# What makes the debt-to-GDP ratio rise or fall?

> Written with AI · [Fiscal policy and the Keynesian model](https://lessoons.com/en/fiscal-policy) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/fiscal-policy/what-makes-the-debt-to-gdp-ratio-rise-or-fall

The debt-to-GDP ratio rises when the interest rate on the debt is higher than the growth rate of GDP and when the budget before interest is in deficit. It falls when the economy grows faster than the interest rate and when the government runs a primary surplus. A country can cut its debt ratio without repaying a shekel, if the economy grows fast enough.

## The topic explained

### Debt grows by interest and by the primary deficit

The public debt is everything the government owes; the debt-to-GDP ratio divides it by a year's GDP, because a debt of ₪1,200 billion means one thing for an economy of ₪2,000 billion and another for one of ₪600 billion. Each year the debt grows for two reasons: interest on what is already owed, and the primary deficit, the gap between spending and revenue before interest payments.

Take a model economy with debt of ₪1,200 billion and GDP of ₪2,000 billion, a ratio of 60%. The interest rate on the debt is 5% and the primary deficit is ₪20 billion (numbers made up for this page). Next year's debt is 1,200 · 1.05 + 20 = 1,280. If GDP grows by 3%, to ₪2,060 billion, the ratio becomes 1,2802,060 ≈ 62.14%.

### The race between interest and growth

The ratio is a fraction, and both its parts move. The debt grows at the interest rate r; GDP, the denominator, grows at the growth rate g. A short rule captures the race: Δ d ≈ (r - g) · d + pd where d is the debt ratio and pd the primary deficit as a share of GDP. In the example, (5% - 3%) · 60% + 1% = 2.2 points, close to the exact 2.14.

When r > g, a government must run a primary surplus just to hold the ratio steady: here about 0.02/1.03 · 60% ≈ 1.17% of GDP. When r < g, the ratio can fall even with a small deficit: with interest of 3% and growth of 5%, a primary deficit of ₪20 billion leaves a ratio of 1,200 · 1.03 + 202,100 ≈ 59.81%. Over ten years the gap compounds, as the three paths in the chart show: from the same 60%, path A climbs to about 83% and path C falls to about 50%.

### What a government can and cannot control

The primary balance is the lever a government holds: it can cut spending or raise taxes. Growth and interest rates it controls only in part. Nominal growth includes inflation, so unexpected inflation lowers the ratio for a while, which is one reason governments with large debts are tempted by it; investors then demand higher rates on new bonds, and the gain fades.

The rule also explains why cuts in a recession can backfire. If a sharp cut in spending slows growth, g falls, and the ratio may rise in the short run although the deficit is smaller. Economists disagree about how large this effect is, and the bagrut asks for the mechanism and the argument on each side.

### Common mistakes

Confusing the deficit with the debt: the deficit is a yearly flow, the debt the stock it adds to. Thinking the ratio can fall only if the debt is repaid: it falls whenever GDP grows faster than the debt. Forgetting interest: a balanced primary budget still adds the interest to the debt. Mixing real and nominal rates: r and g must both be nominal, or both real.

## Practice: the debt-to-GDP ratio

For 12th grade economics students. Use the tables and the chart on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **What is a primary deficit, and how does it differ from the overall deficit?** — The gap between spending and revenue before interest payments. The overall deficit adds the interest on the debt.
2. **Fill in the table. The primary budget is balanced.** — Debt: 800 · 1.04 = 832. GDP: 1,000 · 1.06 = 1,060. Ratio: 8321,060 ≈ 78.49%, down from 80%.
3. **Use the chart. Which path rises, which stays flat and which falls, and why?** — A rises: interest 5% above growth 3%, plus a primary deficit. B stays at 60%: interest equals growth and the primary budget is balanced. C falls: growth 5% above interest 3%.
4. **Write in the table whether each event pushes the ratio up or down.** — Rates on new bonds rise: up. A boom lifts growth: down. Taxes cut, spending kept: up, because the primary deficit grows.
5. **The debt ratio is 50%, the interest rate 6%, growth 2% and the primary budget balanced. About how much is the ratio a year later?** — Δ d ≈ (6% - 2%) · 50% = 2 points, so about 52%.
6. **With the numbers of the explanation, interest 5% and growth 3%, what primary surplus keeps the ratio at 60%?** — About 0.02/1.03 · 60% ≈ 1.17% of GDP.
7. **Write a short paragraph: can a government lower its debt ratio while still running a deficit? Explain.** — A good answer says yes, when GDP grows faster than the debt: if nominal growth is above the interest rate, the denominator grows faster than the numerator, so a small primary deficit can still leave the ratio lower, as with interest 3%, growth 5% and a deficit of 20.

## Common questions

### Why is public debt measured as a share of GDP?

Because the ability to pay depends on the size of the economy, which is also the base of the taxes. The same debt is a heavy burden for a small economy and a light one for a large one.

### What is the difference between a primary deficit and an overall deficit?

The primary deficit leaves out interest payments; the overall deficit includes them. A government can have a primary surplus and still an overall deficit, if the interest is large.

### What does r minus g mean?

The interest rate on the debt minus the growth rate of GDP. When it is positive the debt ratio tends to rise unless there is a primary surplus; when it is negative the ratio tends to fall.

### Does inflation reduce the public debt?

Unexpected inflation raises nominal GDP while the existing debt stays fixed, so the ratio falls for a while. Lenders then ask for higher interest on new bonds, and the effect fades.

### Can austerity raise the debt ratio?

In the short run it can, if cutting spending in a weak economy slows growth enough. How often this happens is debated among economists.
