “everything is in the hands of heaven except the fear of heaven” (Berakhot 33b) means that God decides much of a person's life, such as strength, talent and wealth, but not whether that person will be righteous or wicked. Reverence for God and moral choice are left to human freedom, and so they are what God asks for.
3. [What does ein mazal leYisrael mean?](https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought/what-does-ein-mazal-leyisrael-mean) (Grade 12) — Ein mazal leYisrael means “Israel has no star”: the stars do not decide the fate of the Jewish people, because their deeds and prayers can change it. It is Rabbi Yochanan's view in Shabbat 156a, against Rabbi Chanina, who held that a person's star does shape his wisdom and wealth. Maimonides later rejected astrology altogether.
4. [What is the balance between bitachon and hishtadlut?](https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought/what-is-the-balance-between-bitachon-and-hishtadlut) (Grade 12) — Bitachon is trust in God and hishtadlut is human effort. Most Jewish sources hold that they work together: a person must act, by working, studying or seeing a doctor, while trusting that the result is in God's hands. Rabbi Yishmael says to work in the way of the world; Chovot HaLevavot says effort is itself God's command.
5. [What is Can a decree be torn up?](https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought#lesson-5) (Grade 12) — The sages list deeds that tear up a person's decree, and the prayer Unetaneh Tokef sets repentance, prayer and charity against it.
6. [What is Where choice happens?](https://lessoons.com/en/free-will-and-providence-in-jewish-thought#lesson-6) (Grade 12) — Thinkers ask whether a person chooses in every act or only at the edge of what he already is, and what that means for growth.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Why was Pharaoh punished if God hardened his heart?

Pharaoh was punished because he first chose evil freely: for the first five plagues the Torah says he hardened his own heart. Maimonides explains that God's hardening was itself the punishment, the withholding of repentance from a man who had sinned greatly. Sforno reads it the other way: it kept Pharaoh free from fear, so his choice stayed his own.

### What does everything is in the hands of heaven except the fear of heaven mean?

The saying “everything is in the hands of heaven except the fear of heaven” (Berakhot 33b) means that God decides much of a person's life, such as strength, talent and wealth, but not whether that person will be righteous or wicked. Reverence for God and moral choice are left to human freedom, and so they are what God asks for.

### What does ein mazal leYisrael mean?

Ein mazal leYisrael means “Israel has no star”: the stars do not decide the fate of the Jewish people, because their deeds and prayers can change it. It is Rabbi Yochanan's view in Shabbat 156a, against Rabbi Chanina, who held that a person's star does shape his wisdom and wealth. Maimonides later rejected astrology altogether.

### What is the balance between bitachon and hishtadlut?

Bitachon is trust in God and hishtadlut is human effort. Most Jewish sources hold that they work together: a person must act, by working, studying or seeing a doctor, while trusting that the result is in God's hands. Rabbi Yishmael says to work in the way of the world; Chovot HaLevavot says effort is itself God's command.

### What does Jewish Thought: Free Will and Providence in Depth for 12th Grade cover?

Hard cases for the belief that people choose and God guides: the hardening of Pharaoh's heart, the one thing that is not in the hands of heaven, the stars and fate, and the balance between trust in God and human effort. The unit includes 6 ordered lessons covering The hardening of Pharaoh's heart, All is in the hands of heaven except the fear of heaven, Is there fate? Mazal and the stars, Trust in God and human effort.
