# How do you analyze a short story for the English Bagrut?

> Written with AI · [English, five units](https://lessoons.com/en/english-five-units) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-09 · https://lessoons.com/en/english-five-units/how-to-analyze-a-short-story

To analyze a short story, state its central conflict in one sentence, trace how the main character changes from the opening to the ending, and then reread an earlier scene in the light of the ending. In many short stories the last page reveals something that changes what an earlier moment meant, and explaining that change is the heart of the analysis.

## The topic explained

### Analyzing a short story starts with the conflict

To analyze a short story, begin with its conflict: what the main character wants, and what stands in the way. The obstacle can be another person or society, an external conflict, or a feeling inside the character, an internal conflict. State the conflict in one sentence. If it takes a paragraph, you are retelling the plot, not analyzing it.

In Kate Chopin's “The Story of an Hour” (1894), Louise Mallard, a woman with “a heart trouble,” is told that her husband has been killed in a railroad accident. She weeps, then sits alone in her room and begins to whisper “Free! Body and soul free!” In one sentence: Louise grieves for her husband but feels a joy at her freedom that she cannot say aloud. Then Brently Mallard walks through the front door, alive, and she dies.

### How does the character change?

Trace the main character from the first scene to the last, and name the change in a pair of words: from grief to joy, from shame to understanding. Then ask what caused it. Louise begins as a widow in tears, discovers alone in her room that she wants a life of her own, and comes down the stairs “like a goddess of Victory,” only to see her husband open the front door.

The ending that reframes is the last sentence: “When the doctors came they said she had died of heart disease—of the joy that kills.” The doctors believe she died of joy at seeing her husband alive. The reader knows the opposite: she died at the loss of her new freedom. Now reread the opening, where everyone takes “great care” to break the news gently because of her heart. The care was for the wrong danger.

### Comparing two stories, and the mistake to avoid

To compare two stories, choose a basis first and keep to it. O. Henry's “The Gift of the Magi” (1905) is also about a marriage, and it also turns at the end: Della sells her hair to buy a chain for Jim's watch, and Jim has sold his watch to buy combs for her hair. On the basis of what the ending reveals, the two stories split: Chopin's ending reveals what a marriage cost a woman, while O. Henry's reveals that the gifts were useless and the love behind them was not.

A common mistake for Hebrew speakers is repeating the subject after who or that, as Hebrew does with שהיא: “Louise is a woman that she wants freedom” is wrong. Write “Louise is a woman who wants freedom.” Write about the story in the present simple, too: “Louise weeps,” not “Louise wept,” because the story happens again each time it is read.

## Short story practice: conflict, character and the ending

For 12th grade students preparing for the literature part of the English Bagrut. Read the story in item 1, answer each question in full sentences, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Read the story “The Window Seat”: “Every morning Noa's grandfather took the number 9 bus into the city and sat in the same seat by the window. Noa, who was sixteen, rode the same bus to school and pretended not to know him. He talked to strangers, hummed old songs and waved at children in the street. ‘Grandpa, please,’ she whispered one morning, ‘people are looking.’ He smiled, stopped humming, and for the rest of the week he sat in silence with his hands folded in his lap. On Monday he was not at the bus stop. That evening her mother told her that he had moved into a care home on the other side of the city. ‘He has known for months,’ she said. ‘His eyes are going. He wanted to see the city every day while he still could.’ The next morning Noa sat in the seat by the window. She looked at everything.” State the central conflict of the story in one sentence.** — Noa loves her grandfather but is ashamed of him in front of other people, so she pretends not to know him. It is an internal conflict, between her love and her embarrassment.
2. **Put each event from the story in item 1 on the plot line: (a) Noa asks her grandfather to stop humming. (b) Noa sits in his seat and looks at everything. (c) Noa and her grandfather ride the same bus every morning. (d) On Monday he is not at the bus stop. (e) Her mother explains why he rode the bus.** — Exposition: (c). Rising action: (a). Climax: (d). Falling action: (e). Resolution: (b).
3. **Complete the character map for Noa in the story in item 1.** — At the start: she is embarrassed by her grandfather and pretends not to know him. She wants: to look normal in front of the other passengers. What changes her: learning that he is losing his sight. At the end: she sits in his seat and looks at the city the way he did.
4. **Which earlier scene does the ending of the story in item 1 change, and how?** — The scene of the grandfather humming, talking to strangers and waving from the window. At first it seems embarrassing, as it does to Noa. After the ending we know that he was saying goodbye to a city he would soon not be able to see, and that by sitting in silence for Noa he gave up part of the joy of his last week on the bus.
5. **What does the last sentence of the story in item 1, “She looked at everything.”, show about how Noa has changed?** — Noa now does what her grandfather did: she looks at the city instead of hiding from the people on the bus. The short sentence shows that she understands him at last and has taken his place by the window.
6. **Find and correct the mistake: “Noa is a girl that she is ashamed of her grandfather.”** — Noa is a girl who is ashamed of her grandfather. The word who is already the subject of the clause, so she is not repeated.
7. **In Kate Chopin's “The Story of an Hour” (1894), a woman who is told that her husband has died realizes that she will now be free. When he walks in alive, she dies, and the doctors say she died “of the joy that kills.” Compare the ending of this story with the ending of the story in item 1 on one basis: what each ending reveals, and who learns it.** — A model answer: Both endings reveal a truth that was hidden. In “The Window Seat,” the grandfather's daily ride hid his failing eyesight, and Noa learns the truth and changes. In Chopin's story the doctors never learn it: only the reader knows that Louise died of losing her freedom, not of joy. One ending leads to understanding, while the other leaves the truth unspoken.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between internal and external conflict?

An external conflict sets a character against someone or something outside: another person, society or nature. An internal conflict happens inside the character, between two feelings or two duties. Many short stories have both, as in “The Story of an Hour,” where Louise's private joy clashes with what her world expects of a widow.

### What is a twist ending?

A twist ending turns the story at the last moment, often through situational irony: what happens is the opposite of what the reader expected. A good twist does not just surprise you; it makes you reread the earlier scenes and see them differently, and that change is what you explain in an analysis.

### Should I write about a story in the present or the past tense?

Use the present simple to write about what happens in a story: “Della sells her hair,” “Louise weeps.” The story happens again each time someone reads it. Use a past tense only for events that come before the moment you are describing.

### How do I avoid retelling the plot?

Give each sentence of plot a sentence of explanation. After “Louise whispers ‘Free!’” write what it shows: that her grief hides a wish she never admitted. If you can delete a sentence and lose no idea, it is retelling.

### How do you compare two short stories?

Choose one basis before you start, such as the conflict, the ending or the main character's change, and write about both stories on that basis in every paragraph. Use words that compare: both, while, whereas, unlike. Two separate summaries side by side are not a comparison.
