# What is the difference between expansionary and contractionary fiscal policy?

> Written with AI · [Fiscal policy and the Keynesian model](https://lessoons.com/en/fiscal-policy) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/fiscal-policy/what-is-the-difference-between-expansionary-and-contractionary-fiscal-policy

Expansionary fiscal policy raises total spending in the economy by increasing government spending or cutting taxes; it is used to close a recessionary gap and it widens the deficit. Contractionary fiscal policy does the opposite, cutting spending or raising taxes, to cool an overheating economy and an inflationary gap. Both work through the multiplier, and both act with delays.

## The topic explained

### Two directions, the same tools

Fiscal policy is the government's use of its budget, spending, taxes and transfers such as allowances and benefits, to influence total demand. Expansionary fiscal policy adds to demand: the government builds more, hires more, pays more in allowances or cuts taxes. Contractionary fiscal policy takes demand away: it cuts spending or transfers or raises taxes.

The choice follows the output gap. In a recessionary gap, with output below potential and unemployment high, policy expands. In an inflationary gap, with output above potential and prices rising fast, policy contracts. An expansion widens the budget deficit; a contraction narrows it.

Economists separate discretionary policy, a decision by the government and parliament to change spending or taxes, from the budget's automatic response to the business cycle. This page is about the first. A typical expansion in a slump combines several tools at once: a public works program, a temporary tax cut and higher unemployment benefits, each reaching the economy at its own speed.

### How much closes a gap

Take an economy with planned spending AE = 135 + 0.75Y (₪ billion, made up for this page). It settles at Y = 135/0.25 = 540, while potential output is 600: a recessionary gap of 60. With an MPC of 0.75, the spending multiplier is 4, so extra spending of 60/4 = 15 closes it; the tax multiplier is -3, so a tax cut of 60/3 = 20 would do the same.

For an inflationary gap of 40, the same multipliers give a cut in spending of 40/4 = 10 or a rise in taxes of 40/3 ≈ 13.3. Spending changes act more strongly per shekel than tax changes, because part of a tax change is absorbed by saving.

### Lags, crowding out and debt

Fiscal policy is slow. It takes months for data to show a slump, more time for the government and parliament to agree, in Israel the budget is passed by the Knesset, and more time before the money is spent. By then the economy may already be recovering, and the stimulus can push it into an inflationary gap.

There are other limits. When the state borrows more, interest rates can rise and private investment can fall, crowding out part of the effect. Expansions add to the public debt, which must be serviced later. And some of the work is done without any decision, by automatic stabilizers: in a slump taxes fall and benefits rise by themselves, cushioning demand.

### Common mistakes

Dividing the gap by the wrong multiplier: a change in spending uses 1/(1 - MPC), a change in taxes (MPC)/(1 - MPC). Treating expansionary policy as always good: in an inflationary gap it adds to inflation. And confusing fiscal with monetary policy: the interest rate is set by the central bank, the budget by the government and the Knesset.

## Practice: expansionary and contractionary fiscal policy

For 12th grade economics students. Use the graph, the tables and the chain of boxes on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Name the three tools of fiscal policy, and say which way each moves in an expansionary policy.** — Government spending (raised), taxes (cut) and transfer payments such as allowances (raised).
2. **Use the graph. Where does AE1 cross the 45-degree line, and how large is the gap from potential output of 600?** — At 540, since 135/0.25 = 540. The gap is 540 - 600 = -60, a recessionary gap.
3. **Fill in the table for an MPC of 0.8.** — Gap −50: expansionary; spending +50/5 = 10, or taxes -50/4 = -12.5. Gap +30: contractionary; spending -30/5 = -6, or taxes +30/4 = 7.5.
4. **Write in the table whether each measure is expansionary or contractionary.** — New railways: expansionary. Raising VAT: contractionary. Raising child allowances: expansionary. Cutting public-sector wages: contractionary.
5. **Fill in the last box of the chain, and name the effect.** — Private investment falls. This is crowding out: government borrowing raises interest rates and pushes out part of private spending.
6. **Why can a stimulus decided in a recession end up adding to inflation?** — Because of the lags: by the time the slump is recognized, the budget is passed and the money spent, the economy may have recovered, so the extra demand arrives when output is already near or above potential.
7. **Write a short paragraph: in a recession, should a government raise spending or cut taxes? Give one argument for each.** — A good answer says that spending has a larger multiplier and can go to useful projects such as infrastructure, but is slow to start; tax cuts reach households quickly and leave the choice to them, but part is saved, so the effect per shekel is smaller.

## Common questions

### What is fiscal policy?

The use of the government budget, spending, taxes and transfer payments, to influence total demand, output and employment. It is decided by the government and passed in the budget by parliament.

### When is contractionary fiscal policy used?

When the economy is overheating, with output above potential and inflation rising, or when the public debt is judged too high. Cutting spending or raising taxes lowers demand and narrows the deficit.

### What is crowding out?

The fall in private spending, mostly investment, that can follow higher government borrowing, because interest rates rise. It makes expansionary fiscal policy weaker than the simple multiplier suggests.

### What is the difference between fiscal and monetary policy?

Fiscal policy uses the government budget: spending and taxes. Monetary policy uses the interest rate and the quantity of money, and in Israel it is set by the Bank of Israel's Monetary Committee.

### How is this asked on the bagrut?

Students identify the kind of gap, choose expansionary or contractionary policy, compute the change in spending or taxes that closes the gap with the right multiplier, and discuss lags and crowding out.
