# What are the functions of deviance according to Durkheim?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: deviance and social control](https://lessoons.com/en/deviance-and-social-control) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/deviance-and-social-control/functions-of-deviance-according-to-durkheim

For Émile Durkheim, deviance has functions: some crime is normal in every society and does it a service. Punishing it reminds members of their shared rules and draws them together, it marks the boundary between allowed and forbidden, and a few deviants open the way to new norms, as Socrates did. Only an abnormally high or low rate signals that something is wrong.

## The topic explained

### Why Durkheim called crime normal

In The Rules of Sociological Method (1895) Émile Durkheim made a claim that still surprises students: crime is normal. By normal he meant found in every society at every time, so that a society without any crime cannot exist. He did not mean good. Crime can be harmful and should be condemned, he wrote, and punishment is just as normal as crime.

His thought experiment was a society of saints, a community of exemplary people. Theft and violence would be unknown there, but faults that seem trivial elsewhere, a rude remark or a careless word, would cause the same scandal that a crime causes in an ordinary town, and would be punished as such. Every group sets a line, and some of its members will always be on the wrong side of it. The functions of deviance are what this unavoidable rule breaking does for the society around it. The misreading to avoid: Durkheim is not defending criminals; he is asking what the reaction to them achieves.

### Functions one and two: boundaries and solidarity

The first function is marking the boundary. A rule exists in people's minds; a public reaction to someone who breaks it shows everyone exactly where the line runs. The second is solidarity. In The Division of Labor in Society (1893) Durkheim argued that punishment is aimed less at the offender than at the honest majority: their shared outrage reaffirms the collective conscience, the beliefs and feelings members hold in common, and binds them together. A school that responds as one to an act of bullying teaches the whole school what it stands for.

The American sociologist Kai Erikson tested the idea in Wayward Puritans (1966). He studied the Puritan colony of Massachusetts Bay and found three waves of deviance in its first century, each arriving when the community was unsure of its identity. Its reactions, he argued, were ways of drawing the community's boundaries.

### Function three: the way to change

If the collective conscience were so strong that no one ever broke a rule, nothing could ever change. Some deviance is the first step toward new norms. Durkheim's example was Socrates, condemned in Athens in 399 BCE: under Athenian law he was a criminal, yet his crime, the independence of his thought, served humanity and helped prepare a new morality. A modern example is Rosa Parks, arrested in Montgomery, Alabama, on 1 December 1955 for refusing to give up her seat on a bus to a white passenger. She broke the law of her city, and her act helped bring an end to that law.

### Too little, too much, and the critics

Durkheim's functions hold only at a normal level. A rate far above it is pathological, a sign of anomie, a state in which norms no longer guide people. A rate far below it is no reason to celebrate either: it suggests a society so rigid that nothing new can grow.

The critics ask three questions. Functional for whom? The victims of crime are harmed whatever society gains. How much crime is normal? Durkheim gives no measure. And who sets the rules? Conflict theorists answer that the powerful do, and Erikson's own cases show that boundary drawing can turn cruel: twenty people were executed in Salem in 1692.

## Practice: Durkheim and the functions of deviance

For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **What did Durkheim mean when he called crime normal? Write two sentences, one saying what he meant and one saying what he did not mean.** — He meant that crime is found in every society at every time, and that a society without crime cannot exist. He did not mean that crime is good or should go unpunished; punishment is just as normal.
2. **Complete the table: how would a society of saints react to a rude remark?** — As a scandal, punished as a crime would be in an ordinary town. The line between allowed and forbidden moves, but there is always a line.
3. **Fill in the missing step in the cycle.** — People unite: the shared outrage at the act draws the members of the society together, and so the norm is reaffirmed.
4. **Which function of deviance does each case show? (a) After a student is caught cheating and the whole class hears the principal's response, everyone knows exactly what counts as cheating. (b) After the town's community garden is vandalized, residents of every background come together to replant it. (c) A scientist whose theory was mocked by her colleagues is proved right years later.** — (a) marking the boundary; (b) solidarity, the reaction draws people together; (c) change, a deviant idea that becomes a new norm.
5. **Name the wave of deviance missing from Erikson's timeline.** — The persecution of the Quakers, from 1656.
6. **Complete the table: what does a crime rate far above the normal level mean for Durkheim?** — It is pathological, a sign of anomie: the norms no longer guide people.
7. **Read the passage: “A town that punishes rule breakers only becomes more united.” Write a paragraph weighing the claim, using Durkheim and one criticism.** — A good answer explains Durkheim's view that punishment reaffirms the collective conscience and binds members together, then gives a criticism: victims are harmed, the theory does not say how much crime is normal, conflict theorists ask who makes the rules, and Erikson's Salem case shows boundary drawing can become persecution. It ends with a balanced judgment.

## Common questions

### Did Durkheim think crime was good?

No. He called crime normal, meaning that every society has it, and useful, meaning that the reaction to it does things for society. He wrote that crime should still be condemned and that punishment is as normal as crime itself.

### What is the collective conscience?

Durkheim's term for the beliefs and feelings that the members of a society hold in common. Crime offends it, and the public reaction to crime renews it, which is why he saw punishment as a source of solidarity.

### What is boundary maintenance?

The idea that the public reaction to deviance shows members where the limits of acceptable behavior lie. Kai Erikson developed it in Wayward Puritans (1966), a study of the Puritan colony of Massachusetts Bay.

### What is the main criticism of the functionalist view of deviance?

That it asks what deviance does for society and forgets whom it harms and who makes the rules. Critics add that Durkheim gives no way to measure how much crime is normal.

### How is Durkheim different from Merton on deviance?

Durkheim asked what deviance does for society. Robert Merton (1938) asked why some people deviate more than others, and answered with the strain between the goals a culture sets and the means it offers to reach them.
