# What did Eliezer Berkovits say about the Holocaust?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: Faith After the Holocaust](https://lessoons.com/en/faith-after-the-holocaust) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/faith-after-the-holocaust/what-did-eliezer-berkovits-say-about-the-holocaust

Eliezer Berkovits argued in Faith after the Holocaust (1973) that God hides His face so that human beings can be truly free, and that this freedom includes the freedom of the murderers. God's patience with the wicked is paid for by the innocent. Yet God is also present, and the survival of the Jewish people is His witness.

## The topic explained

### A rabbi who asked the hardest question

Eliezer Berkovits (1908 to 1992) was born in Oradea, served as a rabbi in Berlin until 1939, and later taught Jewish philosophy in Skokie, near Chicago, before moving to Israel in 1976. His book Faith after the Holocaust (1973) is one of the first sustained attempts by an Orthodox thinker to face the murder of six million Jews without denying faith or softening what happened.

Eliezer Berkovits refuses the old answer that suffering is punishment for sin: no sin could explain the Holocaust. He begins instead from a verse: “אָכֵן אַתָּה אֵל מִסְתַּתֵּר אֱלֹהֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל מוֹשִׁיעַ” (truly You are a God who hides Himself, the God of Israel, the savior, Isaiah 45:15). Hiding and saving stand in one verse, and his thought lives between them. His books are quoted here only in our own words.

### Freedom requires a hidden God

The heart of his argument, in our words: if God stopped every evil act the moment it began, human beings would not be free, and without freedom there is no moral person, no goodness chosen for its own sake. The Torah's call “וּבָחַרְתָּ בַּחַיִּים” (choose life, Deuteronomy 30:19) means something only if a person can also choose death. So God holds Himself back, and the room He leaves is the room of human freedom.

This has a terrible cost. God's patience with the wicked, his erekh apayim, is suffered by their victims. The Talmud already reads restraint as divine might. Jeremiah asked “גוים מקרקרין בהיכלו, איה נוראותיו” (nations are rioting in His sanctuary, where is His awesomeness?), Daniel asked where His might was, and the Men of the Great Assembly answered that His might is “שכובש את יצרו שנותן ארך אפים לרשעים” (that He conquers His inclination and is patient with the wicked, Yoma 69b).

### Hidden, and still present

Berkovits does not stop at absence. God, he argues, must be absent and present at once: hidden enough for freedom, present enough that evil does not have the last word. The sign of presence is the people itself. Isaiah says “וְאַתֶּם עֵדַי נְאֻם־ה׳ וַאֲנִי־אֵל” (you are My witnesses, says the Lord, and I am God, 43:12), and the same Talmudic passage adds that His awesomeness is shown “היאך אומה אחת יכולה להתקיים בין האומות” (how can one nation survive among the nations?).

For Berkovits the survival of the Jewish people, and the rebirth of a Jewish state, are signs of God's presence in history. He insists that they do not explain or justify the Holocaust; nothing does.

In a later book, With God in Hell (1979), subtitled Judaism in the Ghettos and Deathcamps, he turned from the philosopher's question to the victims themselves: how Jews kept faith, prayer and human dignity where everything was taken from them. The book sets that faith, held by the victims themselves and not by onlookers, at the center of the record.

### The criticism

Critics ask whether freedom is worth such a price, and why a God who intervened at the Exodus did not intervene at Auschwitz, where the victims had no freedom at all. Richard Rubenstein held that the God of history could no longer be affirmed. Berkovits answers that he offers no explanation, only a way to keep faith while the question stays open. The common mistake is to call this a justification of the Holocaust; it is a refusal to let the Holocaust end faith. A strong answer presents the argument, its sources and one objection in fair words.

## Practice: Eliezer Berkovits

For 12th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the sources printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Write the event of 1973 on the timeline. Why is it important for this topic?** — Berkovits published Faith after the Holocaust, one of the first sustained Orthodox responses to the Holocaust.
2. **Isaiah says: “אָכֵן אַתָּה אֵל מִסְתַּתֵּר אֱלֹהֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל מוֹשִׁיעַ” (truly You are a God who hides Himself, the God of Israel, the savior). Which two ideas in the verse does Berkovits hold together?** — That God hides Himself and that He saves: God is hidden, so that people are free, and yet He is the savior of Israel and present in history.
3. **Complete the diagram: what would follow if God stopped every evil?** — There would be no human freedom, and so no moral choice and no goodness chosen freely.
4. **The sages say that God's might is “שכובש את יצרו שנותן ארך אפים לרשעים” (that He conquers His inclination and is patient with the wicked). How does this idea fit Berkovits's argument, and what is its cost?** — It sees restraint, not intervention, as divine power: God holds back to leave room for freedom. The cost is that His patience with the wicked is suffered by their innocent victims.
5. **Fill in Berkovits's use of patience and of witness in the table.** — Patience: its cost is borne by the innocent. Witness: the survival of the Jewish people shows God's presence in history.
6. **Does Berkovits say that the State of Israel explains or makes up for the Holocaust? Explain.** — No. He sees Israel's rebirth as a sign of God's presence in history, but insists that nothing explains or justifies the Holocaust.
7. **Write a paragraph: present Berkovits's argument from freedom and one objection to it, with care and respect.** — A good answer explains hiding for the sake of freedom, the cost of God's patience, and presence through Jewish survival, then gives an objection (the price of freedom, the victims' lack of freedom, Rubenstein's view) in fair words.

## Common questions

### Who was Eliezer Berkovits?

Eliezer Berkovits (1908 to 1992) was an Orthodox rabbi and philosopher, born in Oradea, a rabbi in Berlin until 1939, later a teacher in Skokie near Chicago, who moved to Israel in 1976 and died in Jerusalem.

### What is the free will defense in Faith after the Holocaust?

In our words: God hides so that human beings are truly free and responsible, and real freedom includes the freedom to do terrible evil. Berkovits holds that this does not explain the Holocaust but shows why God's silence need not mean His absence.

### Did Berkovits think the Holocaust was a punishment?

No. He rejected the idea that the victims were punished for sin. The suffering came from human evil, made possible by the freedom God gives.

### How did Berkovits see the State of Israel?

As a sign of God's presence in history, together with the survival of the Jewish people. He insisted that it does not justify or make up for the Holocaust.

### What is the main criticism of Berkovits?

That freedom may not be worth so great a price, and that the victims had no freedom at all. Others, like Richard Rubenstein, held that the traditional God of history could not be affirmed after the Holocaust.
