# What is Fackenheim's 614th commandment?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Faith After the Holocaust](https://lessoons.com/en/faith-after-the-holocaust) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/faith-after-the-holocaust/what-is-fackenheims-614th-commandment

Fackenheim's 614th commandment is Emil Fackenheim's claim, first made in 1967, that after the Holocaust Jews are forbidden to hand Hitler posthumous victories. In our words: Jews must survive as Jews, remember the victims, and not despair of God or of the world. He refused to explain the Holocaust; he heard in it a command.

## The topic explained

### A survivor who became a philosopher

Emil Fackenheim was born in Halle, Germany. On Kristallnacht, in November 1938, he was arrested and held in the Sachsenhausen concentration camp. Released, he fled to Britain, was interned in Canada as an enemy alien in 1940, and became a professor of philosophy in Toronto. In 1984 he moved to Israel, and he died in Jerusalem in 2003.

For years he wrote on philosophy and faith. His response to the Holocaust took its final shape in 1967, the year of the Six-Day War, when he also became a Zionist. His works are under copyright, so they are given here only in our own words.

### The 614th commandment

The tradition counts the Torah's commandments: “שש מאות ושלש עשרה מצות נאמרו לו למשה” (613 commandments were told to Moses, Makkot 23b). In 1967 Fackenheim proposed, at a symposium in New York, that Auschwitz adds a 614th: Fackenheim's 614th commandment forbids Jews to hand Hitler posthumous victories. Hitler sought the end of the Jewish people; to give up being Jewish, or to give up hope, would complete his work.

He spoke of a commanding voice of Auschwitz: not an explanation of why it happened, but a demand heard in what happened. The common misreading is that Fackenheim found meaning or purpose in the Holocaust. He insisted it has none. What he heard was not a reason but an order: go on.

### Four parts of one command

In our words, the command has four parts. Survive as Jews, so that the people Hitler meant to destroy lives on. Remember the victims, so that their memory does not perish with them. Do not despair of the God of Israel, even if one cannot believe as before. Do not despair of the world, as the place where good must still be done.

The command speaks to secular and religious Jews alike. A secular Jew who cannot pray is still bound by the first two parts; the believer is bound to keep the third. Survival itself becomes an act of faithfulness. Later, in To Mend the World (1982), whose title names the old idea of tikkun, repair, he argued: since Auschwitz cannot be undone, the task is to mend what can be mended.

### Weighing the command

It helps to place him in the debate. The old answer, that suffering is punishment for sin, explains too much and blames the victims. Richard Rubenstein concluded that the God who acts in history could no longer be affirmed. Berkovits kept that God, hidden for the sake of human freedom. Fackenheim stands apart from all three: he will not explain, and he will not let the lack of an explanation end Jewish life. A theodicy asks why; his command asks what now.

Admirers see in it a powerful answer that refuses both despair and easy explanation. Critics ask whether a Judaism kept alive to deny Hitler a victory rests too much on the enemy, and how a voice can command those who doubt its source. Fackenheim himself later stepped back from any claim that the voice was a kind of revelation. A strong bagrut answer explains the 614th commandment, its four parts and its refusal to explain, and weighs one criticism fairly.

## Practice: Fackenheim's 614th commandment

For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the event of 1967 on the timeline.** — Fackenheim first proposed the 614th commandment, at a symposium in New York, published that summer.
2. **The Talmud says: “שש מאות ושלש עשרה מצות נאמרו לו למשה” (613 commandments were told to Moses). Why does Fackenheim call his command the 614th?** — Because he presents it as one more commandment beside the 613 of the Torah, a command heard after Auschwitz that binds the Jewish people as strongly.
3. **In your own words, what does it mean not to hand Hitler a posthumous victory?** — Hitler sought to end the Jewish people; if Jews stopped living as Jews or gave up hope, his aim would be achieved after his death. Going on as Jews denies him that.
4. **Write the missing part of the command in the hub.** — Do not despair of God (of the God of Israel), even if one cannot believe as before.
5. **Fill in Fackenheim's column in the table.** — Explains it? No: he refuses to give the Holocaust any meaning. Asks of Jews: to go on living as Jews, with the four parts of the command.
6. **A student writes: Fackenheim found the purpose of the Holocaust. What is wrong with this sentence?** — Fackenheim insisted the Holocaust has no purpose or meaning; he did not explain it but heard in it a command to go on living as Jews.
7. **Write a paragraph: present the 614th commandment and one criticism of it, with care and respect.** — A good answer explains the command and its four parts, stresses that it is not an explanation, and gives a criticism (a Judaism resting on the enemy, a voice without a clear source) fairly, with Fackenheim's own later caution.

## Common questions

### Who was Emil Fackenheim?

Emil Fackenheim was a German-born rabbi and philosopher, held in Sachsenhausen after Kristallnacht in 1938, who taught philosophy in Toronto, moved to Israel in 1984 and died in Jerusalem in 2003.

### What is the 614th commandment?

Fackenheim's teaching, first stated in 1967, that after Auschwitz Jews are forbidden to hand Hitler posthumous victories: they must survive as Jews, remember the victims, and not despair of God or of the world.

### What is the commanding voice of Auschwitz?

Fackenheim's phrase for the demand he heard in the Holocaust: not an explanation of why it happened, but a command to go on living as Jews and not to despair.

### Did Fackenheim explain the Holocaust?

No. He refused to find any purpose or meaning in it. His 614th commandment is a response to the Holocaust, not an explanation of it.

### How is Fackenheim different from Berkovits?

Berkovits offers a partial account, God's hiding for the sake of human freedom, to keep faith. Fackenheim gives no account at all and speaks of a command to survive that binds secular and religious Jews alike.
