# What is cultural lag in sociology?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: culture, norms and groups](https://lessoons.com/en/culture-norms-and-groups) · Grade 10 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/culture-norms-and-groups/what-is-cultural-lag-in-sociology

In sociology, cultural lag is the delay between a change in material culture, such as a new technology, and the change in non-material culture, the norms, laws and values, that adjusts to it. The American sociologist William F. Ogburn named it in 1922. During the lag, people use the new tool under old rules, and problems appear that no rule yet answers.

## The topic explained

### What cultural lag means

Sociologists divide culture into two parts. Material culture is the things a society makes and uses: tools, machines, buildings, phones. Non-material culture is the ideas that guide how people live with those things: values, norms, laws and beliefs. The American sociologist William F. Ogburn noticed that the two parts rarely change at the same speed. In Social Change with Respect to Culture and Original Nature (1922) he argued that material culture usually changes first and faster, while norms and laws resist change and follow later. He called the gap between them cultural lag. Ogburn's best-known illustration was the car: cars became faster and more common before roads and the rules of the road had adjusted to them, and the years in between brought problems that no rule yet answered.

The misreading to avoid: cultural lag does not mean that a society, or some of its people, are backward. It describes two parts of the same culture moving at different speeds, and the period of confusion in between.

### Ogburn's own case: accidents in the factory

One of Ogburn's cases came from the industrial age. Machines filled the factories, and accidents at work became far more common. The law did not keep up. Under the old rules of negligence, an injured worker could usually sue only the fellow worker whose mistake had caused the injury, and that worker was almost always too poor to pay. In practice, injured workers received nothing. Several decades passed between the rise of the factories and the arrival of workers' compensation laws, which made employers pay for injuries at work. For Ogburn this delay was the lag at work: the machines were new, the law about them was old.

Notice the order of the steps, because it is the order of every case of cultural lag: a new object, a problem the object creates, an old rule that fails to solve it, a period of harm and argument, and at last a new rule. A full answer in an exam names each step in its own case.

### A case from today: the phone in the classroom

Take Noa's school. Within a few years almost every student carried a smartphone, with a camera and a class group chat in it. That is the material change. The non-material side came slowly: when may a phone be used in class, may a student film a teacher or another student, what may be written in the group chat, and who is responsible when someone is hurt there? For a while each teacher made up an answer, and quarrels filled the gap. Only later did the school write rules, and norms about filming and sharing began to settle. Even then the lag did not end at once: a written rule is one thing, and a norm that students themselves keep is another.

To analyze a case, separate the object from the rules and values about it, then ask which came first and what went wrong in between.

### What the idea leaves out

Critics raise three points. First, the idea can slide into technological determinism, the view that technology drives everything. Ogburn himself allowed that ideas can change first, and they often do: safety and environmental laws shape which cars are built. Second, calling a norm behind is a judgment: someone decides what the right adjustment is, and others may think the slower norm is the wiser one. Third, a lag is hard to measure, since it is not clear when it begins or ends. A strong answer uses the idea to describe a gap and keeps these limits in mind. It may also note that a lag is not always harmful: the delay gives a society time to argue about what the right rules should be.

## Practice: cultural lag

For 10th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Sort into material and non-material culture: (a) an electric scooter; (b) a law on helmets for riders; (c) the belief that phones should be off at dinner; (d) a hospital scanner; (e) a school rule on photographing others.** — Material: (a) and (d). Non-material: (b), (c) and (e), since a law, a belief and a rule are ideas about how to use things.
2. **What is the name of the shaded gap between the two curves?** — Cultural lag: the time between the change in technology and the change in norms and laws that follows it.
3. **Fill in the missing step in Ogburn's factory case.** — Old law: sue a co-worker. The injured worker could sue only the fellow worker at fault, who could not pay, so the injured received nothing.
4. **Complete the table: write the non-material question raised by each material change.** — A camera in every pocket raises may I film a teacher? (or another person); the class group chat raises who may write there? and what may be written.
5. **Imagine a city where electric scooters spread within two years, and rules on where to ride, helmets and age are written only afterwards. Explain the case in the terms of cultural lag.** — The scooter is the change in material culture. The rules on lanes, helmets and minimum age are non-material culture. The years in between, when riders used the new vehicle under old traffic rules, are the cultural lag.
6. **Complete the table: which criticism says that a lag is a matter of opinion?** — Behind whom? Calling a norm behind is a judgment: someone decides what the right adjustment is.
7. **Students now use AI chatbots for homework, and schools are still deciding what is allowed. Write a paragraph that applies cultural lag to the case and adds one criticism.** — A good answer names the chatbot as the material change and the rules on honest work as the non-material culture still being written, describes the confusion in between, and adds a criticism, such as that calling the rules behind is a judgment or that values may shape how the tools are built.

## Common questions

### Who came up with the idea of cultural lag?

The American sociologist William F. Ogburn, in his book Social Change with Respect to Culture and Original Nature, published in 1922. He argued that norms and laws usually adjust to new technology only after a delay.

### What is the difference between material and non-material culture?

Material culture is the physical things a society makes and uses, such as tools, machines and buildings. Non-material culture is its ideas: values, norms, laws, beliefs and language, which guide how people use those things.

### What is a simple example of cultural lag?

Smartphones spread through schools within a few years, but rules about using them in class, filming other people and behaving in group chats came later. The years of confusion in between are cultural lag.

### Is cultural lag the same as technological determinism?

Not quite. Technological determinism says technology drives social change. Cultural lag says technology often changes first and norms follow, but Ogburn allowed that ideas can change first too. Critics say the idea still leans toward determinism.

### Is cultural lag always a bad thing?

It usually brings confusion and some harm, as in the factory accidents before compensation laws. But the delay can also give a society time to argue about what the right rules are, so a fast new rule is not always a better one.
