# What are the substitution and income effects of a price change?

> Written with AI · [Consumer choice: utility, budgets and demand](https://lessoons.com/en/consumer-choice) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/consumer-choice/what-are-the-substitution-and-income-effects-of-a-price-change

When a good's price falls, its quantity changes for two reasons. The substitution effect: the good is now cheaper than its substitutes, so buyers switch toward it. The income effect: the same income now buys more, so buyers are richer in real terms. For a normal good both effects raise the quantity; for an inferior good the income effect works the other way.

## The topic explained

### One price change, two effects

A change in price does two things at once, and economists separate them to see why demand behaves as it does. Suppose the price of pasta falls. First, pasta is now cheaper compared with rice, bread and other foods, so a buyer swaps some of them for pasta: the substitution effect. Second, the buyer's income now goes further, as if she had received a raise: the income effect.

The substitution effect always pushes toward the good that became cheaper, and away from the good that became dearer. The income effect depends on the good: a richer buyer buys more of a normal good and less of an inferior good, one people move away from as they can afford better, such as the cheapest brand of a food.

### A worked example: Dana's pasta

Dana buys 10 kg of pasta a month at ₪10 a kilogram (numbers made up for this page). The price falls to ₪8. Her old basket now costs 10 × (10 - 8) = 20 shekels less, so the price cut is worth about ₪20 a month of extra income to her.

To find the substitution effect, imagine taking those ₪20 away from her, so she can just afford her old basket at the new prices. Because pasta is now relatively cheap, she would still switch toward it: say from 10 to 12 kg, a substitution effect of +2. Then give the ₪20 back: as a richer buyer of a normal good, she buys one kilogram more, an income effect of +1. The total change is 2 + 1 = 3, from 10 kg to 13 kg.

### Normal, inferior and Giffen goods

For an inferior good the two effects pull in opposite directions after a price fall: substitution +2, income -1, total +1. The buyer still buys more, because the substitution effect is usually the stronger, and so the demand curve still slopes down.

A Giffen good would be the exception: an inferior good with no close substitutes that takes so much of a poor household's budget that the income effect outweighs the substitution effect, +1 - 2 = -1. Then a price fall reduces the quantity, and a price rise increases it. The name comes from Robert Giffen, to whom Alfred Marshall credited the idea in his Principles of Economics. Real cases are rare and debated: in a 2008 study, Robert Jensen and Nolan Miller found Giffen behavior for rice among very poor households in Hunan, China, but weaker evidence for wheat in Gansu.

### Common mistakes

Calling every inferior good a Giffen good: most inferior goods still obey the law of demand. Thinking the income effect needs a change in salary: it comes from the price change itself, through what the same shekels can buy. Giving the substitution effect a sign that depends on the good: it is always toward the cheaper good. And confusing this with a shift of demand: both effects are a movement along one demand curve, because only the price changed.

## Practice: substitution and income effects

For 11th grade economics students. Use the tables and the bar chart on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Define the substitution effect and the income effect of a price change.** — Substitution effect: the change in quantity because the good became cheaper or dearer relative to other goods. Income effect: the change in quantity because the buyer's real income changed with the price.
2. **The price of rice rises from ₪6 to ₪8 a kilogram for a family that buys 15 kg a month. How much more would its old basket cost?** — 15 × (8 - 6) = 30 shekels a month.
3. **Complete the total column in the table for a price rise.** — Normal good: -3 + (-1) = -4 kg. Inferior good: -3 + 1 = -2 kg.
4. **Read the bar chart for pasta. What is Dana's new quantity if she bought 10 kg before?** — 10 + 2 + 1 = 13 kg.
5. **Write the kind of good, normal, inferior or Giffen, beside each reaction in the table.** — Both effects add up: normal. Buys a bit more because income pulls back: inferior. Buys less: Giffen.
6. **Why does the demand curve slope down for most inferior goods?** — Because the substitution effect, toward the cheaper good, is usually larger than the opposite income effect, so the total effect of a price fall is still an increase.
7. **Write a short paragraph: what conditions would a good need to be a Giffen good, and why are such goods rare?** — A good answer names an inferior good, few close substitutes and a large share of a poor household's budget, so the income effect outweighs the substitution effect; this mix is rare, which is why evidence is limited, such as the 2008 Hunan rice study.

## Common questions

### Is the substitution effect always negative?

Measured against the price, yes: when a good's own price rises, the substitution effect always lowers the quantity bought, and when it falls, it always raises it.

### What is an inferior good?

A good people buy less of when their income rises, because they switch to better options, such as the cheapest brand of a food or a long bus trip instead of a taxi.

### What is the difference between an inferior good and a Giffen good?

Every Giffen good is inferior, but very few inferior goods are Giffen. A Giffen good is one whose income effect is so strong that it outweighs the substitution effect.

### Is a Giffen good the same as a luxury bought because it is expensive?

No. A luxury bought for its high price is a different idea. A Giffen good is a cheap staple of the poor, bought more when its price rises because the household can no longer afford dearer food.

### How is this asked on the bagrut?

Students split a change in quantity into its two effects, state the direction of each for a normal and an inferior good, and explain when a demand curve could slope upward.
