# What is the Pygmalion effect in education?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: education, youth and inequality](https://lessoons.com/en/education-youth-and-inequality) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/education-youth-and-inequality/what-is-the-pygmalion-effect-in-education

The Pygmalion effect in education is the idea that a teacher's expectations of a student can change how the student does: pupils expected to succeed are treated differently and come to do better. Rosenthal and Jacobson reported it in Pygmalion in the Classroom (1968). Later research found the effect real but usually small and often temporary.

## The topic explained

### An expectation that fulfills itself

In 1948 the sociologist Robert K. Merton named the self-fulfilling prophecy: a false belief about a situation that leads people to act in ways that make it come true. His example was a sound bank that fails because a rumor that it will fail sends everyone to withdraw their money. Merton built on the Thomas theorem of 1928: if people define situations as real, they are real in their consequences.

The Pygmalion effect in education is this idea inside the classroom. A teacher who expects a pupil to succeed may, without noticing, give the pupil a warmer climate, more material, more chances to answer and more feedback. The pupil responds, and the result seems to prove the teacher right. The misreading to avoid: the effect is not about a teacher who lies or plays favorites on purpose. It works through small, everyday behavior.

### The 1968 study

Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson worked in one California elementary school. At the start of the year every pupil took an IQ test presented as a test that could spot children about to bloom intellectually. The researchers then gave teachers the names of about 20% of the pupils as future bloomers. In fact these names had been chosen at random: the only difference between the groups was in the teachers' minds. Random choice is what makes the design an experiment: since the bloomers were no different from the others at the start, a gap that opened later could be traced to the teachers' expectations, provided the test itself measured well.

When the pupils were tested again, both groups had gained in every one of the six grades. Only in the first and second grades, however, did the bloomers gain significantly more than the others. Rosenthal and Jacobson concluded that the teachers' expectations had raised the pupils' scores.

### What later research found

The study was famous and was quickly criticized. Robert Thorndike (1968) found the IQ test seriously flawed. Stephen Raudenbush (1984) combined many studies and found that when teachers had known their pupils for two weeks before hearing the false information, its effect fell to almost zero. Lee Jussim and Kent Harber (2005), reviewing 35 years of research, concluded that self-fulfilling prophecies do happen in classrooms but are usually small and temporary, and that many teacher expectations are accurate rather than self-fulfilling.

Israeli research added two findings. Dov Eden and Abraham Shani (1982) told instructors in an Israel Defense Forces course that some trainees, in fact chosen at random, had high potential, and those trainees did better on objective tests. Elisha Babad, Jacinto Inbar and Rosenthal (1982) named the reverse the Golem effect: low expectations lead to poorer results.

### Why sociologists care

For sociologists the effect is part of the interactionist view of school and close to labeling theory: what a teacher believes about a pupil can become part of the pupil. It matters most when expectations follow a pupil's class, origin or track rather than the pupil's work, because then the classroom can reproduce inequality. A strong answer explains the mechanism, cites the 1968 study and its criticism, and does not claim more than the evidence shows.

The idea also links to other parts of the course. Tracking places pupils in levels, and each level carries an expectation that teachers and pupils both learn. Bourdieu's cultural capital explains why a middle-class pupil may look promising sooner. In each case an expectation formed outside the pupil's work can shape what the pupil is later able to do.

## Practice: the Pygmalion effect

For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Define a self-fulfilling prophecy and name the sociologist who coined the term.** — A false belief that leads people to act in ways that make it come true. The term is Robert K. Merton's (1948).
2. **Which step of the cycle is missing?** — The teacher treats the pupil in line with the expectation (warmth, material, chances to answer, feedback).
3. **What did the teachers hear about the pupils in the first row, and what was the real difference between the groups?** — They heard that the pupils would bloom this year. The real difference was none: the names were chosen at random.
4. **In which grades was the extra gain of the bloomers significant?** — Only in 1st and 2nd grade.
5. **What did Raudenbush find, and what does it suggest about when the effect works?** — When teachers had known their pupils for two weeks before hearing the false information, the effect was near zero. It works mainly when a teacher knows little about the pupil yet.
6. **In a new class, a teacher reads that Noa came from a school with a low reputation and gives her easier tasks. Which effect may follow, and why?** — The Golem effect: a low expectation may lead to less challenge and less feedback, and so to poorer results, confirming the expectation.
7. **Write a paragraph weighing the Pygmalion effect: present the 1968 finding, one criticism and one Israeli study, and explain its link to inequality.** — A good answer describes the random bloomers and the gains in 1st and 2nd grade; gives a criticism (Thorndike's flawed test, Raudenbush's two weeks, or Jussim and Harber's small, temporary effects); cites Eden and Shani or the Golem effect; and explains that expectations shaped by class or origin can reproduce inequality, without claiming more than the evidence shows.

## Common questions

### Where does the name Pygmalion come from?

From the Greek myth of the sculptor Pygmalion, whose statue came to life, and George Bernard Shaw's play Pygmalion, in which a flower seller is taught to speak like a lady. Both are stories of someone becoming what another expected.

### Is the Pygmalion effect real?

Research supports it, but more weakly than the 1968 study claimed. Reviews find that teacher expectations do affect pupils, usually by a small amount and often for a short time, and that many expectations are simply accurate.

### What is the Golem effect?

The reverse of the Pygmalion effect: low expectations lead to poorer performance. Babad, Inbar and Rosenthal named it in 1982.

### What is the difference between the Pygmalion effect and the Galatea effect?

The Pygmalion effect comes from the expectations of others, such as a teacher. The Galatea effect comes from the person's own expectations of themselves, which can rise when others believe in them.

### How can teachers avoid a negative self-fulfilling prophecy?

By basing expectations on a pupil's actual work rather than on labels, files or background, and by giving every pupil challenging tasks, time to answer and feedback.
