# What is tracking in education?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: education, youth and inequality](https://lessoons.com/en/education-youth-and-inequality) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/education-youth-and-inequality/what-is-tracking-in-education

Tracking in education is the sorting of students into separate groups, streams or schools by their measured ability or achievement, each with its own curriculum and pace. Sociologists study who ends up in which track and what the track does to students, because tracking can widen gaps between social groups as well as match teaching to each student.

## The topic explained

### Three forms of tracking

Tracking, also called streaming or ability grouping, divides students into groups by their measured ability or achievement, so that each group learns a different curriculum or at a different pace. It comes in three forms. Students can be sorted between schools: in Germany, achievement at the end of primary school, generally after four years, decides which type of secondary school a child attends. They can be sorted into streams inside one school, such as academic and vocational programs. And they can be sorted into levels within one subject, as when Israeli students take mathematics or English at 3, 4 or 5 study units.

Jeannie Oakes and Martin described three qualities of any tracking system: how many subjects it covers, how many levels it has, and how flexible it is, that is, whether students can move between tracks. The misreading to avoid: tracking is not only about ability. Sociologists ask what else decides a placement.

Picture Shira and Adi, who both score 78 on a 9th grade test. Shira's parents ask the school to place her in the top group and pay for extra lessons; Adi's parents do not know the request can be made. Two years later Shira studies mathematics at 5 units and Adi at 3, and the gap looks like a gap in ability.

### How tracking can reproduce inequality

In Keeping Track: How Schools Structure Inequality (1985), Jeannie Oakes reported that high-track classes were taught to think critically, while low-track classes worked mostly from workbooks. She also found poor and minority students placed in low tracks out of proportion to their ability. Once placed, students received different teaching, reached different results, and the results seemed to prove that the placement had been right.

The British sociologist Colin Lacey (1970) described a second effect, polarization. Students in top sets hear that the school values them and form a pro-school subculture; students in bottom sets, denied status, often form an anti-school subculture that wins respect by rejecting school values. Later studies found that friendships form mostly within tracks, and that low-track students were more likely to drop out. Through all these channels, tracking can turn a difference at the start into a gap at the end, which is how conflict theorists see it as part of social reproduction.

### The case for and against

Supporters, often in the functionalist tradition, argue that teachers can match the pace to the class, that strong students gain from learning together, and that vocational tracks give useful skills. Some evidence backs them: Kulik and Kulik (1992) found that high-ability students in tracked classes achieved more than similar students in untracked ones. Critics answer that the gains go to those already ahead, while low tracks get weaker teaching and lower expectations. Many researchers therefore look at the details: a flexible system that lets students move up behaves differently from a rigid one.

### Tracking in Israel

In Israel the debate is old. Critical sociologists argued that in the early decades of the state many Mizrahi students, and later many immigrants from the former Soviet Union, were directed into vocational education, which made it harder to reach university. Supporters of vocational schools answered that they opened skilled work to many students. Researchers have also pointed to tracking by gender, in the different programs that boys and girls tend to choose or are steered toward, which can shape their later roles at work and at home. On 29 July 1968 the Knesset adopted a reform that created the junior high school and aimed, among other goals, to bring children of all backgrounds into shared schools. A strong answer weighs both sides and asks how flexible the tracks are.

## Practice: tracking in education

For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Name the form of tracking in each case: (a) Noam takes English at 5 units and history at 2; (b) a city sends children to different secondary schools by their grades; (c) a high school has an academic program and a vocational program.** — (a) levels in a subject; (b) between schools; (c) streams in a school.
2. **Fill in the missing step and explain why the chain can look fair to those inside it.** — Different results. Because the results differ, the placement seems to have been correct, even if it was partly decided by background or by the teaching each group received.
3. **Complete Lacey's grid: what subculture forms in each set?** — Top set: a pro-school subculture. Bottom set: an anti-school subculture.
4. **What did Jeannie Oakes find about teaching in high and low tracks?** — High-track classes were taught to think critically, while low-track classes worked mostly from workbooks; poor and minority students were placed in low tracks out of proportion to their ability.
5. **Complete the table with the missing argument against tracking.** — Placement follows origin: who ends up in which track depends partly on class and origin, not only on ability.
6. **Explain what makes a tracking system flexible, and why flexibility matters to sociologists.** — A flexible system lets students move between tracks, for example from 4 to 5 units. It matters because it limits how far an early placement fixes a student's future.
7. **Your school is deciding whether to split 9th grade math into levels. Write a paragraph advising it, with one argument for and one against.** — A good answer gives an argument for (a pace suited to each group, gains for strong students) and one against (weaker teaching and labels in low groups, placement that follows background), and proposes a condition such as regular chances to move up.

## Common questions

### What is the difference between tracking and streaming?

None in substance. Streaming is the British word for what Americans call tracking: placing students in groups by ability or achievement. In Britain, tracking usually means recording a student's progress.

### Does tracking help strong students?

Some studies, such as Kulik and Kulik (1992), found that high-ability students in tracked classes achieved more than similar students in mixed classes. Critics answer that these gains can come at the cost of students in low tracks.

### What is detracking?

Placing students of different achievement levels in the same classes on purpose. Supporters hope it will close gaps between groups; critics worry that strong students will be held back.

### What is vocational education in sociology?

Schooling that prepares students for a trade or technical work. Sociologists ask whether it widens choice or limits it, depending on who is directed into it and whether it still leads to a bagrut and higher education.

### How is tracking linked to the self-fulfilling prophecy?

A placement is a public label. If teachers expect less of a low track and students come to believe it, the lower results that follow can confirm a label that was partly mistaken.
