# How do you use the modal verbs must, should, may and might?

> Written with AI · [English grammar for the Bagrut](https://lessoons.com/en/english-grammar) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-09 · https://lessoons.com/en/english-grammar/how-to-use-modal-verbs-must-should-may-might

The modal verbs must, should, may and might come before the base form of another verb and show how sure the speaker is, or what kind of rule a sentence gives. From most to least certain: “She must be at home,” “She should be at home,” “She may be at home,” “She might be at home.” Must also gives a rule, should gives advice and may gives permission.

## The topic explained

### How modal verbs work

Modal verbs such as must, should, may and might sit in front of another verb and add the speaker's attitude to it: how sure they are, or whether the sentence is a rule, a piece of advice or a permission. Their form never changes. There is no -s for he, she or it, no to before the next verb, and the next verb is in its base form: “He must leave now,” not “He musts to leave now.”

To make a negative, add not straight after the modal: must not, should not, may not and might not, or the short forms mustn't and shouldn't. To ask a question, put the modal first: “Should I call her?” “May I come in?” A modal verb never needs do.

### From certain to possible

When you guess about the present or the future, the modal shows how sure you are. Must is for a conclusion you are almost sure of, based on evidence: “The lights are off. They must be asleep.” Should is for what you expect: “The bus left at eight, so it should arrive by nine.” May is for a real possibility: “Take a coat. It may rain later.” Might is a little less sure: “I might go to the party, but I'm not sure yet.”

For the opposite of must, a conclusion that something is impossible, English uses can't, not mustn't: “That can't be Dan. He's in Paris this week.”

### Rule, advice or permission

Must, should and may also tell people what to do. Must gives a rule or a strong duty: “You must wear a seat belt.” Should gives advice, something that is a good idea: “You should drink more water.” May gives permission in a polite or formal way: “You may leave when you finish.”

The negatives are where most mistakes happen. Must not means that something is not allowed: “You mustn't park here.” Don't have to means that it is not necessary, though you can if you like: “You don't have to bring food. Lunch is free.”

### Should have, might have, and the mistakes to avoid

To talk about the past, put have and the past participle after the modal. Should have says that something was the right thing to do but did not happen, so it often sounds like a regret or a criticism: “I should have studied harder.” Might have is a guess about the past: “She might have missed the bus.” Must have is a conclusion about the past that you are almost sure of: “He must have forgotten our meeting.”

In the unseen texts on the Bagrut, the modals show how sure the writer is. “This may explain why some birds change their routes” offers a possible reason, while “This explains why” states it as a fact.

Hebrew speakers often carry over צריך ל and write “You should to rest,” which is wrong: write “You should rest.” Another common mistake is “You mustn't come” for “לא חייבים לבוא”; the right sentence is “You don't have to come.”

## Modal verbs practice: must, should, may and might

For 10th grade students preparing for the English Bagrut. Answer the items in order, as they get harder, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Put the four modals on the scale, from the most certain to the least certain: might, must, may, should.** — From left to right: must, should, may, might.
2. **Fill in the table: does each sentence give a rule, advice or permission?** — “You must wear a helmet.” gives a rule. “You should see a doctor.” gives advice. “You may sit here.” gives permission.
3. **Choose the correct answer: “You (mustn't / don't have to) bring food. Lunch is free.”** — don't have to. Lunch is free, so bringing food is not necessary, but it is not forbidden either.
4. **Find the mistake and correct it: “You should to call your grandmother.”** — You should call your grandmother. A modal verb is followed by the base form, with no to.
5. **Choose the correct answer: “Her lights are off and her car is gone. She (must / should) be away.”** — must. The lights and the car are evidence, so the speaker is almost sure.
6. **Rewrite the sentence with should have: “I didn't take an umbrella, and I got wet.”** — I should have taken an umbrella.
7. **Explain the difference between “Dan might have missed the train.” and “Dan should have taken the earlier train.”** — The first sentence is a guess about the past: perhaps Dan missed the train, but we are not sure. The second says that Dan did not take the earlier train, and that this was a mistake.
8. **Read this sentence from a science article: “The new findings may explain why some birds change their routes.” How sure is the writer, and which word shows it?** — The writer is not sure. May presents the explanation as possible, not proven. Without it, “The new findings explain why some birds change their routes” would state it as a fact.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between must and have to?

Both express obligation. Must often comes from the speaker: “I must call my mother tonight.” Have to often reports a rule from outside: “We have to wear a uniform at school.” Must has no past form, so in the past both become had to: “I had to wait an hour.”

### Is there a difference between may and might?

For possibility they are very close, and might sounds a little less sure: “It may rain” and “It might rain” are both correct. To ask for permission, use may: “May I leave early?” In reported speech, may usually becomes might: “She said she might come.”

### What is the opposite of must?

It depends on the meaning. For a rule, the opposite is mustn't, not allowed, or don't have to, not necessary. For a conclusion, the opposite is can't: “He must be tired” against “He can't be tired. He slept all day.”

### Can you use must about the past?

Not on its own. For a rule in the past, use had to: “We had to leave at six.” For a conclusion about the past, use must have and the past participle: “The road is wet. It must have rained last night.”

### How do modal verbs help on the Bagrut?

In the unseen texts, modals show how certain the writer is, and questions about the writer's view often depend on them. Notice the difference between “This proves that” and “This might show that.” In an opinion essay, should and must help you argue a point: “Schools should start later in the morning.”
