# What are the attachment styles in Ainsworth's strange situation?

> Written with AI · [Psychology: development across the life span](https://lessoons.com/en/developmental-psychology) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/developmental-psychology/what-are-ainsworths-attachment-styles

Mary Ainsworth's strange situation sorts infants of about one year into attachment styles by how they react when a parent leaves and returns: secure (upset, then soothed at the reunion), avoidant (ignores the parent), and resistant or ambivalent (clings and resists). Main and Solomon (1990) added a fourth, disorganized. The styles describe a relationship, not a child's fixed character.

## The topic explained

### Attachment and the strange situation

John Bowlby (1907–1990) argued that babies are born ready to seek closeness to a caregiver, because staying close kept infants alive; he called the bond attachment (Attachment, 1969). Harry Harlow (1958) gave support from rhesus monkeys: infants spent most of their time clinging to a soft cloth figure rather than to a wire one that gave milk, so comfort, not food alone, builds the bond. Those experiments caused the monkeys severe distress and would not be allowed today.

Mary Ainsworth (1913–1999) measured the bond in the strange situation, a laboratory procedure of eight episodes of about three minutes each, first fully reported by Ainsworth and Bell (1970) with 56 one-year-olds. Observers watch how the baby explores with the parent as a secure base, reacts to a stranger and to separation, and above all what the baby does at the two reunions.

### Three styles, then a fourth

A secure baby explores, may cry when the parent leaves, and at the reunion goes to the parent and calms quickly. An avoidant baby shows little upset and turns away at the reunion; heart-rate studies later showed that such babies are aroused all the same. A resistant (ambivalent) baby is very distressed, and at the reunion both clings and pushes away, hard to soothe. Ainsworth's team published these three in Patterns of Attachment (1978).

Mary Main and Judith Solomon (1990) added disorganized attachment for babies who show no consistent strategy: they freeze, or approach the parent with their face turned away. The common mistake is to judge by crying. Secure babies also cry; what separates the styles is what happens at the reunion.

### Across cultures, and in Israel

Marinus van IJzendoorn and Pieter Kroonenberg (1988) combined 32 samples, 1,990 infants from eight countries: 65% were secure, 21% avoidant and 14% resistant. Secure was the most common style in every country, but a North German sample had more avoidant babies and Japanese samples more resistant ones, perhaps because a Japanese baby left alone with a stranger meets something unusual. The differences within one country were about 1.5 times those between countries.

Israel has a famous case. On some kibbutzim babies slept in a communal children's house, a practice that has since ended. Abraham Sagi and colleagues (1994) compared 48 kibbutz infants: 80% of those who slept at home were secure with their mothers, against 48% of those who slept communally, with no difference in temperament between the groups.

### What the styles predict, and what they do not

A style belongs to a relationship: a toddler can be secure with one parent and not with the other (Main and Weston, 1981). It is moderately stable, and it changes when a family's circumstances change (Fraley, 2002). Critics add that 20 minutes in a laboratory is a narrow window, that a baby's temperament may play a part, and that one procedure may not mean the same in every culture. A style is not a diagnosis, of a child or of a parent. If reading about attachment raises worries about your own relationships, the school counselor or a psychologist is the person to talk to.

## Practice: attachment styles and the strange situation

For 11th grade psychology students. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **What did John Bowlby argue about why babies form attachments?** — That babies are born ready to seek closeness to a caregiver, because staying close to a caregiver kept infants safe and alive.
2. **Fill in the three missing episodes of the strange situation.** — 3: a stranger joins the parent and the baby. 5: the parent returns and the stranger leaves (the first reunion). 7: the stranger returns while the baby is alone.
3. **Fill in what the avoidant and the resistant baby do at the reunion.** — Avoidant: ignores or turns away from the parent. Resistant: clings to the parent and at the same time pushes away, and is hard to soothe.
4. **Classify each baby. Dana cries when her father leaves; when he returns she reaches for him and is playing again within a minute. Omer barely looks up when his mother leaves or when she returns. Yael screams when her mother leaves and, when she returns, holds on while kicking her.** — Dana: secure. Omer: avoidant. Yael: resistant (ambivalent).
5. **In Harlow's study, infant monkeys spent most of their time on a cloth figure, not on the wire figure that gave milk. What does this show about attachment?** — That attachment is built by comfort and contact, not by feeding alone. Harlow's monkeys were badly harmed, and such a study would not be allowed today.
6. **Read the chart. Which style was most common across the eight countries, and give one reason why a Japanese sample might show more resistant babies.** — Secure, at 65%. Japanese babies at the time were rarely separated from their mothers, so being left with a stranger was unusually stressful, and the procedure may not mean the same thing there.
7. **In the kibbutz study of Sagi and colleagues (1994), 80% of infants who slept at home were secure, against 48% of infants who slept communally. What does the result suggest, and what is one limit of the study?** — It suggests that nighttime care by the parent matters for secure attachment; the gap was 32 percentage points. Limits: only 48 infants, and families were not assigned at random to a sleeping arrangement, so other differences between the kibbutzim may play a part.
8. **A student writes: the strange situation shows what kind of adult a baby will become. Write a paragraph evaluating the claim.** — A good answer says the style describes one relationship at one time, that a toddler can differ with each parent, that attachment is only moderately stable and changes with circumstances, and that the procedure is short and may not mean the same in every culture.

## Common questions

### What is the most common attachment style?

Secure attachment. In the meta-analysis of van IJzendoorn and Kroonenberg (1988), 65% of 1,990 infants from eight countries were secure, and secure was the most common style in every country studied.

### Can an attachment style change?

Yes. Attachment is only moderately stable from infancy onward, and it is more likely to change when a family's circumstances change, for better or for worse. A style measured at one year is a starting point, not a fixed trait.

### Is avoidant attachment a disorder?

No. Avoidant, resistant and secure are patterns of behavior seen in ordinary babies in a laboratory procedure, not diagnoses. Attachment disorders are separate clinical conditions, diagnosed only by professionals.

### What is the difference between Bowlby and Ainsworth?

Bowlby built the theory: babies are born ready to seek closeness to a caregiver, who becomes a secure base. Ainsworth measured it: she designed the strange situation and described the secure, avoidant and resistant styles.

### Do adult attachment styles come from the strange situation?

They grew out of the same theory, but adult styles are measured differently, by interviews and questionnaires about close relationships. Online quizzes that label a person's attachment style are not a psychological assessment.
