# What are Kohlberg's stages of moral development?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: development across the life span](https://lessoons.com/en/developmental-psychology) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-12 · https://lessoons.com/en/developmental-psychology/what-are-kohlbergs-stages-of-moral-development

Kohlberg's stages of moral development are six stages of moral reasoning in three levels: pre-conventional (avoiding punishment, then self-interest), conventional (approval, then law and order) and post-conventional (social contract, then universal principles). Lawrence Kohlberg (1958) scored not whether people said yes or no to a dilemma but why, and argued that everyone climbs the stages in the same order.

## The topic explained

### The reason, not the answer

Lawrence Kohlberg, an American psychologist, built on Piaget's work on children's moral judgment. For his 1958 doctoral study at the University of Chicago he interviewed 72 Chicago boys aged 10, 13 and 16 about moral dilemmas. The best known is the Heinz dilemma: a woman is dying of cancer; a druggist has a drug that might save her but charges $2,000, ten times what it costs him; her husband Heinz can raise only about $1,000. Should Heinz steal the drug?

Kohlberg's key move was to score the reasoning, not the decision. "Yes, steal it" and "no, don't" can each be given at any stage; what changes is why. A child who says "don't steal, you'll go to prison" and an adult who says "don't steal, the law protects everyone's rights" give the same answer at very different stages.

### Three levels, six stages

At the pre-conventional level, typical of children, right and wrong are judged by consequences for oneself. Stage 1: obey to avoid punishment. Stage 2: self-interest and fair exchange, "you help me, I'll help you." At the conventional level, which most adolescents and adults reach, morality means living up to the expectations of others and society. Stage 3: be a good person in the eyes of family and friends, seeking approval. Stage 4: law and order, doing one's duty so that society can function.

At the post-conventional level people judge laws by principles. Stage 5: laws are a social contract that can be changed when they fail to protect rights and welfare. Stage 6: universal ethical principles, such as justice and human dignity, which a person follows even against the law. Kohlberg found stage 6 so rarely that he later stopped scoring it.

### What the evidence says

Kohlberg's team re-interviewed the boys for 20 years, and Colby and colleagues (1983) reported that they moved through the stages in order, without skipping. Snarey (1985) reviewed 45 studies in 27 countries, among them a longitudinal study of adolescents on Israeli kibbutzim (1969–1978), and found the early stages widely, while the highest stages were rare and took different forms in different cultures. The common mistake is to treat a stage as a label for a person; Kohlberg scored reasoning, and a person can reason at different stages about different questions.

### Gilligan and other criticisms

Carol Gilligan, a colleague of Kohlberg, argued in In a Different Voice (1982) that the theory was built on boys and measures only an ethics of justice, rules and rights. Many people, and in her research many women, reason through an ethics of care, attending to relationships and to the needs of the people involved, which Kohlberg's scoring could mistake for a lower stage. Later meta-analyses (Walker 1984; Jaffee and Hyde 2000) found only small differences between the sexes in moral reasoning, but Gilligan's point that care is a full moral orientation was widely accepted.

Two further criticisms: the theory measures reasoning about hypothetical dilemmas, which does not always predict what people do, and Jonathan Haidt has argued that people often decide by intuition and find reasons afterwards. A strong answer places a piece of reasoning at its stage, explains why the reason counts, and adds one criticism with its evidence.

## Practice: Kohlberg's stages of moral development

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from the page, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Fill in the names of stages 2 and 4, and the level each belongs to.** — Stage 2: self-interest (fair exchange), pre-conventional. Stage 4: law and order (social order and duty), conventional.
2. **Write the level of each reason given in the Heinz dilemma.** — So he won't be punished: pre-conventional (stage 1). Society needs laws: conventional (stage 4). Life over profit: post-conventional (stage 5 or 6).
3. **Why did Kohlberg score the reason and not the decision? Give an example.** — Because the same decision can come from very different reasoning. "Don't steal, you'll be punished" (stage 1) and "don't steal, the law protects everyone" (stage 4) give the same answer at different stages.
4. **A 16-year-old says: "I wouldn't cheat on the test, my parents would be so disappointed in me." Which stage is this? Explain.** — Stage 3, conventional: the reason is to be seen as a good person by people who matter to her and to keep their approval.
5. **Fill in Gilligan's column.** — Morality is about care and relationships. Good reasoning responds to the needs of the people involved.
6. **What did the 20-year follow-up of Kohlberg's sample find, and why does it matter for the theory?** — The boys moved through the stages in order without skipping (Colby et al. 1983). It supports the claim that the stages form an invariant sequence, which is the core of a stage theory.
7. **Evaluate Kohlberg's theory: one strength and two criticisms, each with evidence.** — A good answer gives a strength (the stages appear in order over 20 years, Colby et al. 1983; early stages found in many cultures, Snarey 1985) and two criticisms (built on boys and a justice orientation, Gilligan 1982; highest stages culture-specific, Snarey 1985; reasoning does not always predict action; intuition may come first, Haidt), and concludes.

## Common questions

### What is the Heinz dilemma?

It is Kohlberg's best-known moral dilemma. Heinz's wife is dying, a druggist charges $2,000 for a drug that might save her, ten times its cost, and Heinz can raise only about $1,000. People are asked whether Heinz should steal the drug, and why.

### Does everyone reach the highest stage?

No. Most adolescents and adults reason at the conventional level, stages 3 and 4. Stage 5 is less common, and Kohlberg found stage 6 so rarely that he stopped scoring it.

### How is Kohlberg different from Piaget on moral development?

Piaget described two broad phases of children's moral judgment, from obeying fixed rules to understanding that rules are agreements. Kohlberg extended the idea into six stages that continue through adolescence and adulthood.

### Is Kohlberg's theory biased against women?

Gilligan argued that it was, because it was built on boys and valued justice over care. Later meta-analyses found only small differences between men and women in moral reasoning, but her idea of an ethics of care became part of the field.

### Does moral reasoning predict moral behavior?

Only partly. People who reason at higher stages are somewhat more likely to act on principle, but situations, emotions and intuitions also shape behavior, so reasoning about a dilemma and acting in real life are not the same.
